10 Houses Under $50,000: February 2014 Edition: Part 1

It’s a snowy morning here in New York — the perfect weather in which to cozy up and take in some inexpensive old house beauty. There are some serious showstoppers (and some to-die-for porches) in today’s round-up of 10 incredible old houses for sale for under $50,000. So put your dreaming cap on, and read on!


717 E Broadway St, Yazoo City, MS

Yazoo! What a fantastic name for a city. Even more fantastic is this absolutely charming cottage for only $35,000. Look how sweet the porch is! I love the front door and subtle dtails inside, like the archway and the staircase.

21825 Creamery Dr, Houston, MN

SWOON. I love snow. Have you ever seen a more photogenic fixer-upper? This c. 1888 house sits on a 3.75-acre property, according to the listing, “along Riceford Creek with farmhouse outbuildings and the old Yucatan creamery. Great opportunity for a country retreat with trout stream access.” How idyllic.

647 W Wilford St, Grafton, WV

WOW. This might be my favorite today. West Virginia, where have you been all my life? I’ve found so many cheap historic houses there that I’ve devoted three of today’s ten to the Mountain State. This house is just a delight, inside and out. Hardwood floors, original woodwork, wraparound porch… the list goes on and on and on. I just love the windows at the very top of this house. Can any locals shed some more insight on the location?

325 5th St, Syracuse, NE

If you’re anything like me, you have dreams of owning a little house close to town and operating a small business out of a storefront on an historic main street. This beauty in Syracuse, Nebraska, can make that happen. According to the listing, it was built in 1886 as the Bank of Syracuse and still contains the original historical bank sign, safe and cashier’s oak door. So fun! “Original tin tiles and tin crown molding decorate the ceilings. Exposed brick walls and limestone floor in the vault area along with original hardwood flooring make up the original portion of the building.”

316 W Georgia Ave, McComb, MS

The porch! There is just SO MUCH to love here. Clearly this is in need of some work, but many details appear to survive from this home’s glory days. How absolutely charming.

1114 16th St, Parkersburg, WV

The interior photos of this house don’t reveal much, but this house’s exterior just screams good ol’ fashioned Americana. I just love the way it sits up on a small hill. See what I mean about West Virginia?

315 W 12th St, Pueblo, CO

I nearly scrolled right past this house originally, but I’m certainly glad I looked past the so-so-exterior and checked out the inside. That staircase! The listing says this one is located in downtown Pueblo, but that it’s suffering from “substantial cracking and settling.” Alas, you can “bring all offers.” Which means you could probably scour this beauty for even LESS than the $24,900 asking price. I’d pay that just to have those windows in my house.

247 Forest Ave, Jamestown, NY

This house is $9,500. Which means that if you drank one less cup of Starbucks coffee each week, you could save up the down payment within a year. I wish there were interior photos, but my assumption is that it’s in need of a lot of work. But who cares? The outside is amazing! Look at that circular window!

223 N Main St, Hope, KS

Cute-as-a-button, perfectly-proportioned cottage in Hope, Kansas. Hope!

444 Indiana Ave, Chester, WV

West Virginia strikes again! This time, we’re looking at a Queen Anne home with an original slate roof and a decorative mantel or two. Let’s also appreciate how the last name of the property’s listing agent is Greathouse.
And that’s a wrap! What’s your favorite?
Elizabeth is the founder of CIRCA and a practicing writer, architectural historian and preservation consultant living in Brooklyn, NY. Elizabeth has loved historic houses for as long as she can remember, having grown up in an 1850’s Greek Revival gem that was lovingly restored by her parents. Elizabeth, her husband Ethan and their beagle Banjo remain on a relentless hunt for their perfect “Thanksgiving house.”

Join The Discussion

4 thoughts on “10 Houses Under $50,000: February 2014 Edition: Part 1”

  • Lisa

    I used to go to Lake Grafton, WV as a kid. It’s a beautiful, remote, deep lake. WV houses are often the perfect example of preservation by poverty. Because the owners could not afford to “upgrade” their property through the years, many houses remained unchanged. There are many treasures in this much maligned state.

  • Amanda Davis

    I also thought “Yazoo!” when I saw that listing! Great house – love the arched cove. Cute Syracuse, NE store, too. Does the fabric come with the sale? 😉

  • CIRCAhouses

    Amanda, I’m sure you could negotiate it!

  • Emily Bruner Dean

    My boyfriend and I just bought the house from Pueblo, CO. We were so excited to find this article when we googled the address. So glad someone saw the potential that we did 🙂

Compare listings

Follow us @cheapoldhouses + launching on HGTV & Discovery+, Monday, August 9th at 9pm ET