Search

Converted Houses for Sale

Converted Churches, Lighthouses & Other Unconventional Houses for Sale

Because Boring Houses Rarely Make History.

Normalcy is SO overrated. And who ever said a house had to be a house, anyway? Get quirky living in a converted lighthouse, an old mill, or a church reborn as a big, old mansion. Now THAT’s making a STATEMENT.

c. 1782
  • Fleetwood, Pennsylvania
  • $400,000

Welcome to 3811 Pricetown Road in Ruscombmanor Township. This Oley Valley Schools 1760’s Cape Cod style home was once a church in earlier times and converted to residential use with some of the original pews still being used on the covered front porch. Step inside to see the perfect blend of old world charm and […]

c. 1851
  • Waterford, Virginia
  • $599,000

Nestled in the charming VILLAGE OF WATERFORD, VIRGINIA, this stunning converted barn offers a unique blend of rustic elegance and modern convenience– and a motivated seller. Built around 1851 and remodeled as an open floor plan home for over 30 years, this newly upgraded residence boasts a rich history, evidenced by its original exposed beams […]

c. 1850
  • Winchester, Massachusetts
  • $3,450,000

Introducing 18 Ridge Street — a masterfully restored and reimagined Greek Revival residence where timeless architectural beauty meets elevated modern luxury. Set on a beautifully landscaped 20,654 sq ft lot, this exceptional 5-bedroom, 5 full and 1 half bath home offers over 5,200 square feet of exquisitely curated living space designed for both sophisticated entertaining […]

Step inside Unit 203 and feel the charm of Edenton’s past wrapped in modern comfort. Once the heartbeat of a bustling cotton mill, this beautifully restored landmark now offers a lifestyle that blends history, character, and ease; this condo captures that spirit from the moment you enter. Every detail of the layout is designed to make […]

c. 1730
  • Halifax, Massachusetts
  • $675,000

HISTORY MEETS MODERN COMFORT. Enjoy peace of mind with a NEW roof (2024), full upstairs bath remodel (2025), new water main/plumbing updates (2025), recent foundation work, and fresh paint (2026). Built c.1791 on the original late-1600s Deacon David Bosworth farm, this center-chimney Cape perfectly blends historic soul with essential updates. Once serving as Halifax’s original […]

c. 1940
  • Saratoga Springs, New York
  • $2,399,900

Limited opportunities remain! Units 1, 3, and 5 are still available. Contact us today to schedule your private tour! This grand Tudor style building was established in 1940 & later became the Waldorf School of Saratoga Springs. Now it’s taken on a brand-new life. Inside the brick & Tudor walls are newly constructed luxurious high-end […]

c. 1938
  • Thomasville, North Carolina
  • $300,000

Exciting adaptive reuse opportunity in Thomasville’s vibrant downtown historic district! The monumentally-scaled 1938 Art Deco building offers exuberant architectural detailing inside and out. Commercial zoning awaits your creative vision including mixed-use projects that will add to the vitality of this downtown location. Architectural and Historical Information Built in 1938 with funding from the Public Works […]

c. 1845
  • Middletown Springs, Vermont
  • $749,000

1840’s Converted Post & Beam Barn to Home (2005)  VisitHigherGround.com for full listing. 4 Acres, 3+B/3.5B, 2,100 sq. ft. Private well (tested pure) + Spring Access · No Zoning/waste water permit possible for ADU. $749,000 FSBO Description: South-facing view of valley, organic flat meadow, wood lot, raised garden beds, grape vines, stone walls, old maples, […]

c. 1985
  • Willow, New York
  • $3,325,000

More than a century in the making, and unlike anything else on the market, this extraordinary multi-residential estate began as a historic Hudson Valley farm before being thoughtfully transformed into a modern lifestyle retreat of remarkable scale and character. Over the years, musicians, entrepreneurs, and creative thinkers have called it home. Prior to that, it […]

c. 1812
  • Winchester, Virginia
  • $370,000

This is a unique opportunity to purchase a piece of history. The Glass Mill (Glass/Rinker/Cooper Mill) is available. The Mill was constructed during the years 1812-1815. At the base, the structure has stone walls that are 3’ thick, tapering to about half that at the gable ends. The Mill has a ”mechanics level”, the lower […]

There’s a quiet sense of history the moment you arrive at this remarkable property. It was once the former Mount Crawford General Store. The large addition dates back to 1840. Every space tells a story while remaining comfortable for modern living. Inside, 9-foot ceilings in the primary bedroom, dining room, and living room create an […]

c. 1863
  • West Chester, Pennsylvania
  • $875,000

UNDER CONTRACT on 6/8/26! Here we go once again with yet another Magical History Tour!   Since I have been sharing a few listings recently in Chester and Delaware counties, I think I’ll skip the historical narrative about William Penn and the original land grants.   So let’s go straight into the lovely & rural […]