Compare Listings

Converted

Houses

for Sale

Converted Churches, Lighthouses,

and Other Unconventional

Houses for Sale

Because Boring Houses Rarely Make History.

Normalcy is SO overrated. And who ever said a house had to be a house, anyway? Get quirky living in a converted lighthouse, an old mill, or a church reborn as a big, old mansion. Now THAT’s making a STATEMENT.

c. 1849

Iconic Renovated Church with Stunning River Views c. 1850

  • Essex, Connecticut
  • $1,295,000

Check out the Virtual Tour here! The much admired, iconic historic former circa 1850 renovated church property at the crest of Methodist Hill with stunning views of the Connecticut River […]

c. 1902

1900s Hardware Store with Apartment, River View, Antique Store, Barber Shop, Nature Trail

  • Cairo, West Virginia
  • $49,500

PLEASE READ ALL THE WAY TO THE BOTTOM 🙂 This building seriously has everything – rolling wooden library ladders, original fixtures, ornate wood and glass cabinetry, lofted filigreed tin ceilings, […]

c. 1922

Chimbley House – Historic Orchid Greenhouse Renovated into Elegant Home

  • Southern Pines, North Carolina
  • $1,400,000

Circa 1922 , Chimbley House was constructed of terra cotta and stucco. It has been completely renovated into an elegant home perfect for entertaining. There is a gourmet kitchen, 5 […]

c. 1937

Gorgeous Redesigned Barn on Almost 7 Acres

  • South Bend, Indiana
  • $840,000

Check out the Virtual Tour here! OWN A PIECE OF HISTORY AS YOU STEP BACK IN TIME TO A PERIOD OF GRACE AND OPULENCE. $500K RECENT REMODEL ADDS ALL THE […]

c. 1880

The Free Liberty United Church – UNDER CONTRACT

  • Pinebluff, North Carolina
  • $30,000

Calling for creativity! This quaint but spacious church situated in the restive sandhills region among native longleaf pines would make a perfect artist retreat or weekend getaway.  Located only about […]

c. 1908

Carnegie Library Awaiting Reuse

  • Conneaut, Ohio
  • $132,500

GRAND OLD BUILDING. Built by Andrew Carnegie in 1908. A lot of possibilities. Just waiting for someone to breathe some life back into it.

c. 1891

The Mayodan Hotel

  • Mayodan, North Carolina
  • $79,000

Unique 3-story inn in picturesque Mayodan!  Situated in a prime downtown location near the scenic Mayo River, the Mayodan Hotel has played a prominent role in town with its origins […]

c. 1897

Unique Renovated Church with Gorgeous Details

  • Senoia, Georgia
  • $510,000

Originally a church, built in the 1890s, this unique renovated home has kept all of its original charm, while offering updated features and a functional floorplan. Original stained glass windows […]

c. 1951

The Dunbar School

  • Lexington, North Carolina
  • $310,000

Mid-century Modernist school available for adaptive use! Architectural and Historical Information Constructed for the African American Community before integration, the Dunbar School was named for Paul Lawrence Dunbar, an African […]

c. 1880

Historic Mill B&B

  • Hatfield, Massachusetts
  • $1,150,000

One of the most unique B&Bs in the country, this is an amazing opportunity to own a piece of New England history! The Old Mill Inn combines meticulous preservation of […]

c. 1927

Firehouse Inn – A Converted Historic Firehouse in Heart of Rutherfordton

  • Rutherfordton, North Carolina
  • $890,000

The Firehouse Inn is located in the foothills of western North Carolina, one block from historic downtown Rutherfordton. Just a short drive to Lake Lure, NC (home of the movie […]

c. 1895

Former Bedford County Jail: Transform this Unique Property!

  • Bedford, Pennsylvania
  • $394,900

Are you looking for an exceptionally unique property? Well once upon a time this building housed the criminals and characters of interest of Bedford County and local travelers being originally […]