Converted Houses for Sale

Converted Churches, Lighthouses & Other Unconventional Houses for Sale

Because Boring Houses Rarely Make History.

Normalcy is SO overrated. And who ever said a house had to be a house, anyway? Get quirky living in a converted lighthouse, an old mill, or a church reborn as a big, old mansion. Now THAT’s making a STATEMENT.

“The traveler finds himself [or herself] suddenly inspired with new hope, on catching view of the four-pronged top of the meeting house; assured of having discovered where civilization abounds and where piety asserts its empire.” Want to escape from it all? This soaring 1825 account describes a view of the magnificent First Congregational Church of […]

c. 1835
  • Hartland, Connecticut
  • $250,000

Attention creative souls and/or lovers of great open spaces!! This truly unique 1830’s converted church boasts over 1700 sq/ft of living/play or home business (art/dance/music studio) space…and it takes open-concept to new levels. Soaring ceilings, hardwood floors and charm abound. The first floor features an open concept kitchen area (9’ x 16’) with plenty of […]

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Rockport Harbor Views – Urban Luxury in a Seaside Village. Located in the heart of Rockport on .87± acres with commanding views of Rockport Harbor, the village and the Camden Hills, this top-quality, contemporary residence presides in a prominent hillside location. The house, a historic Methodist church, is now a […]

c. 1870
  • Hawthorne, Florida
  • $574,895

HISTORIC 10 Unit Apartment Building in downtown Hawthorne FL. An Owner’s unit plus 9 other units (totaling 9443SF),a 975SF Artist Studio,  a wood shop & 2 other sheds on 1.37 A. Current rent $6,675. 4 2 BR units, 6 1 BR units, all 1 Bath. Enjoy small town living in a piece of .North Florida history that […]

c. 1893
  • Bristol, Connecticut
  • $569,000

Rare opportunity!! Looking to own a unique piece of history? Your search ends here! Built in 1893, this beautiful home was the carriage house to the expansive Rockwell estate, Brightwood Hall, designed by architect H. Neill Wilson. The exquisite craftsmanship of this home–ironwork, stonework, woodwork–is unparalleled. Nestled away on park-like grounds, yet convenient to shopping, […]

c. 1855
  • Lorman, Mississippi
  • $1,645,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Canemount was constructed in 1855 by John and Frances Louise Murdoch. The 40 acre property is surrounded by 3,500 acres of Canemount Wildlife Management Area where some of the finest hunting in the Mississippi Delta can be had. Canemount’s extraordinary Italianate architecture was listed on the National Register of Historic […]

c. 1810
  • Emmaus, Pennsylvania
  • $798,000

THE BARNHOUSE PROPERTY is the evidence of a remarkable vision. The current owners of this bank barn c 1810 created a handmade jewel. The property consists of 5 acres of mixed woods, an open lawn, and an artfully crafted landscape masterpiece. The property feels very rural yet is only 5-minute drive to Emmaus Borough for […]

c. 1927
  • Perrysburg, Ohio
  • $549,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Award-winning architecture of the gorgeous Stranahan Estate Gatehouse! LOCATED IN PBRG SCHOOL DISTRICT! Across from the WW Knight preserve offering nature hiking trails & boardwalks. Less than 10 minute drive to historic Perrysburg w/shops,restautants & coffee shops.Gatehouse features an enchanting walled garden with a private cobblestone courtyard.Charming library, spacious modern […]

c. 1822
  • Chaplin, Connecticut
  • $289,900

Historic Tavern in move in condition, priced at an unheard of $94 per sq ft (price per sq ft is the end all be all in appraisal and lender underwriting guidelines)! Lowest priced home with 5 or more bedrooms & baths in the state, actually, all Southern New England, CT, MA & RI. Motivated seller […]

Historic Farmhouse with modern amenities & historic charm, just 50 mins from Nashville. Built by a Revolutionary War Vet & acquaintance of Daniel Boone. The original log cabin has been meticulously restored & expanded to a 5BR, 4BA modern farmhouse with in-law apartment & contemporary kitchen. Old world charm but with new plumbing, electrical, hvac, […]

c. 1850
  • Elkhorn, Wisconsin
  • $425,000

History still in the making with this 3 bedroom 1.5 bath home w 2 car garage that has been in the same family for 5 generations. Reynolds-Weed house was constructed in 1850 as Elkhorn’s second schoolhouse and became a home in 1857. The two story brick home was built of yellow Elkhorn brick but later […]

c. 1897
  • Grenada, Mississippi
  • $525,000

Have you been searching for a Cattle & Horse Farm with Character? LOOK NO MORE! This incredible 125.34 Acres farm offers Rolling Hills , All under fence, Large stocked pond , Restored 1897 Church into Beautiful A-Frame Country Home that you would have to view to feel all the charm of the one of a […]

Compare listings

Follow us @cheapoldhouses + launching on HGTV & Discovery+, Monday, August 9th at 9pm ET