Converted Houses for Sale

Converted Churches, Lighthouses & Other Unconventional Houses for Sale

Because Boring Houses Rarely Make History.

Normalcy is SO overrated. And who ever said a house had to be a house, anyway? Get quirky living in a converted lighthouse, an old mill, or a church reborn as a big, old mansion. Now THAT’s making a STATEMENT.

c. 1930
  • Galisteo, New Mexico
  • $1,195,000

This historic 2 bed, 2 bath adobe home is tucked away in the charming village of Galisteo. This unique property was the schoolhouse in a previous life. High viga & beam ceilings throughout and kiva fireplaces in the living room and bedroom offer the stylistic character of an old adobe with modern updates including new […]

c. 1720
  • Ipswich, Massachusetts
  • $1,295,000

 Established in 1671 as an “ordinary” (tavern), this restored home at 8 North Main Street, Ipswich combines historic significance with modern comfort. In the 1600s, taverns on the main roads out of Boston were referred to as “ordinaries,” offering rest, hospitality, and whatever was cooking over the hearth that day. One such ordinary was Sparks’ […]

Gorgeous unique home that was once a Church. Sellers have seamlessly combined original elements with new features to create a one of a kind home. Richly detailed woodwork, stained glass and a working bell tower are just some of the highlights! The fully fenced and beautifully landscaped yard feels like an oasis. The .23-acre corner […]

Built in 1897, this stunningly beautiful stone church is a true architectural gem steeped in the rich history of Peoria. With over 9600 square feet of space, this building presents a myriad of possibilities for its future owners and offers a unique opportunity for those seeking a property with character and charm. The sanctuary of […]

c. 1925
  • Paupack, Pennsylvania
  • $499,900

Your chance to own one of the most unique & historic properties in the Lake Wallenpaupack area! Partially converted from a 1925 Neo-Classical Revival-style school into living space w/additional opportunities to convert the property. 3 units: (1) short-term rental, (1) classroom, (1) mixed use space lower level, plus an unfinished basement. The living space was […]

c. 1938
  • Santa Fe, New Mexico
  • $2,100,000

Historic Tesuque property with abundant water rights, a New Mexico dream! Experience what used to be the community hub of Tesuque Village, home to the post office, market, small cottage motel, service station and residence of the postmistress and proprietor. All businesses have long since relocated. The main structure was converted into a private home […]

c. 1900
  • Cincinnati, Ohio
  • $1,649,900

Welcome to the exquisite, award winning, historic church turned single-family home, a gem nestled in the up and coming West End of Cincinnati within The Dayton Street Historic District. This remarkable property seamlessly combines timeless architectural beauty with modern amenities, offering an extraordinary opportunity for a discerning buyer seeking endless income potential through rental or […]

This charming country home with a fascinating history has been lovingly restored and is now move-in ready for its next lucky owner. Formerly the Rocky Point train station, the structure was moved to its current location, and now sits on almost a full acre of prime land with stunning views in every direction. Complete with […]

c. 1800
  • Durham Township, Pennsylvania
  • $5,999,000

Surrounded by almost 90 acres of rural tranquility, La Grange boasts panoramic views in every direction, 360 degrees of pastoral splendor that is impressive in every season. This stunning home was originally built in the 1800s, fully renovated in 2022, and includes five ensuite bedrooms with a total of eight full baths in the main […]

Have you ever dreamed of owning a beautiful old church building? What about an old church building in a vibrant coastal town in Oregon? Today is the day that your dream could easily become a reality. Step back in time and embrace Astoria’s rich history through this magnificent 1947 church building. With over 9000 square […]

c. 1915
  • Katonah, New York
  • $740,000

If you love historic settings, exposed beams, stone walls, magnolias, wisteria and more, this circa 1915 Carriage House with Barn is for you! Interior and exterior boast original stone walls, red-brick and wide-plank flooring, barn-timber walls, hand-hewn beams. Imagine an idyllic time when horse-drawn carriages brought guests to this charming home bedecked with candles in […]

Charming country church in Upstate NY is a mixed use building w endless possibilities for living, performance, studio, event or commercial kitchen space. The former sanctuary has cathedral ceiling, hardwood floors, a low stage and movable pews. Six large windows let the light shine in. Former enclosed choir loft is perfect for office and/or storage. […]

Compare listings

Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !