Converted Houses for Sale

Converted Churches, Lighthouses & Other Unconventional Houses for Sale
Because Boring Houses Rarely Make History.
Normalcy is SO overrated. And who ever said a house had to be a house, anyway? Get quirky living in a converted lighthouse, an old mill, or a church reborn as a big, old mansion. Now THAT’s making a STATEMENT.
Visit the Open House this Sunday, 8/30 from 1-4pm! Beautifully renovated historic Colonial located in the charming Borough of Rocky Hill and served by the highly regarded Montgomery School District. Rich in character and thoughtfully updated, this 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home blends timeless architectural details with modern comforts. Built as the borough’s first school […]
Offering exceptional flexibility for multigenerational living, extended family, guests, or investment use, this extraordinary post and beam property combines historic character with versatile living spaces and a quintessential Maine setting. Originally built as a mill circa 1860+/-, the home has been thoughtfully renovated while preserving its character. The lower-level ADU is a standout feature, offering […]
Live your best life in Delaware County where you’ll find this CHARMING Circa 1865 schoolhouse; proudly listed as an historic landmark, and lovingly restored with meticulous attention to detail. Tucked away in the peaceful countryside, this small, magical space is the ultimate, idyllic pocket of pure serenity. **Why You’ll Love It** Authentic historic character with […]
Once-in-a-Lifetime Waterfront Conversion on the Shores of Lake Erie. Welcome to one of Lowbanks’ most extraordinary properties—a beautifully renovated former church transformed into a stunning waterfront residence where historic architecture meets modern luxury. Perfectly positioned on the shores of Lake Erie, this truly one-of-a-kind home offers breathtaking lake views from nearly every window, creating an […]
The Vermillion Institute is a grand landmark with a rich history. When built in 1845, it was the largest building in the county and housed a college, predecessor to the College of Wooster. This National Register-listed property was later the local high school and sat empty for years until rescued and completely rebuilt to modern […]
A Piece of Fairfax History, Beautifully Lived In In 1865, Andrew J. Sager, abolitionist, farmer, and namesake of Fairfax’s Sager Avenue, purchased three hundred acres called Hollyberry Hill from his family, only to return home after the war to find a Union fort and stockade standing on his land. Thirty years later, on October 24, […]
Go to the Head of the Class: Own a piece of Denver history in the highly desirable Sloan’s Lake neighborhood! This turnkey, pet-friendly property offers exceptional flexibility as a place to call home, a lock-and-leave urban retreat, or an income-producing investment for mid- to long-term rentals. Built in 1904, the classic red-brick Boulevard Elementary School […]
Known over the years as The Old Parish House, Fuller’s Hall, and the Fuller Block, this remarkable Medway property has played an important role in the community for more than two centuries. The building was constructed in 1816–1817 using hand-hewn timbers salvaged from Medway’s original 1749 West Parish Meetinghouse. In 1818, the Freemasons added the […]
A rare opportunity to own one of North Carolina’s most historically significant waterfront residences. Built circa 1769, the Warner House, later incorporated into Beaufort’s famed Davis Boarding House, is older than the Declaration of Independence and represents more than two and a half centuries of Coastal Carolina history. Prominently positioned along Beaufort’s iconic Front Street […]
Welcome to Wit’s End, Rivertowns Historic Gem, where timeless, period charm meets maintenance-free condo living that feels like private estate living. One block to Aqueduct Trail, village shops, dining, 40-minute train to NYC, experience Rivertowns living at its finest yet with comparatively low taxes. Step into this stunning ground-floor condo in a circa 1865 Victorian […]