Converted Houses for Sale

Converted Churches, Lighthouses & Other Unconventional Houses for Sale

Because Boring Houses Rarely Make History.

Normalcy is SO overrated. And who ever said a house had to be a house, anyway? Get quirky living in a converted lighthouse, an old mill, or a church reborn as a big, old mansion. Now THAT’s making a STATEMENT.

c. 1750
  • Ledyard, Connecticut
  • $525,000

Truly a one of a kind opportunity, this four bedroom 1750’s colonial home is listed with the Ledyard Historical Society. Serenity, charm, and traditional New England character abound. As you pass through the home you find fireplaces, wide board floors, and raised panel doors. The grounds feature massive local stone walls, mature fruit trees, and […]

c. 1912
  • Northampton, Massachusetts

St. John Cantius: 1912 Romanesque Revival 1-story brick church for redevelopment. A landmark historic building across from new community arts center, just off the beautiful classic Main Street of Northampton with its many shops & restaurants. Easy car & transit access to Boston, New York City. Progressive and pedestrian/bike friendly city. The building does need […]

c. 1855
  • Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
  • $1,045,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! With its breathtaking stained-glass windows, original hardwood flooring and soaring 28’ ceilings, this heavenly building has been transformed into a modern, stylish home. With the old becoming the new, this 165-year-old church conversion sitting in the heart of the South Side Flats is seriously impressive. Be in awe as you […]

c. 1952
  • Palm Springs,
  • $3,498,500

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Moroccan flare and one-of-a-kind design in the Historic Tennis Club.  If you are looking for a destination that feels a world away, here is the perfect getaway.  This home delivers tranquility as well as delight with its Bohemian Chic feel. Find your own space to relax with 4 separate bedroom […]

c. 1775
  • Old Chatham, New York
  • $15,000,000

In over 25 years, we have never had the privilege of seeing an estate restored and designed with the imagination and perfection of this exquisite 160-acre sanctuary with magical paths , gardens, and 3 miles of trails to take your breath away. The main house with formal living and FDR each w/wbfp, masterful kitchen main […]

c. 1932
  • Bryson City, North Carolina
  • $1,199,000

Amazing investment opportunity in the hospitality hub of the Great Smokys. A farm-to-table 10 guest room bed and breakfast for sale with 2 bedroom Inn Owner’s quarters with a private entrance. Farm to Table Gourmet is an understatement. The Folkestone Inn has long been know for its delicious breakfasts. Now the mornings are even more […]

c. 1910
  • New Baltimore, New York
  • $1,295,000

This property has a 9, 061 sf footprint with 3 porches & a turret that housed the town fire bell. This historic property when sold by the town was repurposed for residential & in home use. Current zoning now allows for a number of additional options with proper permitting & various allowable uses without permits. […]

c. 1880
  • Richfield Springs, New York
  • $950,000

CLOSE and CRUISE! Circa 1880 timber-frame, bank barn (40 ft x 60 ft) converted into family residence for year-round enjoyment of lake living (boating, fishing, kayaking, swimming, paddle boarding, ice fishing, sledding, cross-country skiing, ice hockey, ice skating and snowmobiling – 3 snowmobiles included). ♦ Sitting atop locally acclaimed ‘’Perkins Hill” (Perkins Family built the […]

c. 1852
  • Westernville, New York
  • $700,000

Nestled in the quaint, historic town of Westernville, sits one of the most special properties you will ever see. Over 7 years in the making, every square inch of this former church has been meticulously RENOVATED, RESTORED & REBUILT. Not a detail has been spared, which is evident the moment you step foot through the […]

c. 1961
  • Sierra Madre, California
  • $875,000

Restored Fire Station No 2 in Sierra Madre, CA. This single family home is the ultimate live/work loft with a beautiful roof top area for outdoor living and enjoying the mountain views.  Featured in LUXE Magazine in 2018.  Located 1 mile from the village in the canyon near Mary’s Market Cafe.  Property is adjacent to the Angeles Crest […]

c. 1930
  • Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania
  • $1,595,000

Welcome to 711 Pennstone Road! Situated on pristine grounds in northside Bryn Mawr, “The Bank Barn” was originally a stable/barn on the historic Harriton Estate and was converted to a “carriage house” home in the 1930s. Beautifully maintained, and thoughtfully expanded and updated both inside and out by the current owners, this special home is […]

c. 1700
  • Lyme, Connecticut
  • $699,000

A true Lyme landmark, this c1700’s home has original features and was once a post office and general store. Even the pony express stopped here! “The Stark Homestead” has been wonderfully restored with modern conveniences, The main floor great room overlooks the in ground pool and stone terrace. The updated kitchen with built-ins and stone […]

Compare listings

Follow us @cheapoldhouses + launching on HGTV & Discovery+, Monday, August 9th at 9pm ET