Compare Listings



for Sale

Converted Churches, Lighthouses,

and Other Unconventional

Houses for Sale

Because Boring Houses Rarely Make History.

Normalcy is SO overrated. And who ever said a house had to be a house, anyway? Get quirky living in a converted lighthouse, an old mill, or a church reborn as a big, old mansion. Now THAT’s making a STATEMENT.

c. 1850
  • Lititz, Pennsylvania
  • $370,000

Step back in time and enjoy this extraordinary German Colonial stone farmhouse just north of Lititz with a southern exposure. This meticulously maintained home features wood floors throughout and a […]

c. 1926
  • Boonton, New Jersey
  • $599,000

Open house: Sunday, June 9th, 1:00 PM – 4:00 PM View the video HERE. A distinctive home with a sense of history, built to entertain large parties in the expansive […]

c. 1825
  • Rhinebeck, New York
  • $465,000

This circa 1825 stylishly renovated Rhinebeck Greek Revival schoolhouse has been meticulously maintained and expanded while retaining its original charm. Initially designated the Eighmyville District 9 Schoolhouse, ‘The Belfry,’ became […]

c. 1839
  • Farnham, Virginia
  • $340,000

It is a rare find indeed to find an outstanding time capsule of a property as the old Downing Store and adjoining Victorian family home at 11 Hales Point Road.  […]

c. 1776
  • Lititz, Pennsylvania
  • $300,000

The Compass Mill complex includes the 5,500+ square foot Mill, a 2 bedroom log cabin, and a two-room cottage, all on 1.2 acres along the Lititz Run Creek and Rothsville Road in Lititz.

c. 1760
  • Middleburg, Virginia
  • $2,150,000

Historic Pot House Corner sits on 11+ acres tucked amongst large farms just minutes from the village of Middleburg. It features a brick Main House, a Studio building (old potters […]

c. 1904
  • Cornersville, Tennessee
  • $289,000

Amazing opportunity and great location! Situated almost exactly halfway between Nashville and Huntsville this 4800 sf property is only minutes from Exit 22 on I-65, yet offers all the peace […]

This is a great time to build your investment portfolio! Well-established income property in Lansing, Iowa, offers the best of both worlds. Four 2-bedroom apartments, along with a very popular […]

c. 1796
  • Catskill, New York
  • $475,000

True Barn Find!

c. 1859
  • Galena, Illinois
  • $649,000

U.S. Marine Hospital is a wonderful historic edifice just waiting for restoration or reuse as single family home, corporate retreat etc.