Converted Houses for Sale

Converted Churches, Lighthouses & Other Unconventional Houses for Sale

Because Boring Houses Rarely Make History.

Normalcy is SO overrated. And who ever said a house had to be a house, anyway? Get quirky living in a converted lighthouse, an old mill, or a church reborn as a big, old mansion. Now THAT’s making a STATEMENT.

c. 1857
  • Greenville,
  • $995,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Surrounded by 3,500 acres of Canemount Wildlife Management Area; Listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1982; Adapted into a Bed & Breakfast and Events Venue in 2018. The finest example of Italianate architecture in Claiborne County, Canemount Inn is a 7 building complex with guest rooms and […]

Charming country church in Upstate NY is a mixed use building w endless possibilities for living, performance, studio, event or commercial kitchen space. The former sanctuary has cathedral ceiling, hardwood floors, a low stage and movable pews. Six large windows let the light shine in. Former enclosed choir loft is perfect for office and/or storage. […]

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Rockport Harbor Views – Urban Luxury in a Seaside Village. Located in the heart of Rockport on .87± acres with commanding views of Rockport Harbor, the village and the Camden Hills, this top-quality, contemporary residence presides in a prominent hillside location. The house, a historic Methodist church, is now a […]

c. 1847
  • Dallas, North Carolina
  • $125,000

One of the most high profile and distinctive buildings in downtown Dallas, only 30 minutes from Charlotte! Amazing adaptive reuse space and ideal for those looking for an urban feel within the charm of a small southern town. Architectural and Historical Information The Dallas Jail is a contributing structure in the Dallas National Register Historic […]

1885 Catholic Church converted to a gorgeous Mediterranean home on 2 city lots (120 x 140). Original architecture with hard maple floors, original 20 foot domed ceilings in living area and kitchen, and original Gothic arched windows in living area. The open kitchen has 2 huge stained glass windows and impressive chandelier. Huge full bath […]

c. 1922
  • Southern Pines, North Carolina
  • $990,000

Chimbley House has a space for every time of day, whether work or play. A unique piece of Southern Pines history and once featured on HGTV, this former Orchid Greenhouse was originally constructed circa 1922. Chimbley House has been lovingly renovated and remodeled into an elegant, updated home with 6 car garage, 5 bedrooms, 4 ½ baths, 3 […]

c. 1880
  • Pinebluff, North Carolina
  • $30,000

Calling for creativity! This quaint but spacious church situated in the restive sandhills region among native longleaf pines would make a perfect artist retreat or weekend getaway.  Located only about ten miles from Pinehurst and Southern Pines, it could offer the best of both worlds for those who enjoy the peace and quiet of a […]

c. 1891
  • Mayodan, North Carolina
  • $58,000

Unique 3-story inn in picturesque Mayodan!  Situated in a prime downtown location near the scenic Mayo River, the Mayodan Hotel has played a prominent role in town with its origins as a modest two-story home to the Lewis family and gradually evolving into its current 26 rooms. Archival photographs (including main image), extensive history, floor […]

c. 1904
  • Cornersville, Tennessee
  • $279,000

Unlimited Possibilities! Amazing opportunity and great location! Situated exactly halfway between Nashville and Huntsville this 4800 sf property is only minutes from Exit 22 on I-65, yet offers all the peace and tranquility of country living. Beautiful country views in all directions! Originally the New Hope Methodist Church, this 100 year-old brick building could be […]

Compare listings

Follow us @cheapoldhouses + launching on HGTV & Discovery+, Monday, August 9th at 9pm ET