Old Houses for Sale in New York

Old Houses for Sale in New York

c. 1917
  • New Rochelle, New York
  • $4,900,000

“Oak Island” is aptly named for the lush, green landscape that protects the stunning oasis set on over a half-acre, situated on Premium Mill Pond and overlooks the Long Island Sound. An arched stone bridge connects to the circular driveway, inviting you to the heart of the property housing a 6 bedroom, 6.5 bath Mediterranean-style […]

c. 1895
  • Wurtsboro, New York
  • $450,000

This beautifully renovated and historic 5-bedroom seasonal home with lake access is the perfect spring, summer, and fall getaway! Registered on the National Register of Historic Places, this spectacular 1800’s home is an entertainer’s dream with a large country kitchen, multiple indoor and outdoor dining zones and a wrap-around patio with sunset views. With all […]

c. 1912
  • Cooperstown, New York
  • $725,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! 1912 Rare Historical Beauty! This 5 bedroom, 4.5 bathroom home is located on a little-traveled, desirable, quiet street in the Village of Cooperstown. Upon entering the home, one gets a sense of Old World Style, which will maintain its timeless and elegant appeal for many years to come. This beautiful […]

c. 1762
  • Rhinebeck, New York
  • $1,875,000

Strawberry Hill is a captivating historic estate in Rhinebeck set on more than 21 private and luscious acres. The enchanting property is anchored by a gable-roofed German stone farmhouse built into a hill and set back from the road. Commissioned in 1762 by Henry Beekman, one of the earliest land patent holders in the Hudson […]

c. 1951
  • Big Flats, New York
  • $784,900

Unique and charming old stone home along the Chemung River. Situated on 7 acres of picturesque land with 1023′ of combined river frontage. Custom stonework throughout from the main home with multiple chimneys and tower, the renovated guest house to the stone arched bridge walkway through the beautifully maintained flower gardens. Built by a local […]

c. 1902
  • Poughkeepsie, New York
  • $619,000

Welcome to Black Horse Manor in the coveted south side of Poughkeepsie known for quaint, private and historic neighborhoods. This historically significant former residence of the mayor offers the rare combination of circa 1902 home in a bucolic and nearly 2.5 acre setting. Passing stone pillars, majestic trees and lush landscape, the circular driveway continues […]

“The traveler finds himself [or herself] suddenly inspired with new hope, on catching view of the four-pronged top of the meeting house; assured of having discovered where civilization abounds and where piety asserts its empire.” Want an escape from it all? This soaring 1825 account describes a view of the magnificent First Congregational Church of […]

c. 1800
  • Nassau, New York
  • $262,000

Nestled on the little town of Nassau’s Main Street you find only 2 original Historical homes left from the 1800’s. This old home has many upgrades starting with a state of the art hot water on demand heating system. New bathroom fixtures, yet still has 1930 Claw foot tub. Original tin ceilings in most of […]

c. 1880
  • Catskill, New York
  • $679,000

Here is one of the glories of Catskill’s East Side Historic District. Imagine a spacious three-story NYC townhouse – but freestanding on a large parcel of land. Constructed about 1880 in the dramatic Second Empire style, this light-filled home offers a carefully restored interior. Some details: Original windows, very high ceilings, hardwood and old board […]

This beautiful Greek Revival farmhouse has 3060 square feet of living space and is located on (14.78) 15 acres of verdant farmland in historic Hoosick, NY. The property includes three barns, two of which have been converted into art studio/woodworking spaces. It is bordered by forest and also contains a pond and stream. The house […]

An exquisitely renovated Victorian beauty on a magical half-acre corner setting with spectacular views of Larchmont Harbor and Long Island Sound from multiple levels. Beautifully oriented toward the water, just steps to Manor Park, this sunlit home is fringed by a wildly pretty wraparound porch with a myriad of alfresco entertaining spaces and possible site […]

c. 1600
  • Palisades, New York
  • $2,295,000

The “Big House” is a stunning historic estate and farm built in the 18th and 19th century and is located on 4.4 park-like acres in Sneden’s Landing, New York. The home has been continuously lived in for 350 years. Originally built in the late 1600’s and over the centuries updated and expanded. The three-story home […]

c. 1891
  • Staten Island , New York
  • $1,075,000

This majestic 1895 Richardsonian Romanesque Victorian home is rich in history, unique in design, and overflowing in craftsmanship. Original features throughout include a masonry entry archway with renown architecture, a grandesque staircase as well as service stairs, hardwood floors, wood burning fireplaces, ceiling medallions and last but not least a slate shingle roofing. This one […]

Directly across from the Hart-Cluett Mansion, this charming property is timeless and loaded with historic details and craftsmanship. Currently used as the owner’s business and residence, it remains versatile and can be used in a number of ways. Located in the heart of the Central Business District on a tree lined street, within walking distance […]

c. 1923
  • Scarsdale , New York
  • $7,750,000

Welcome to your own fabulously private oasis in the coveted Fox Meadow area of Scarsdale. 57 Old Orchard Lane is the absolute perfect combination of award winning design and unparalleled elegance. This grand estate was built in 1923 and meticulously updated by its current owners. It is comprised of over 2 acres of bucolic grounds […]

c. 1842
  • Valley Falls, New York
  • $980,000

1840’s Greek Revival restored to original condition 5 working fireplaces, 5 bedrooms, wide plank floors throughout the entire house, built-in cabinets, vintage Millwork & moldings, butlers pantry, winding staircases, glass enclosed sun porch, in-ground pool, 2 barns, outbuildings, 3 ponds, 65 + rolling acres of fields, stunning hilltop views of the Tomhannock Reservoir, Grafton mountains […]

c. 1860
  • Chester, New York
  • $995,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! This wonderfully renovated, dramatic farmhouse colonial was built in 1860, with an authentic period double height front entrance and beautiful porch overlooking gorgeous mountain views. With original pocket doors, 4 fireplaces and double stairway, it infinitely impresses with countless elements of historic grandeur. A modernized, high end kitchen, bricked garden […]

c. 1775
  • Old Chatham, New York
  • $15,000,000

In over 25 years, we have never had the privilege of seeing an estate restored and designed with the imagination and perfection of this exquisite 160-acre sanctuary with magical paths , gardens, and 3 miles of trails to take your breath away. The main house with formal living and FDR each w/wbfp, masterful kitchen main […]

Historic and Majestic! You would have to search high and low to find anything else to compare. Nothing says welcome home more than this oversized wrap-around stone porch where you can sit on the swing and sip sweet tea (or wine). Incredibly stunning turn of the century, historic 6 bedroom/4 bath Stone and Cedar Victorian […]

c. 1887
  • Bayport, New York
  • $1,395,000

Built in 1887, This Elegant Georgian Colonial Offers A Rare Opportunity To Own A Piece Of History In South Bayport, NY- Masterful Architecture And Old-World Charm! This Lovely 3 Story Home Offers A Grand Foyer Entrance With 10ft Ceilings, Full Eat In Kitchen, Large Formal Living Room, Sunlit Dining Room, Den, Office, Separate Laundry Room, […]

c. 1890
  • Larchmont, New York
  • $2,395,000

Modern perfection wrapped in a historic architectural envelope; this fully renovated Victorian has everything to please today’s home buyer. Thoughtfully renovated and expanded to preserve the original integrity and beauty of the home while integrating modern amenities that make life seamless and at ease radiant heat floors, gas burning fireplaces, high-end appliances, office space, a […]

c. 1910
  • New Baltimore, New York
  • $1,295,000

This property has a 9, 061 sf footprint with 3 porches & a turret that housed the town fire bell. This historic property when sold by the town was repurposed for residential & in home use. Current zoning now allows for a number of additional options with proper permitting & various allowable uses without permits. […]

c. 1814
  • Sackets Harbor, New York
  • $525,000

Architecturally gorgeous federal-style home situated on 2 acre parcel in the village of Sackets Harbor. This property is known as the famous Elisha Camp House, Camp Manor. This historical mansion features 5 spacious bedrooms, 3 baths, formal dining, grand entry way w/original folding doors and archways, hardwood floors throughout, fireplace and much more. This property […]

c. 1890
  • Hudson, New York
  • $695,000

Cypress Step is an impressive Queen Anne Victorian and an original in every way, built to impress and to last with gracious integrity. The expanded four-square layout offers well-proportioned living spaces and bedrooms with high ceilings and a beautiful flow starting in the stunning entry foyer with a grand staircase. The ornate original mantels, doors, […]

All the Cool Kids are Doing it.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.


Monthly Page Views


Combined Social Media Followers


Newsletter Subscribers

Compare listings

Follow us @cheapoldhouses + launching on HGTV & Discovery+, Monday, August 9th at 9pm ET