Search

Old Houses for Sale in New York

Old Houses for Sale in New York

c. 1918
  • Newburgh, New York
  • $1,275,000

Originally built in 1918 as the centerpiece of a larger estate, Twin Oaks is a timeless center hall Colonial set on 3.1 acres in the heart of Balmville. With 4,696 square feet of living space, this distinguished residence blends historic character with thoughtful updates, offering both presence and comfort. A classic center hall layout anchors […]

c. 1886
  • Brant Lake, New York
  • $14,900,000

A historic Adirondack legacy, the Island House Estate offers a rare, charming foothold on the shore of 5-mile Brant Lake. Including four islands, four residences, and a combination of equestrian and lakefront amenities, the estate spans 212+ acres and over 3/4 mile of shoreline. Built in 2007, the 5,414 sq. ft., 4-bedroom Main House sits […]

c. 1851
  • City of Saratoga Springs, New York
  • $9,299,000

Owned by the iconic Queen of Saratoga, the late Marylou Whitney, and her husband the late John Hendrickson, this 120+ acre property embodies the beauty and history of Saratoga Springs going back to the 1700’s when the property served as a stagecoach stop. The property dates back to the pre-revolutionary war with rumors of George […]

c. 1885
  • City of Saratoga Springs, New York
  • $3,250,000

This iconic N Broadway home known as Bracket House is a Queen Anne Victorian with all of the classic charm. Original details & design at every turn from original custom woodwork to a one of a kind front staircase. 6 original fireplaces throughout, 3 floors of living space with 8 ensuite bedrooms, some with sitting […]

c. 1940
  • Saratoga Springs, New York
  • $2,399,900

Limited opportunities remain! Units 1, 3, and 5 are still available. Contact us today to schedule your private tour! This grand Tudor style building was established in 1940 & later became the Waldorf School of Saratoga Springs. Now it’s taken on a brand-new life. Inside the brick & Tudor walls are newly constructed luxurious high-end […]

c. 1810
  • Bedford Hills, New York
  • $6,400,000

One of Bedford’s most iconic estate properties–first time offered in nearly 100 years. Remarkable Colonial Estate dating to 1810. Grand main rooms with incredibly preserved period detailing. Stunning interior with graciously proportioned rooms, high ceilings, period millwork, intricate moldings and spectacular quarter-sawn oak floors with black walnut inlays. Impressive Portico supported by massive Corinthian columns. […]

c. 1880
  • Sharon Springs, New York
  • $285,000

Step back in time with this beautifully maintained 1880 Victorian home in the heart of historic Sharon Springs. A wide covered front porch invites you into an elegant interior defined by stained-glass windows, curved walls, French doors, and crystal lighting. This four-bedroom home features a sweeping staircase, high ceilings, and a large walk-up attic. Outside, […]

c. 1860
  • Bovina Center, New York
  • $895,000

A three-building country compound on close to 15 acres just outside Bovina Center, thoughtfully sited on Gin Hill within an easy walk of the village. The property comprises a main farmhouse, a guest cottage, and a purpose-built artist’s studio, creating a rare live/work setting in the Western Catskills. It is an ideal fit for buyers […]

Welcome to this stunning, awe-inspiring historic treasure. Once the Sloat House & Inn originally built in 1755 served as a command post. Operated by the Sloat family the inn offered lodging and meals to the Continental Troops, including General George Washington. Understandable has earned its place on the National Register. This authentic exquisite home is […]

Beautifully renovated residence offering a thoughtful blend of historic charm and modern updates. On a charming street, lined with historic homes and greenery, lies the enchanting 290 Main Street. With original wood floors, marble fireplaces, exposed beam ceilings, and other historic details, this is a rare opportunity to own a piece of Owego history that […]

Commissioned in 1910 by H. Leroy Emmet, and masterfully designed by renowned architect H. Van Buren Magonigle as an English Country manor of exceptional distinction. Set on nearly 5.5 acres in sought-after Tuxedo Park, this Hudson Valley estate offers over 800 feet of private frontage on Tuxedo Lake and captures sweeping northern views across the […]

c. 1955
  • Warwick, New York
  • $925,000

Where the sky meets the earth, this mountaintop Craftsman looks out across long-distance views to the lower Catskills. Built in 1955 and thoughtfully reimagined over time, the home reflects a rare continuity. Only two owners have shaped it, each refining rather than replacing. The main residence offers approximately 2,400 square feet, complemented by a legal […]

c. 1759
  • Pawling, New York
  • $3,100,000

Farm Nord is a meticulously restored country estate, originally established in the 1700s as a dairy farm by the renowned Taber family of Rhode Island. The Tabers were stewards of the estate for five generations and two centuries, with only a few families since carrying on its legacy. The Home The property’s idyllic 12 acres […]

c. 1750
  • Chappaqua, New York
  • $2,350,000

A Rare Opportunity Where History Meets Modern Living. Built in 1750 and thoughtfully renovated in 2005. White clapboard, black shutters, cedar shake roof, and copper gutters set a timeless exterior, framed by professionally designed grounds. A wide entry hall opens to living and dining rooms bookended by floor-to-ceiling stone fireplaces. Hardwood floors and detailed millwork […]

Rarely does an offering of this scale and provenance come to market. Set across more than 114 acres, Honey Lane Farm is a private estate of exceptional beauty-three distinct period residences forming a serene, self-contained retreat in the heart of the Harlem Valley. The four-bedroom mid-19th century main house is both refined and inviting, bathed […]

c. 1985
  • Willow, New York
  • $3,325,000

More than a century in the making, and unlike anything else on the market, this extraordinary multi-residential estate began as a historic Hudson Valley farm before being thoughtfully transformed into a modern lifestyle retreat of remarkable scale and character. Over the years, musicians, entrepreneurs, and creative thinkers have called it home. Prior to that, it […]

c. 1916
  • Briarcliffe Manor, New York
  • $2,995,000

The Essence of Westchester Luxury. A Grand Briarcliff Manor Estate sited on 3.83 Private Acres. Perfectly positioned between the Hudson River and Sleepy Hollow Country Club. World-class dining, shopping and Metro North train are nearby, blending convenience with serene privacy. The stately home boasts five spacious ensuite bedrooms, including a spectacular primary suite with a […]

Built in 1887 in the Aesthetic Movement Style, this red brick building commands the center of Warren Street in the heart of Hudson. The exterior features extensive ornamental terra-cotta panels and trim. The historic interior retains elaborate wood beam ceilings with richly paneled rooms, oak and cherry fireplace mantles and intricate parquet floors. Originally a […]

Cedar Ridge Farm is a premier 246-acre equestrian estate set in the heart of Dutchess County, offering exceptional land quality, extensive infrastructure, and the rare scale required for a top tier equestrian operation or private country estate. The farm encompasses approximately 110 acres of fenced paddocks supported by thoughtfully designed facilities that ensure efficiency, functionality, […]

c. 1740
  • Kinderhook, New York
  • $2,595,000

Welcome to Hardwicke Farmhouse. Set on more than eight private acres along a quiet country road, this exceptional Greek Revival farmhouse tells the story of nearly three centuries of Columbia County history. The original structure dates to the 1740s, with a gracious Greek Revival center hall added in the 1840s. Its striking mid-20th-century modern addition […]

Set far back from one of the Hudson Valley’s most prestigious and scenic roads, this stunningly restored 1830s  farmhouse is a masterclass in combining historic charm with sophisticated living. Situated in the heart of the pastoral Shekomeko Valley on 9.6 pristine acres, this property offers ultimate privacy surrounded by large, rolling farms and protected acreage. […]

c. 1950
  • Millbrook, New York
  • $849,000

Tucked quietly among the trees on 9 private acres, this striking contemporary retreat—known as The Treehouse—offers a rare blend of architectural distinction and natural serenity, overlooking a peaceful swimming pond with its own dock. Designed in 1973 by Richard Stein around a 1950’s cottage, the home showcases a bold sawtooth roofline and clerestory windows that […]

Illustrating one of the most enchanting architectural styles to emerge from 19th-century America, this Carpenter Gothic home and barn—gracefully positioned at the corner of Lake Road South and Reed Road—feel as though they’ve been lifted from the pages of a storybook. Inspired by the European Gothic Revival movement, the property offers a rare chance to […]

c. 1740
  • Mount Sinai, New York
  • $875,000

This home was built in the mid 1700s and was here before the Revolutionary War. This location served the family as a home and the community as the Post Office in the mid 1800s. If you’ve wanted to own a piece of history, this distinctive red-roofed Saltbox-style house behind the white picket fence may be […]

All the Cool Kids are Doing it.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

2m

Monthly Page Views

575k

Combined Social Media Followers

55k

Newsletter Subscribers