Old Houses for Sale in New York

Old Houses for Sale in New York

Historic 3-story, 5-bay Federal style mansion circa 1827 home originally owned by William Swain, a famous Nantucket Sea Captain reputed to have speared a whale himself on one of his last voyages before settling permanently to the completed four-level mansion in 1827. Many improvements have been recently made to this property, including foundation repair, gutters, […]

c. 1900
  • Mendon, New York
  • $329,900

Charming Honeoye Falls Victorian Gem! This beloved village treasure is finally available! Beautifully maintained and thoughtfully renovated, this 4-bedroom home blends timeless character with modern updates—truly move-in ready. Step inside to find original hardwood floors throughout, a formal living room, elegant parlor, and spacious dining room. The custom kitchen, completed in 2023, features new appliances […]

c. 1907
  • Hague, New York
  • $2,300,000

Once in a lifetime opportunity to own a stunning ”Adirondack Great Camp’’ on the shores of Lake George. ”Chipwick,’’ a circa 1907 shingle style Queen Anne Victorian has been in the same family for nearly 100 years. Enjoy breathtaking views of the water and approx. 137’ of sandy shoreline. Property features the 5,366 sq ft […]

Old House Lovers: your rare opportunity to own a piece of Hudson Valley history has arrived. Long before Croton-on-Hudson became one of Westchester’s most sought-after river towns, A.P. Gardiner – an early 1900s gentleman from New York City – chose this very hillside for his sprawling country estate. ”Hessian Hills” served as a seasonal refuge […]

The “Cloisterie”, one of the county’s grandest historic homes,  built in 1860 as a wealthy family’s residence, many years afterwards an adult home, it sold 16 years ago when the proprietor retired and it reverted to a private residence. It is now for sale again due to an untimely death in the family. There are […]

c. 1917
  • Larchmont, New York
  • $3,250,000

This architectural beauty is nestled on a tree-lined corner property in the heart of Larchmont Manor, close to the Village, parks, and the waterfront! This coveted location offers a lifestyle of convenience and seaside charm. Blissfully private and designed for entertaining, this home boasts a wide sun-drenched front terrace overlooking newly landscaped level lawn and […]

c. 1860
  • Buskirk, New York
  • $624,900

c. 1840-1860 Welcoming old homestead, surrounded by protected land trust which will never be developed, among rolling hill views. This historic, tastefully updated  home with kitchen and bathrooms, including soapstone countertops, farmhouse sink, high-end appliances and walk-in pantry. When you drive down this quiet country road full of lush green pastures, you will be experiencing […]

c. 1854
  • Amsterdam, New York
  • $574,900

OPEN HOUSE SUNDAY 6/29/25  FROM 12-2 .  This majestic mansion was built in the late 1850’s by industrialist  John Kellogg  one of the owners of Kellogg and Miller Linseed Oil Company . It was built in Victorian Italianate Style with many of  the original features still in tact .  It’s been utilized over the years […]

c. 1840
  • Meredith, New York
  • $1,395,000

The very best in the Catskills, Upstate New York and 3 hours from NYC. Gut renovated 1840 farm with red dairy barn, Carriage house and small barn. 95 acres and includes hay fields, two freshwater swim ponds, perennial gardens, restored stone walls, and an enchanting forest. This incredible family estate & farm offers a peaceful […]

Rich in history, the iconic Pink House in Schoharie is now available.This 4, 800 sq ft gem blends original 19th-century charm with tasteful, modern renovations completed within the last decade. Featuring 5 fireplaces, 2 with efficient pellet inserts, this home offers timeless elegance with contemporary comfort. Highlights include soaring ceilings, intricate woodwork, a grand staircase, […]

c. 1930
  • Wurstboro, New York
  • $4,750,000

Welcome to Painter Hill Castle, a 300-acre estate with three distinct homes: an Old World-inspired castle, a guesthouse, and a vintage stone cottage. The main residence features handcrafted built-ins, leaded windows, custom red oak doors, and a Vermont slate roof. Enjoy sweeping panoramic views of the Shawangunk Mountain foothills, four en suite bedrooms, a stately […]

Perfectly situated on the historic River Road on the Hudson River and equidistant from the center of bustling Hudson and charismatic Kinderhook lies the Garrett Sickles House. Constructed in 1820 and treated to a four-year restoration program completed in 2023, this home presents perfect symmetry of historic provenance and modern convenience that has been featured […]

c. 1885
  • Gilboa, New York
  • $747,500

Come fall in love with the original Clover Valley Farm! While the dairy is gone, the stunning 4-bed, 2-bath farmhouse has been beautifully restored. At 3,100 sq ft, this home features original wood floors, a grand staircase, a charming country kitchen, formal dining, parlor, and living room &all filled with natural light. Enjoy sunrise and […]

Designed by acclaimed architect Charles P. Winter, this Hudson River property is a bold and thoughtful expression of mid-century modern design and is being put up for sale for only the second time since its construction in 1967. Set high on a wooded bluff, the home is oriented to capture commanding seasonal views of the […]

c. 1929
  • Webster, New York
  • $2,200,000

13.63 ACRES & OVER 550 FEET OF LAKE FRONTAGE IN WEBSTER: Welcome to 1516 Lake Road, fondly known to the family as Meadow Edge . This incredibly gracious & spacious property has been in the same family since being built in 1929-Fanny Cooper Rochester Rodgers (Nathaniel Rochester’s granddaughter) was original owner! Quality design by noted […]

c. 1880
  • Hudson, New York
  • $945,000

This picturesque Hudson home is one of the finest examples of French second-empire style, in a city known as ”a dictionary of American architecture.’’ It features a prominent mansard tower with bullseye (oeil-de-boeuf) dormer windows and tall arched paired windows. At the second-floor level, the curved mansard slate roof is pierced by ornate crowned dormer […]

Welcome to The Anson Pratt House, a masterfully restored Federal Adams-style residence located in the historic hamlet of New Concord in East Chatham, NY. Built in 1793 atop a marble clad foundation, this architectural jewel is honored in the Library of Congress as part of the Historic American Buildings Survey. Featured in numerous architectural and […]

c. 1905
  • Briarcliff Manor, New York
  • $2,995,000

Stylishly reimagined by two New York fashion VIPs, this sophisticated 1905 Colonial blends modern luxury with the home’s original integrity, grandeur and charm. Tucked away on Hardscrabble Road, the serene sanctuary—a highlight of the New Castle Historical Society house tour—offers a Martha Baker-designed landscape, close to an acre, comprising woodlands, curated boxwoods, flowering dogwoods and […]

c. 1890
  • Stamford, New York
  • $3,395,000

Welcome to West Branch Farm, a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own an extraordinary piece of history and one of the largest properties available in New York State. This breathtaking estate spans over 1,080 acres, encompassing an entire mountainside and stretching as far as the eye can see on both sides of the West Branch of the […]

c. 1930
  • Briarcliff Manor, New York
  • $4,300,000

Welcome to Boxwood: A Timeless Retreat Boxwood offers a unique blend of classic Williamsburg Colonial architecture and thoughtful modern upgrades, creating a warm and inviting home that caters to both comfort and elegance. Situated on 3.895 acres of beautifully maintained grounds, this gated property provides a peaceful escape while remaining functional and accommodating for modern […]

Nestled within the serene and secluded enclave of Hilltop Place in Rye, stands a magnificent property once the country retreat of Andrew Goodman, the former owner of Bergdorf Goodman. A true embodiment of 1920s elegance, this captivating Colonial masterpiece is a harmonious blend of classic charm and modern luxury, in a fully fenced and gated, […]

c. 1910
  • Millbrook, New York
  • $2,995,000

Experience the charm of country living in Millbrook with this 110-acre estate. As you wind your way along the quaint country road and up the circular driveway, you’re greeted by manicured lawns, lush pastures, and majestic oak trees, setting the stage for the grandeur that awaits. The main residence, a masterpiece of architectural design, boasts […]

Located in Garrison, NY, this country carriage-style house was once part of the estate of Samuel Sloan, a prominent railroad magnate who settled in the Hudson Valley during the 1850s. Charming and filled with natural light, the home has been meticulously renovated from top to bottom, seamlessly blending comfort, style, and functionality. The gardens, thoughtfully […]

c. 1950
  • Millerton, New York
  • $3,400,000

Once in a lifetime opportunity to acquire one of the last remaining unrestricted working farms in Northern Dutchess County, NY. Choice building sites, panoramic views and seclusion yet convenient to New York City, Metro North commuter train and nearby area amenities including Millerton, NY, Litchfield County, CT, Troutbeck Inn, Millbrook, NY and Silo Ridge. Boasting […]

All the Cool Kids are Doing it.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

2m

Monthly Page Views

575k

Combined Social Media Followers

55k

Newsletter Subscribers

Compare listings

Compare
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
SUBSCRIBE
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
SUBSCRIBE