Compare Listings

OLD HOUSES FOR SALE IN NEW YORK

The Gingerbread House

Larchmont, New York

This classic Gothic cottage, historically known as “The Gingerbread House,” is one of the six original cottages built by the Larchmont Manor Company in 1872.

$2,950,000

Old Houses

for Sale in

New York

Old Houses for Sale in New York

c. 1890
  • Nyack, New York
  • $1,900,000

Hudson Riverfront Queen Anne circa 1890; location for one of Edward Hoppers paintings. This perfectly restored classic is located on one of Nyack’s prettiest tree lined dead end streets. Previously […]

c. 1776
  • Valley Cottage, New York
  • $690,000

A Rare Opportunity to Own Your Own 1 Acre Mini Estate alongside Lake DeForest. This Serene Enclave Consists of a 1700’s Dutch Colonial Farm House, a Cottage, and a Converted […]

c. 1875
  • West Nyack, New York
  • $399,900

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Contemporary meets historic in this 1800’s 3 bedroom, 2 bath colonial located in a charming West Nyack neighborhood. This 2000+ sq ft home capitalizes on […]

c. 1920
  • Kingston, New York
  • $425,000

This beautifully restored 100 year old Victorian is perched directly above the historic Rondout district in downtown Kingston. Steps away from the waterfront with marinas, shopping, museums, and the best […]

c. 1922
  • Briarcliffe Manor, New York
  • $2,499,000

Style and architecture blend seamlessly with modern design at this superb 15 acre estate. The exquisite colonial residence is sited amid a dazzling landscape of open and rolling property. The […]

c. 1929
  • Scarsdale, New York
  • $3,770,000

Spectacular renovation by owner/developer, this Fox Meadow Normandy Tudor is an extraordinary integration of old world and new. With a beamed ceiling soaring to a height of 2-1/2 stories, the […]

c. 1928
  • Scarsdale, New York
  • $4,450,000

Santa Barbara comes to Scarsdale! Stunning and unique California stucco home on 2.38 lush acres with tennis court, pool, cabana and fabulous guest house! Entertain large groups in style on […]

c. 1889
  • Nyack, New York
  • $939,000

The Westerfeldt house built in 1889 is one of the original homes on this beautiful, architecturally consistent, South Nyack tree lined street. This stately Victorian with bright southern exposures has […]

c. 1899
  • Staten Island, New York
  • $1,100,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! The bright and airy victorian 2- family house features water views along with views of the verrazano bridge. Plenty of windows contribute to the house’s […]

c. 1850
  • Hillsdale, New York
  • $1,400,000

Stunning home with amazing Berkshire Mountain views set back on a quiet country road in Hillsdale, New York. Surrounded by lush mature perennial gardens, this historic property features Victorian details […]

c. 1840
  • East Marion, New York
  • $899,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Own a piece of North Fork history! Built in the 1840’s, this charming, 15 room, updated Italianate sea captain’s house makes for the perfect family […]

c. 1835
  • Shawangunk, New York
  • $2,025,000

TWO MAGNIFICENT HOMES ON ONE BEAUTIFUL ESTATE PROPERTY!!! GREAT FAMILY COMPOUND!!! One 1835 Greek Revival farmhouse (3BR) on the National Register, and one newly built Log Home (5 BR; all […]

c. 1766
  • Hudson, New York
  • $5,950,000

Locust Dale Farm, known also as the Conyn-Van Rensselaer house, is an incredible example of a fully restored Dutch home. A truly extraordinary 5-bedroom, 6400+ sq ft residence set on […]

c. 1870
  • Carmel, New York
  • $2,800,000

An exceptional property, this charming 19th-century Victorian manor home is situated on the banks of beautiful Lake Gleneida. The stately main house offers an incomparable view of sprawling green lawns […]

c. 1794
  • Old Chatham, New York
  • $1,250,000

Inspiration and enchantment await at this exquisite 18th century Quaker farmstead on 66 pastoral acres. Nestled on the land, the original farmhouse maintains the architectural integrity of its historic roots […]

c. 1870
  • Greenport, New York
  • $2,495,000

The Corwin House is a restored Greenport Grand Victorian. In the past 150 years, this house, which is situated in the heart of Greenport Village, was owned by only five […]

c. 1870
  • Wright, New York
  • $259,000

Unique opportunity to own your own slice of heaven! Over 17 acres of rolling hills, waterfalls, caves to explore, berry bushes, vegetable gardens, ponds and flower gardens…you will never be […]

c. 1880
  • Hammondsport, New York
  • $399,900

The nicely updated Lake and Vine Bed & Breakfast is an exceptional village home! This 1800s Queen Anne property provides simple elegance with modern comfort and luxury! It boasts 4 […]

c. 1860
  • Clifton Springs, New York
  • $649,900

Welcome to Buttonwood Farms! Unique opportunity to own a private Finger Lakes Estate, set on over 40 acres of mostly tillable & pasture land with some wooded areas, bordering the […]

c. 1932
  • Poughkeepsie, New York
  • $419,000

Enchanting Cape style home with loads of character, sitting on over 1 and a half acres of flat land plus Arlington schools. Fully renovated with classic charm and a modern […]

c. 1925
  • Yorktown Heights, New York
  • $550,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Country Charm and Suburban Convenience! Location, Location, Location! Pride radiates from this unique farmhouse with attached timber-framed barn nestled on 1.5 private acres. Beautiful level […]

c. 1925
  • Armonk, New York
  • $2,195,000

From the moment your drive through the gates into this park-like retreat, you’ll leave all your worries and stress of the day behind. The inviting pool and spa/waterfall with natural […]

c. 1899
  • Mount Tremper, New York
  • $1,750,000

The Mountain House is like no property this veteran agent has ever seen. Sited on 26 uber-private acres and surrounded by state land, the home itself is accessed by a […]

c. 1929
  • Rye, New York
  • $2,495,000

Gather luxuriously in this treasured residence in Park Ridge Harrison. This property is a jewel of custom craftsmanship and design. A lifestyle of beauty, relaxation and privacy are all yours […]

Old House

Real Estate

Agents in

New York

Old House

Real Estate Agents

in New York

MAIKEN NIELSEN
Weld Realty
Nyack

maiken (at) weldrealty (dot) com
(845) 596-8059

KELLI IDE
Michael DeRosa Exchange, LLC
Owasco

kelli (at) buy-design-sell (dot) com
(315) 706-9692

LAURA WEINTRAUB
Weld Realty
Nyack

laura (at) weldrealty (dot) com
(914) 588-6878

LAURA CONRAD
Purdy Realty LLC
Burnt Hills

lconrad (at) purdyrealty (dot) com
(518) 229-4943

CHRISTINA PORTER
Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty
Locust Valley

christinaporter (at) danielgale (dot) com
(516) 759-4800

ROLAND VINYARD
Vinyard’s Choice
Sprakers

roland (at) bardrocks (dot) com
(518) 673-3212

BEN HOLSCHER
Keller Williams Upstate New York Properties
Oneonta

bholscher (at) kw (dot) com
(607) 376-7509

RICH MILLER
Results Realtors
Kendall

richgetsresults (at) gmail (dot) com
(585) 737-3000

KENYATTA JONES-ARIETTA
R2M Realty, Inc.
Nyack

Kenyatta (at) Ready2Mov (dot) com
(845) 358-2000

CHRISTINE COLASURDO
Garrison Realty Group, Inc.
Garrison

garrisonrealtygroup (at) gmail (dot) com
(845) 656-3488

ONNALEE YOUNGMAN
Howard Hanna
Canandaigua

luxuryhomesbyo (at) gmail (dot) com
(585) 905-8374

KATE WOOD
Patricia A. Hinkein Realty
Germantown

kate (at) worthpreserving (dot) com
(212) 380-8612

MICHAEL CRANE
Gillani Homes Inc.
Staten Island

michaelcrane63 (at) gmail (dot) com
(917) 583-5501

All The

Cool Kids

Are Doing

It.

List an Old House

for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

2m

Monthly Page Views

575k

Combined Social Media Followers

55k

Newsletter Subscribers