Compare Listings

OLD HOUSES FOR SALE IN NEW YORK

Millbrook Hunt 66-Acre Compound

Stanfordville, New York

The perfect country setting to escape, Honey Meadow Farm is less than two hours from New York City and minutes to Amenia and Millbrook.

$2,590,000

Old Houses

for Sale in

New York

Old Houses for Sale in New York

c. 1918
  • Scarsdale, New York
  • $7,500,000

One-of-a-kind all-stone Scarsdale estate renovated in 1998 on 3.16 acres located in the heart of Murray Hill. Incredibly private, tranquil, sunny and bright with the most beautiful property. Guest cottage, […]

c. 1888
  • Irvington, New York
  • $1,600,000

This 19th Century stone gate lodge evokes Brooklyn in the Rivertowns. In this painstakingly modernized home, impressive architectural elements meet 21st Century lifestyle while embracing original patina and old world […]

c. 1896
  • Saranac Lake, New York
  • $650,000

This home has had a variety of fascinating uses over time…a cure cottage, Carmelite Monastery, and now a B&B!

Step into this circa 1830’s charming farmhouse, and you will be amazed at how lovingly maintained and upgraded it is! 33+ acres of well maintained lawns and lush forest with […]

c. 1922
  • Larchmont, New York
  • $1,599,000

Walk to train and Village of Larchmont. Steps from the brook in Larchmont Gardens. Updated Center Hall Colonial with large family room and adjacent eat-in kitchen. Formal dining and living […]

On the banks of the Hudson River you will find your own peaceful, private paradise. One-of-a-kind estate tucked away on .75 private riverfront acres. This lovely home is the epitome […]

c. 1890
  • North Salem, New York
  • $1,029,500

Fabulous, restored antique Farmhouse with wrap-around porch on gorgeous acreage and direct water views of the Titicus Reservoir. House has incredible charm with beautiful Kitchen & Baths, great space and […]

c. 1860
  • Galway, New York
  • $189,900

Galway, NY – Ask us about an awesome renovation loan option to roll into your purchase and make this home exactly as you dream!  Some exterior TLC needed.  Interior is […]

Johnstown, NY- Classic 3BR/1.5BA Victorian home loaded with original architectural details! Gorgeous moldings, doors, built-ins, pocket doors, flooring, staircase,

c. 1840
  • Amsterdam, New York
  • $249,900

Perth, Galway Schools – Come lose yourself in this spacious Colonial from the 1800s. Wide plank flooring throughout most of the home gives off the classic charm of yesteryear. Outside […]

c. 1930
  • Amsterdam, New York
  • $289,900

Broadalbin Perth  SCHOOLS – Set back from the road, charm and character fill this early 1900’s farmhouse that sits on 1.55 acres. This incredibly well maintained home has 4 bedrooms […]

c. 1818
  • Brightwaters, New York
  • $1,099,000

Classic Center Hall Colonial On The Grand Concourse Is The One You Have Been Waiting For! Relax on Your Front Porch and Enjoy The Amazing South Shore Sunsets! 5 Fireplaces, […]

c. 1938
  • Chappaqua, New York
  • $2,395,000

This impressive English-style stone and shingle Country Estate, designed by noted architect Charles Lewis Bowman has been completely refreshed and restyled with a new and modern look. Front-to-back entry with […]

c. 1950
  • Mount Kisco, New York
  • $1,699,000

Lily Pond, the enchanting home of TV Host/Author Sandra Lee and New York Governor Andrew Cuomo, is the quintessential American Colonial. The majestic three acres of sweeping lawn are surrounded […]

c. 1896
  • Larchmont, New York
  • $3,395,000

This magnificent classic Dutch Colonial with views of Larchmont Harbor seamlessly combines sophisticated luxury and a truly masterful design. No detail was overlooked in this meticulously restored and exquisitely renovated […]

c. 1808
  • Sackets Harbor, New York
  • $695,000

Check out the Virtural Tour here! Listed on the National Register of Historic Homes, this classic federal style home underwent a complete restoration down to the studs in 2002 including […]

c. 1911
  • Larchmont, New York
  • $4,995,000

One of Larchmont’s premier streets, Sixteen Pryer offers coveted waterfront living while enjoying best of the walkable Larchmont lifestyle.

c. 1870
  • Boonville, New York
  • $660,000

Opportunities like this simply don’t come along but once in a lifetime! This spectacular, fully furnished and equipped, late 19th Century Victorian mansion, currently being run successfully as a Bed […]

c. 1747/1755
  • Hudson, New York
  • $629,000

This is a unique property situated just outside of Hudson New York. It is actually 2 distinct houses, one side being built in 1737, the other being built in 1755. […]

c. 1931
  • Scarsdale, New York
  • $2,450,000

Welcome to this refined and genteel home in the heart of Fox Meadow, situated on a perfect, level .59 of an acre. With six-bedrooms, four-and-a-half baths and a superb flow […]

c. 1932
  • Scarsdale, New York
  • $2,895,000

Have the Best of both worlds. Located in one of Scarsdale’s best neighborhoods! Gorgeous 5 bedroom home, each bedroom w/private bath plus an additional bath and a half. Built-in copper […]

c. 1928
  • Rye, New York
  • $1,195,000

Fantastic location in Rye PO, in walking distance to town and train. The ultimate in convenience and privacy. All you need to do is unpack. The new kitchen has marble […]

c. 1860
  • Germantown, New York
  • $379,999

Listed on the National Register of Historic Places and potentially eligible for rehabilitation tax credits, this 1860 5-bedroom/3 bath Germantown center-hall Italianate Victorian on 3.5 acres is ready for its […]

c. 1750
  • Slate Hill, New York
  • $339,000

Welcome to The Dunning House in the Town of Wawayanda, This unique farmhouse is full of charm & character at every turn! First built in the mid-18th century as a […]

Old House

Real Estate

Agents in

New York

Old House

Real Estate Agents

in New York

MAIKEN NIELSEN
Weld Realty
Nyack

maiken (at) weldrealty (dot) com
(845) 596-8059

KELLI IDE
Michael DeRosa Exchange, LLC
Owasco

kelli (at) buy-design-sell (dot) com
(315) 706-9692

LAURA WEINTRAUB
Weld Realty
Nyack

laura (at) weldrealty (dot) com
(914) 588-6878

KATE WOOD
Patricia A. Hinkein Realty
Germantown

kate (at) worthpreserving (dot) com
(212) 380-8612

LAURA CONRAD
Purdy Realty LLC
Burnt Hills

lconrad (at) purdyrealty (dot) com
(518) 229-4943

CHRISTINA PORTER
Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty
Locust Valley

christinaporter (at) danielgale (dot) com
(516) 759-4800

ROLAND VINYARD
Vinyard’s Choice
Sprakers

roland (at) bardrocks (dot) com
(518) 673-3212

ONNALEE YOUNGMAN
Howard Hanna
Canandaigua

luxuryhomesbyo (at) gmail (dot) com
(585) 905-8374

BEN HOLSCHER
Keller Williams Upstate New York Properties
Oneonta

bholscher (at) kw (dot) com
(607) 376-7509

RICH MILLER
Results Realtors
Kendall

richgetsresults (at) gmail (dot) com
(585) 737-3000

MICHAEL CRANE
Gillani Homes Inc.
Staten Island

michaelcrane63 (at) gmail (dot) com
(917) 583-5501

CHRISTINE COLASURDO
Garrison Realty Group, Inc.
Garrison

garrisonrealtygroup (at) gmail (dot) com
(845) 656-3488

All The

Cool Kids

Are Doing

It.

List an Old House

for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

2m

Monthly Page Views

575k

Combined Social Media Followers

55k

Newsletter Subscribers