Old Houses for Sale in New York

Old Houses for Sale in New York

c. 1790
  • Poestenkill, New York
  • $1,200,000

Down a country lane, this pristine 18th-century farmhouse, barn and guest cottage create a world all their own. Miles of trails wind through 100+ acres of woods, field, stream and pond, evoking the Hudson Valley’s most beautiful state parks Olana and Clermont. The spacious main house includes 4 bedrooms and 2 baths; sociable cook’s kitchen […]

c. 1900
  • Spencer, New York
  • $549,900

Stunningly Preserved Neoclassical situated on a large lot in the heart of charming Spencer Village. Coming through the grand entrance you will be taken back to the days of extravagance, surrounded by leaded and beveled glass , and jaw dropping natural woodwork throughout. Any woodworker would appreciate the details and craftsmanship of the mahogany raised […]

c. 1880
  • Richfield Springs, New York
  • $950,000

CLOSE and CRUISE! Circa 1880 timber-frame, bank barn (40 ft x 60 ft) converted into family residence for year-round enjoyment of lake living (boating, fishing, kayaking, swimming, paddle boarding, ice fishing, sledding, cross-country skiing, ice hockey, ice skating and snowmobiling – 3 snowmobiles included). ♦ Sitting atop locally acclaimed ‘’Perkins Hill” (Perkins Family built the […]

c. 1900
  • Larchmont, New York
  • $2,475,000

Nostalgia for elegance – In the heart of Larchmont Manor, authentic vintage home with an incredible 1035 square feet wrap around porch, perfect for Summer outdoor living and ideal for large gatherings. Voluminous rooms filled with natural light, high ceilings, lot of charm and period architectural details. The cozy entry foyer with original wall paneling […]

c. 1780
  • Selkirk, New York
  • $749,000

The Jacobias Mull house, with over two hundred years of Dutch history steeped within its walls, sits serenely above the west bank of the Hudson River. This true riverfront property with approximately a thousand feet of shoreline & 32 acres of surrounding mature woodlands, is listed on the national & state historic registries. Travel back […]

c. 1820
  • Cape Vincent, New York
  • $950,000

RIVER LIVING! YOU WILL FORGET TO COUNT THE DAYS in this PICTURESQUE and METICULOUSLY cared for YEAR ROUND on THE RIVER IN THE 1000 ISLANDS. Cape Vincent Village home Restored and Updated with detailed attention to maintain the classic elegance of 1820’s era Greek Revival style. Surrounded by beautifully manicured lawns and gardens this 4 […]

c. 1886
  • Bay Shore, New York
  • $749,000

Rare find in the Historical Bay District of Bay Shore. Magnificent Classic Victorian built in 1886 loaded with Old World Charm with original character and elegance maintained. Enormous wrap around porch, Turret, original doors and doorknobs, original hand blown curved glass windows, and stunning stained glass on second floor, wood floors, beautiful moldings, high ceilings, […]

c. 1852
  • Westernville, New York
  • $700,000

Nestled in the quaint, historic town of Westernville, sits one of the most special properties you will ever see. Over 7 years in the making, every square inch of this former church has been meticulously RENOVATED, RESTORED & REBUILT. Not a detail has been spared, which is evident the moment you step foot through the […]

c. 1932
  • Elba, New York
  • $499,900

Watch the Virtual Tour here! True Craftsman home known as the “Porter Mansion of Elba” This stately home took over 2+years to build! This home boasts large beautiful rooms, gorgeous woodwork, wide pegged hardwoods and featuring intricate crown moldings. Dining room has 2 arched built-in must see glassed china cabinets. Sunken living room has 3 […]

c. 1873
  • Cazenovia, New York
  • $39,900

This Italianate farmhouse was built by Jabez Abell in 1870 and comes with .75 acres. Listed on the historic Register and ready to be restored. Loads of early architectural details still intact and stored onsite. The property qualifies for both federal and state grants or tax breaks to undertake the restoration process. Important historic features […]

c. 1800
  • Burnt Hills, New York
  • $1,495,000

Charm abounds in this center-chimney colonial on ten acres Saratoga County, NY. Originally constructed circa 1800 in Clifton Park, in approximately 1986 the house was carefully disassembled, parts and pieces numbered, and moved to its current location so it could be rebuilt nestled into an apple orchard in Burnt Hills, but with a modern foundation, […]

c. 1793
  • Greenfield Center, New York
  • $850,000

This house has remained in the same two families since it was built, It has never been offered for sale before now! 10 minutes to Downtown Saratoga Springs. Wonderful Farmhouse built in 1793! 4 bdrms, 2 full baths, 2 fireplaces. Wide plank floors, custom kitchen built with wood from the property. House has the potential […]

c. 1816
  • Unadilla, New York
  • $237,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Classic Federal-style Brick Beauty in the town of Unadilla. Built in 1816, with bricks that were made on site, the home was once a tavern on the Catskill Turnpike. It now boasts modern updates in a lovingly preserved package. This 3 bedroom, 3 bath home retains all the charm of […]

c. 1922
  • Stony Point, New York
  • $630,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Welcome to the “Evergreen House” a stunning classic Arts & Crafts colonial build in 1922, bringing old world charm coupled with today’s amenities.  Situated above the evergreen trees, we begin our house tour through the gated property.  Once thru the entry foyer we start with a handsome living room with […]

c. 1932
  • Piermont, New York
  • $995,000

Renovated & Expanded Dutch Colonial within walking distance to galleries, restaurants, shops, farmers market, parks, hiking, kayaking & more! Enter the front yard & step onto the porch – Imagine yourself relaxing in the swing or enjoying your morning coffee. Enter the house and appreciate its craftsmanship, charm and warmth. Wander through the formal living […]

c. 1915
  • Katonah, New York
  • $775,000

If you love historic settings, exposed beams, stone walls, magnolias, wisteria and more, this circa 1915 Carriage House with Barn is for you! Interior and exterior boast original stone walls, red-brick and wide-plank flooring, barn-timber walls, hand-hewn beams. Imagine an idyllic time when horse-drawn carriages brought guests to this charming home bedecked with candles in […]

c. 1914
  • Bronxville, New York
  • $3,100,000

Stately in appearance, inviting in character, this iconic 1914 brick Georgian is defined by its crisp architectural symmetry and an unbeatable location. It is ideally situated in Bronxville’s coveted Lawrence Park Hilltop enclave, minutes’ walk from the village, school, and shops. The classic center hall layout lends itself to formal or casual entertaining in rooms […]

c. 1878
  • Sea Cliff, New York
  • $875,000

Enjoy Gorgeous Sunsets From This Historic Harbor Side Home! Steps Away To Our Private Beach ! Close Proximity To All 5 Of Sea Cliff’s Restaurants! Original Carriage House Of The First Mayor Of Sea Cliff! Wonderful Year Round Water Views! Fully Fenced In Yard Providing Security & Protection! Granite Counters & High End Stainless Appliances.Great […]

Charming country church in Upstate NY is a mixed use building w endless possibilities for living, performance, studio, event or commercial kitchen space. The former sanctuary has cathedral ceiling, hardwood floors, a low stage and movable pews. Six large windows let the light shine in. Former enclosed choir loft is perfect for office and/or storage. […]

c. 1840
  • Canandaigua, New York
  • $739,000

1840 Inn On the Main located in downtown Canandaigua is one of the largest & most impressive Bed and Breakfasts in the area – Ranked #16 for the best Travelers Choice Award in the US! Bursting with charm and is meticulously maintained with quality designed rooms. The guests love the choice of 5 spacious guest […]

c. 1870
  • Kingston, New York
  • $445,555

Escape to the Country! You will never want to leave this enchanting 1870 cottage totally and tastefully transformed by The owner/artist. Nothing was left unturned. Attention to detail incorporating original woodwork. Enter from the gravel flower lined walkway to the covered entrance. The kitchen will wow you with tin ceilings, handmade wood trim by local […]

c. 1878
  • Greenport, New York
  • $2,200,000

Truly One of A Kind. This Whimsical, Historic & Romantic Bay Front Home with 100 ft of Cement Bulkhead Awaits Your Updates to Make it Uniquely Yours, Fabulous & Elegant-An Exclusive Opportunity to Live In Your Very Own Decorator Ready Castle! A Rare Chance to Personally Modernize Without Sacrificing its Original Charm and Historic Integrity. […]

c. 1907
  • Huntington, New York
  • $975,000

Beautiful historic Charles Street House, two blocks from Huntington Village, perched high and situated on .28 professionally landscaped acres with specimen trees, a tapestry of colorful flowers, rose gardens, fountain, green house and shed. Majestic residence featuring a covered front porch, huge center hall, high ceilings, custom millwork, a spacious living room, formal dining room, […]

c. 1855
  • Westernville, New York
  • $1,100,000

It’s not often that a property like this becomes available.​ Historically linked to General William Floyd this four story brick mansion could be your next home.​.​.​or Bed & Breakfast! The current owners are using four of the bedrooms and the third floor has five more bedrooms ready for you to make your own. With river […]

All the Cool Kids are Doing it.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.


Monthly Page Views


Combined Social Media Followers


Newsletter Subscribers

Compare listings

Follow us @cheapoldhouses + launching on HGTV & Discovery+, Monday, August 9th at 9pm ET