Old Houses for Sale in New York

Old Houses for Sale in New York

c. 1903
  • Tannersville, New York
  • $3,750,000

Take a ride in the scenic mountains near Tannersville NY and you will have the opportunity to wander down a magical drive that will transport you back in time to the Golden Age of The Catskills, and to Caddam Hill. Once the home of the famous actress Maude Adams, you can hear echoes of a […]

c. 1930
  • Poughkeepsie, New York
  • $525,000

This Hooker Avenue gem, tucked away behind a row of mature trees, is simply stunning. Gorgeous stone walls and perfectly manicured landscaping frame the carefully crafted bluestone stairs which lead to this majestic beauty. The house sits atop a gentle hill. From the expansive front porch, enjoy exquisite views of treetops, church steeples and the […]

c. 1870
  • Sharon Springs, New York
  • $1,200,000

Historic Hotel for Sale in Sharon Springs, NY “The Roseboro” 210 Main Street, Sharon Springs, NY  13459 Listed at $1.2M For Sale By Owner 45,000 Sq feet / 13 acres m/l   Historic Hotel for Sale in Sharon Springs, NY “The Roseboro” 210 Main Street, Sharon Springs, NY  13459 Listed at $1.2M   45,000 Sq […]

c. 1720
  • Kerhonkson, New York
  • $1,100,000

Steeped in history, this property’s 2.9 acres were originally part of a Lenape settlement, before French Huguenot refugees, descendants of the King’s guards at Fontainebleau, built the farmhouse, one of the first French Huguenot Houses in the region, in the 1680s from fir, chestnut and local stone. With two feet thick walls, and eyebrow and […]

7 Bedroom Elegant Home – Near Syracuse University – offered for sale, as a home or a business – or both! This opportunity won’t last. The eminently popular 12 Room – Iron Lion Inn is being offered for sale for the first time as fully and fabulously furnished with its eclectic assortment of Chippendale & […]

c. 1885
  • Roxbury, New York
  • $725,000

Welcome to Vega Valley Farmhouse, a sprawling 3460 square foot historic farmhouse in the wide and peaceful Denver Vega Valley. The home dates to 1885, with beautiful original details, and thoughtful updates throughout, making for a fantastic family retreat, or epic rental property. Enter double doors into a wood clad mudroom entryway, with plenty of […]

c. 1743
  • Windham, New York
  • $875,000

The first Dutch settlers to New Amsterdam (later named New York) brought with them a distinct style of stone homebuilding exemplified in the early Dutch stone houses of the Hudson Valley. These beautiful and rare homes are seldom restored to their original look, and this 1743 house, home to many Revolutionary War soldiers, is one […]

c. 1860
  • Clifton Springs, New York
  • $449,900

Step back in time to this 1860 Victorian in the village of Clifton Springs with an abundance of natural woodwork. Well-cared for and preserved with original bathroom tiling, tin ceilings, parquet flooring, beautiful archways, marble fireplace, new wall-paper that fits the time-frame, and more. This home is over 4, 000 square feet with 5 beds […]

c. 1975
  • Millerton, New York
  • $1,495,000

A jewel in the heart of Millbrook’s Hunt Country, Highgrove Cottage is beautifully sited on six spectacular acres offering ultimate privacy in the coveted Smithfield Valley. The house has spectacular views in all directions and is surrounded by large estates and farms protected by the Dutchess Land Conservancy. The elegant main house has been meticulously […]

Welcome to this “historic” Mid-Town Kingston DIY home built in 1890 with 4 beds, 1 bath on a spacious single-family corner lot in up-and-coming Mid-Town neighborhood very near the happening Stockade District of Kingston. The house features long lost findings like beautiful trim and architectural victorian details, unusually tall ceilings and its potential shines through […]

c. 1850
  • Poughkeepsie, New York
  • $399,900

53 Spackenkill Rd, Poughkeepsie Twp, NY 12603: Welcome, Bienvenue, Bienvenido to 53 Spackenckill Rd, a historic home owned in the mid 19th century by W.A. Davies, a practicing lawyer and president of the then Farmers and Manufacturers’ National Bank of Poughkeepsie. His family has a storied history in the local community still being felt to […]

c. 1906
  • Belle Terre, New York
  • $5,495,000

530ft Private Beach Frontage frames this Timeless and Elegant Property, with the most water frontage in Belle Terre makes it the ultimate gem of Belle Terre. This Historical Estate, originally built for Ralph Peters in 1906, has been stunningly renovated to showcase the original details complete with all today’s modern necessities. The almost 6000 sqft […]

We don’t use the term “paradise” very often but this mountaintop 1900s Victorian farmhouse on 90+ acres — including endless meadows, swimming/boating and water garden ponds, a creek, a cider apple orchard, and wide open views — is as close to a Catskills paradise as you can get!    Whether you’re cozying up in one of […]

c. 1800
  • Chappaqua, New York
  • $1,499,000

Distinctive and admired 5 bedroom Chappaqua Landmark The Dickinson-Conklin Home is freshly painted inside and out, new roof and many recent updates located on an estate-like property just a short stroll by sidewalk to the vibrant village of Chappaqua. 275 Quaker is a spacious and light-filled home with great flow that offers an elegant living […]

c. 1927
  • Bronxville, New York
  • $1,995,000

Set majestically on a stunning acre of landscaped property overlooking Siwanoy Golf Course, this strikingly handsome Lewis Bowman Tudor is the epitome of elegance and grandeur. From its original stone facade to its prominent slate roof, the curb appeal here registers at 11! Inside, the oversized receiving hall features its own wood burning fireplace, beamed […]

Privacy, space, and grandeur with infinite possibilities come perfectly packaged in beautiful Bronxville village! This gracious 1920s Georgian colonial is in a prestigious estate neighborhood on a magnificent oversized lot — one of the largest in all of Bronxville. Located just 15 miles from midtown Manhattan, it promises the best of all worlds: quiet seclusion […]

c. 1927
  • Pelham, New York
  • $1,776,000

On a quiet block in the center of the historic Pelham Heights neighborhood, this impeccable Center Hall Colonial has been loved and updated to perfection. Double foyer entry, living room with fireplace and adjoining, square family room, and formal dining room. Consistent with the home’s historic character, the renovated kitchen (2016) includes custom cabinetry, soap […]

c. 1865
  • Cornwall On Hudson, New York
  • $1,145,000

Welcome to the Ephraim Tompkins House, Circa 1865.Nestled in the heart of historic Cornwall-on-Hudson, 12 Idlewild Avenue is a true masterpiece of Second Empire architecture. This majestic home, with its iconic mansard roof, seamlessly blends old-world charm with modern-day luxury. Meticulously restored and maintained, it’s in turnkey condition, ready to be your dream residence.As you […]

c. 1862
  • Seneca Falls, New York
  • $750,000

Calling all nature lovers! Hike and explore almost 100 acres of wooded land complete with miles of trails. Kayak on your own large pond, complete with 2 islands, and a plethora of wildlife. This unique, historic, Italiante architecture home has been meticulously restored to preserve its original character and charm while carefully integrating modern amenities.  It has over 1000 […]

Killearn. A place of remarkable beauty, this exceptional country estate is perfect for today’s style of living and entertaining. Offering 68.3 pastoral acres highlighted by sweeping vistas of the gently rolling Hudson Valley countryside, the 1832 residence (completely renovated and updated with every luxury amenity) features well-proportioned living spaces; including a richly detailed and sun-filled […]

Privacy, Property, Proximity! Such a unique offering — this stately, renovated 1920s Colonial is offered with 2 lots (25 and 22 Hilltop) for a combined 2.48 acres at the end of a coveted lane with rolling lawns, a pristine pond and panoramic views of the Apawamis Club, Harrison Meadows Country Club and Westchester Country Club […]

c. 1872
  • Groton, New York
  • $749,000

This elegant Second Empire Victorian home is located at 118 Park Street on private serene grounds with an in-ground pool & 2 barns. Historical writings of this property state it has been recognized by different names over its long history including Mansion, Castle, & Terrace Place. Built by Sampson Williams/1875 on an 8ft rise at […]

Welcome to the historic stone Hasbrouck House, a true gem dating back to 1846 — minutes from the town center of Highland, which the New York Times called, “A Small Community with a Feel-Good Spirit.” Situated majestically high on the lot on a 1.4-acre oasis that abuts the Hudson Valley Rail Trail — yet just […]

c. 1920
  • Bronx, New York
  • $1,250,000

First Open House Sunday 10/29 11am-1pm Nestled in the historic neighborhood of Fieldston in Riverdale, Bronx is this stately brick Dutch Colonial home. Built over a century ago in 1920, the classic design and thoughtful features offer an incredible retreat just minutes from Manhattan. Standout features include the attached garage, wood-burning fireplace, a large, landscaped […]

All the Cool Kids are Doing it.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.


Monthly Page Views


Combined Social Media Followers


Newsletter Subscribers

Compare listings

Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !