Compare Listings


Ideal Bed & Breakfast

Westernville, New York

Gorgeous home includes river frontage and access to the Delta Reservoir.


Old Houses

for Sale in

New York

Old Houses for Sale in New York

c. 1776
  • Valley Cottage, New York
  • $690,000

“I can’t believe this exists less than an hour from the city”, I thought of my first visit to historic 227 Old Mill Road.  This compound is located in Valley Cottage just minutes away […]

c. 1802
  • Eaton, New York
  • $99,000

Major restoration project available via blind bid. We are seeking a steward for this important historic property. We are soliciting renovation proposals and considering bids with best renovation plans starting […]

c. 1899
  • Whitehall, New York
  • $500,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! 1899 Whitehall Armory for sale via blind bid. Soliciting offers for real property only at minimum bid $500, 000 plus 3% buyers premium. Armory designed […]

c. 1910
  • Hudson, New York
  • $1,650,000

The “Five Double Five” is a historically significant and architecturally iconic building on central Warren Street. Built as the “Peoples’ Department Store” in 1910, it was constructed with 28-foot long […]

c. 1800
  • Pound Ridge, New York
  • $699,000

Landmark Azuba Raymond House – Beautiful turn key circa 1800 antique farmhouse. Scandinavian inspired interior design with wide plank floors, minimalist concept, exposed beams and charming details. Main level has […]

c. 1875
  • Boonville, New York
  • $319,000

Welcome to 201 Main Street. This beautiful Victorian home has been lovingly maintained and run as a successful Bed & Breakfast for the past 25 years by two separate owners. […]

c. 1946
  • Nyack, New York
  • $469,000

Lovely 1940’s cottage. First time on the market in over 50 years. This charming home is in the heart of Nyack. Three bedrooms, large full bathroom, living room with fireplace, […]

c. 1707
  • Napanoch, New York
  • $549,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! This fully restored antique home dates to 1707, upgraded with intricate details toward historic preservation, beauty and the tasteful integration of modern comforts. Come, walk […]

c. 1870
  • Kingston, New York
  • $445,555

Escape to the Country! You will never want to leave this enchanting 1870 cottage totally and tastefully transformed by The owner/artist. Nothing was left unturned. Attention to detail incorporating original […]

c. 1735
  • Pound Ridge, New York
  • $599,000

Lovingly maintained Jones Homestead c. 1735 antique farmhouse, one of the oldest homes in Pound Ridge. Sits proudly and conveniently on the border of N Stamford CT. Full of period […]

c. 1830
  • Fayetteville, New York
  • $525,000

RARE OPPORTUNITY to own a stunning 1830’s Italianate Masterpiece. The 12 room, 7-bedroom, 4 full-bathroom home is nestled on a half acre right inside the bucolic Village of Fayetteville, New […]

c. 1940
  • Glenford, New York
  • $1,300,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Ashokan Reservoir Renaissance — What was once a rustic mountain cabin with a fieldstone fireplace has become an artisan owner’s piece de resistance. Now the […]

c. 1836
  • Ancramdale, New York
  • $649,000

Explore the many options available for this property located in the business district of the charming hamlet of Ancramdale. Currently configured as a 4 bedroom, 4.5 bath plus rental apartment […]

c. 1922
  • Rochester, New York
  • $879,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! This iconic elegant home on East Avenue has anchored the celebrated Park Avenue district for nearly a century. Designed in 1922 by Rochester Architect Herbert […]

c. 1790
  • Accord, New York
  • $775,000

A rare and unique opportunity to own a piece of history in the Hudson Valley this recently remodeled home was built in 1790 and is listed on the National Register […]

c. 1870
  • Attica, New York
  • $367,500

Watch the Virtual Tour here! This stately Victorian Italianate in the Village of Attica, NY is a home that has been meticulously restored & maintained to its original elegance & […]

c. 1867
  • Garrison, New York
  • $4,995,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Situated on a rise surrounded by nearly 20 acres of mature hardwoods and rolling grass meadows, and directly beneath a rugged Revolutionary War fortification known […]

c. 1791
  • Old Chatham, New York
  • $1,725,000

Drive down the winding, dirt back road to this fabulous property in Old Chatham, which consists of 18.6 secluded acres. The terraced land and a pond sit on one sideof […]

c. 1878
  • Greenport, New York
  • $2,200,000

Truly One of A Kind. This Whimsical, Historic & Romantic Bay Front Home with 100 ft of Cement Bulkhead Awaits Your Updates to Make it Uniquely Yours, Fabulous & Elegant-An […]

Watch the Virtual Tour here! A home and a lifestyle. A rare and unique opportunity to own one of only 7 residences in the River House, a converted 1907 Limestone […]

c. 1840
  • Rhinebeck, New York
  • $1,475,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Opportunities abound with this 6 bedroom 6 bath historic 1840 Federal known as the Veranda House. This home offers old world charm, updated kitchen with […]

c. 1766
  • Brooklyn, New York
  • $2,900,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Own a piece of American History, New York History, Brooklyn History which has been occupied by only 3 families! The Wyckoff- Bennett- Mont Homestead is […]

c. 1935
  • Catskill, New York
  • $485,000

The Catskill Antique — where one acre feels like ten. The circa 1935 cottage sits nicely back from the road with no neighbors in sight next to a large, finished […]

c. 1845
  • McDonough, New York
  • $1,000,000

The circa 1845 William Johnson house is a historic country estate on 226 dynamic and picturesque acres set in the heart of the most magical, bucolic countryside in all of […]

Old House

Real Estate

Agents in

New York

Old House

Real Estate Agents

in New York

Weld Realty

maiken (at) weldrealty (dot) com
(845) 596-8059

Michael DeRosa Exchange, LLC

kelli (at) buy-design-sell (dot) com
(315) 706-9692

Weld Realty

laura (at) weldrealty (dot) com
(914) 588-6878

Purdy Realty LLC
Burnt Hills

lconrad (at) purdyrealty (dot) com
(518) 229-4943

Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty
Locust Valley

christinaporter (at) danielgale (dot) com
(516) 759-4800

Vinyard’s Choice

roland (at) bardrocks (dot) com
(518) 673-3212

Keller Williams Upstate New York Properties

bholscher (at) kw (dot) com
(607) 376-7509

Results Realtors

richgetsresults (at) gmail (dot) com
(585) 737-3000

R2M Realty, Inc.

Kenyatta (at) Ready2Mov (dot) com
(845) 358-2000

Garrison Realty Group, Inc.

garrisonrealtygroup (at) gmail (dot) com
(845) 656-3488

Howard Hanna

luxuryhomesbyo (at) gmail (dot) com
(585) 905-8374

Patricia A. Hinkein Realty

kate (at) worthpreserving (dot) com
(212) 380-8612

Gillani Homes Inc.
Staten Island

michaelcrane63 (at) gmail (dot) com
(917) 583-5501

All The

Cool Kids

Are Doing


List an Old House

for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.


Monthly Page Views


Combined Social Media Followers


Newsletter Subscribers