Old Houses for Sale in New York

Old Houses for Sale in New York

c. 1900
  • Nyack, New York
  • $599,000

This delightful village colonial across from the majestic Hudson, features a sparkling river view in the morning light that is a slice of heaven! Circa 1900 farm house, nestled on the banks of the Hudson River Valley and in the heart of Nyack village, has 2 bedrooms 1.5 baths and a spacious open floor plan […]

c. 1848
  • Gallatin, New York
  • $449,000

Beautifully restored and updated, this classic farmhouse sits on a serene country road awaiting its new owner. Well located in an area of picturesque and protected farmlands, this ideal country property is just a stone’s throw from the majestic Roe Jan stream. A large country kitchen with a walk-in pantry sits, ready to stock, with […]

c. 1835
  • Cooperstown, New York
  • $1,200,000

The White House Inn is Cooperstown, New York’s favorite bed & breakfast inn! This special property features eight guest rooms in the heart of Cooperstown’s Historic District, just three blocks from the National Baseball Hall of Fame. The renowned Glimmerglass Opera Festival, sparkling Otsego Lake and a host of museums, galleries, shops and restaurants are minutes […]

c. 1910
  • Armonk, New York
  • $1,175,000

This quintessential country colonial on prestigious Round Hill Road is full of character and charm boasting several wood beams, wide plank floors and 3 wood burning fireplaces in the award winning Byram Hills school district. Over 3,000 square feet setback on 2 beautiful acres with a patio and spacious yard. Main floor offers many comfortable […]

c. 1900
  • Stuyvesant, New York
  • $1,495,000

Welcome to “Requa House“, available for the first time in four decades. Architecturally significant colonial revival, listed on The State and National Registers of Historic Places, designed by renowned Hudson architect Henry Moul, and built in 1900 for the Requa family. Surrounded by 34 acres of pastoral views, mature trees and perennial gardens. The house […]

“The traveler finds himself [or herself] suddenly inspired with new hope, on catching view of the four-pronged top of the meeting house; assured of having discovered where civilization abounds and where piety asserts its empire.” Want to escape from it all? This soaring 1825 account describes a view of the magnificent First Congregational Church of […]

Beautiful Historic Victorian in the heart of Chaumont Village, close and within walking distance of local amenities! All major upkeep renovations completed, to include newer electrical, plumbing, roofs on the main home and barn, siding on the home and barn and the foundation has been repointed! The home has been upkept beautifully, with all of […]

c. 1850
  • Cornwall, New York
  • $600,000

Restored and renovated Country Farmhouse Colonial lives like a 6 Bedroom. Renovated kitchen with granite counters and breakfast bar, stainless appliances leads to screened-in porch. Formal dining room with fireplace opens to large deck. Formal living room has show-stopper fireplace with built-in shelves. Library/Home Office with half bath is adjacent to Living Room. Potential In-Law/first […]

This historic country retreat, a two-hour drive from New York City, is nestled among New York’s beautiful Catskill Mountains, on ten acres of sweeping manicured lawns and rolling hills. The stately Federal style house, with Greek Revival details, was one of architect A. J. Davis’ early works.  It was built around 1829 by one of […]

c. 1900
  • Mohawk, New York
  • $299,900

Turn of the Century Landmark Colonial on over 11 acres of serene country beauty. Over 3,500 sq ft tastefully renovated with newer kitchen with island, and updated baths. Stately elegant rooms offer fine taste and classic amenities. Spacious living room with fireplace. Large dining room. Eat-in kitchen with desk area. Main floor laundry. Gleaming floors. […]

c. 1870
  • Warwick, New York
  • $549,900

Circa 1870 Colonial, the “Amity Parsonage” is a mainstay in the Hamlet of Amity in the Town of Warwick, NY. This special home has seen updates and renovations throughout the years to bring it up to modern times while keeping its old house character one would expect in a Circa 1870 home ~ character that […]

c. 1820
  • Skaneateles, New York
  • $1,950,000

Temple Prospect Farm offers 2.6 acres on the east side of Skaneateles Lake, 3.3 miles from the village, and is one of the oldest surviving farmsteads in the Skaneateles Valley & one of the few still retaining the original Greek Revival character. Temple Prospect Farm is a hallmark of Upstate New York & specifically of […]

c. 1802
  • Cooperstown, New York
  • $1,200,000

Beyond the wrought iron fence, stands one of Cooperstown’s finest village homes, known as the Worthington House, built in 1802 with 5, 200 square feet of living space. Built by Ralph Worthington, this house is an excellent example of the early Federal style in the village. It was enlarged by the builder’s son, John Richard […]

c. 1910
  • Nyack, New York
  • $1,190,000

Grand and elegant South Nyack Village Victorian close to center of town with dining, shopping & more. Set back on beautifully landscaped property w/private gardens, mature flowering plants, shrubs & trees, created by prof landscape designer. Generous front porch opens to over 3600 sqft of original details & restored finishes. Formal living & dining rooms […]

c. 1930
  • Chappaqua, New York
  • $3,600,000

Located on 4-acres of private park-like property in sought after Lawrence Farms East, this magnificent, gated stone Colonial offers at home entertaining and relaxed living with a refreshing pool, a flexible 2-bedroom guest suite and a lower-level wine tasting room with a stone fireplace. The front-to-back entry opens to a well-proportioned living room with walls […]

c. 1765
  • Kinderhook, New York
  • $2,950,000

With a colorful provenance dating back to the American Revolution and the distinction of housing British General Burgoyne after his defeat at Saratoga, this iconic brick Georgian manor creates a remarkable setting for today’s style of living. With nearly 7 acres in the center of one of the most charming villages of the Hudson Valley, […]

c. 1905
  • Cambridge, New York
  • $925,000

Located in the victorian Village of Cambridge, New York, The Rice Mansion Inn was built in 1903 for seed tycoon of-the-era, Jerome B. Rice, and his wife Laura who owned the Rice Seed Company located across the street. Cambridge is located in the foothills of the Adirondack (NY) and Green (VT) Mountains and less than […]

c. 1790
  • Salem, New York
  • $1,333,000

Wilson Hollow Farm is a 250 acre farm/cattle ranch snuggled in the foothills of the Green Mountains of Vermont. This Upstate NY historic home has four bedrooms and 2 baths w/modern kitchen. 3 beautifully restored outbuildings. Perfect for your guests, animals or hobbies/art studio. Raspberries, blueberries, grapes, and an apple orchard for sustainable living. 2 […]

c. 1902
  • Larchmont, New York
  • $3,295,000

Mediterranean-chic, just steps to the beach & LI Sound! A rare architectural beauty in heart of Larchmont Manor that enjoys winter water views & lush .44-acre oasis in park-like setting w. fruit trees. Timeless allure w. glorious Spanish influences – 3 levels of sunlit fluid interiors, all refinished floors including herringbone, high ceilings & beautiful […]

c. 1923
  • Richfield Springs, New York
  • $895,000

Stately & Elegant Gentleman’s Farm. This historic property checks EVERY box for the refined buyer. 12 Meticulous acres with beautifully cultivated gardens surround the home allowing for tranquil views from each of the many windows. Welcoming patios, verandas and seating areas are tucked into every corner enabling full enjoyment of the property from diverse vantage […]

c. 1803
  • Valley Cottage, New York
  • $739,000

Love Old Homes??? Circa 1800’s Colonial Situated on a .91 Acre Serene Lot on Historic Old Mill Road. A Nature Lover’s Dream. The 2300+ Square Foot Residence Comes Complete with a Renovated Barn, Great for Work or Recreation. The Rooms of this Home Boast Original Architectural Details & Moldings and Hardwood Floors Throughout. The Kitchen […]

c. 1927
  • Bronxville, New York
  • $3,750,000

A stunning country estate just 15 miles from midtown Manhattan. This magnificent French Normandy Tudor is a spectacular find, presiding over 1.5-acres of exquisitely private property in Bronxville’s Lawrence Park West. Steeped in history, designed by noted architects Delano & Aldrich, who also built Rockefeller’s Kykuit. For all its magnificence, this stately granite home exudes […]

c. 1837
  • East Patchogue, New York
  • $899,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Welcome to The Smith Rourke House! This beautiful home built in 1837 is on the National Registry of Historic Homes and features exquisite details such as Greek revival columns, dental moldings, 2 story pilasters, hand carved fireplace mantels, 10′ ceilings, inlaid plaster crown moldings, wide plank hardwood floors, a fully […]

c. 1913
  • Sea Cliff, New York
  • $2,890,000

Built in 1913 by the same architect that designed the Frick mansion, Westways is a magical oasis 25 miles east of NYC. Nestled into 1.6 sloping acres overlooking the Sound and surrounded by old growth trees and luscious landscaping, the estate invites you into a state of tranquility and private luxury. An expansive flagstone patio […]

All the Cool Kids are Doing it.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.


Monthly Page Views


Combined Social Media Followers


Newsletter Subscribers

Compare listings

Follow us @cheapoldhouses + launching on HGTV & Discovery+, Monday, August 9th at 9pm ET