Old Houses for Sale in New York

Old Houses for Sale in New York

c. 1832
  • Madrid, New York
  • $529,000

A one-of-a-kind home on at least two fronts: architecture and vista! Nestled between two worlds, the front of the home appears in charming black and white vignettes of downtown Madrid throughout its long history—while the backyard opens to a stunning riverfront view, bordered only by parkland and undeveloped shoreline on both sides. This historic home […]

c. 1790
  • West Charlton, New York
  • $625,000

Discover an extraordinary combination of modern country living and the tradition and character of a historic home in this 235-year old colonial farmhouse in southern Saratoga County. Set majestically on 36 acres of woods, meadows, and gardens, this home offers four bedrooms, inspiring period details, and a plethora of indoor and outdoor entertaining spaces to […]

c. 1695
  • Germantown, New York
  • $2,499,000

This historic house is a timeless beauty. Ice skate on the pond, garden in the greenhouse, and fish and swim in the creek, which borders the property on its south side. Looking for a meditative practice? Stroll the orchard, practice your art in one of the many outbuildings perfect for a studio, or read a […]

Knight Homestead is tucked into one of the most quietly extraordinary spots in the region. Along the property line, a series of cascading waterfalls creates what might be the most spectacular water feature imaginable, both visually and sonically. The 5-acre parcel is bordered on two sides by protected DEC bald eagle conservation land, ensuring enduring […]

c. 1870
  • Bethel, New York
  • $4,750,000

Fraser Settlement Legacy Estate – 417 Pristine Acres in the peaceful town of Bethel, NY A once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own a piece of Catskills history: this extraordinary 417-acre estate, preserved through generations since 1808, represents one of the last great pristine tracts in the region. Nestled along a quiet winding road just 90 minutes from […]

c. 1850
  • Little Falls, New York
  • $695,000

Rarely does a true architectural gem like this come to market. This Italianate home features classic 19th century details such as the prominent cupola, intricate corbels and tall, graceful windows that flood the home with natural light. Every detail has been thoughtfully preserved. All mechanical systems including electric, plumbing and heating have been expertly updated […]

c. 1860
  • City of Kingston, New York
  • $8,350,000

Setting and History Ulster Landing is a storied and magnificent former Livingston estate established in the early 1800s, perched on 34 acres above the Hudson River with far-reaching views and more than half a mile of river frontage. The property was sold to the Livingston’s at the turn of the 19th century, shortly after which […]

c. 1910
  • West Hills, Huntington, New York
  • $1,910,000

Uniquely beautiful and modestly aristocratic, this 1910 Long Island farmhouse is serenely tucked away in Huntington’s West Hills, nestled on an incredible 2 acres with breathtaking views of your own spectacular park-like grounds.  Designed by architect Julian Peabody (Peabody,Wilson & Brown) who was noted for graceful elongated design, this lawyer-equestrian-gentleman farmer’s home features 20 rooms, […]

Tucked behind wrought-iron gates in one of the Bronx’s most exclusive waterfront enclaves, this grand 7,600 sqft stone estate offers the rarest blend of timeless architecture, luxury amenities, and resort-style outdoor living — all perched on the serene shoreline of the Long Island Sound. From the moment you step onto the sweeping front steps and […]

Visit the Open House on Sunday, 7/13 from 12pm-2pm! Welcome to the Briggs House, an architecturally rich 4-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom residence in the heart of Hyde Park’s esteemed Main Street Historic District – an enclave known for its beautifully preserved 19th-century character and heritage. Given the Neighborhood Core zoning and over half-acre lot, the Town of […]

c. 1859
  • Livingston, New York
  • $2,195,000

Hawkskill is a rare offering- a quintessential Hudson Valley farmhouse set far back off a country road amidst 40 serene acres and accessed by a long private tree lined driveway. In the front of the house, which stands on a rise framed out by stately trees, a bubbling brook winds its way through a meadow […]

c. 1920
  • Franklinville, New York
  • $375,000

Step into a breathtaking fusion of history and modern luxury. This extraordinary 8-bedroom home is a fully restored and reimagined historic church, now a grand private residence with unmatched character and elegance. Every detail has been thoughtfully preserved and enhanced to create a truly one-of-a-kind living experience. At the heart of the home is the […]

c. 1853
  • Saratoga Springs, New York
  • $1,749,000

Meticulously preserved historic home seamlessly blends timeless elegance with modern luxury. The property boasts an elaborate and professionally designed yard that’s truly one of a kind with a waterfall feature that brings the tranquil sound of flowing water to your doorstep. This creates outdoor living spaces perfect for entertaining or quiet reflection. This rare gem […]

c. 1892
  • Cazenovia, New York
  • $3,950,000

Extraordinary 1892 Stanford White colonial revival Victorian home, set on 3.3 acres & 260’ of level lakefront, just a short walk from the village. The impeccably restored exterior reflects its historic grandeur & welcomes w/ timeless elegance. Inside, the grand foyer sets a tone of refined opulence. The living room’s Venetian plaster walls & gold […]

c. 1855
  • Staten Island , New York
  • $1,599,999

Click Here to View Property Brochure Step inside one of New York City’s most extraordinary landmarked historic homes. Built in 1855 on the grounds of the legendary Rose & Crown Tavern, where British General William Howe once read the Declaration of Independence to his troops. This grand Italianate villa was originally commissioned by a Staten […]

c. 1911
  • Nyack, New York
  • $649,900

Visit the Open House on Saturday 6/28 12:30-2:30PM and Sunday 6/28 11-1PM Welcome to the Cedar Hill Haven, a tastefully and completely restored Colonial nestled in the vibrant and highly sought-after Village of Nyack. This 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath home offers the perfect blend of timeless character and modern comfort—all close to the river, shops, […]

Historic 3-story, 5-bay Federal style mansion circa 1827 home originally owned by William Swain, a famous Nantucket Sea Captain reputed to have speared a whale himself on one of his last voyages before settling permanently to the completed four-level mansion in 1827. Many improvements have been recently made to this property, including foundation repair, gutters, […]

c. 1900
  • Mendon, New York
  • $329,900

Charming Honeoye Falls Victorian Gem! This beloved village treasure is finally available! Beautifully maintained and thoughtfully renovated, this 4-bedroom home blends timeless character with modern updates—truly move-in ready. Step inside to find original hardwood floors throughout, a formal living room, elegant parlor, and spacious dining room. The custom kitchen, completed in 2023, features new appliances […]

c. 1907
  • Hague, New York
  • $2,300,000

Once in a lifetime opportunity to own a stunning ”Adirondack Great Camp’’ on the shores of Lake George. ”Chipwick,’’ a circa 1907 shingle style Queen Anne Victorian has been in the same family for nearly 100 years. Enjoy breathtaking views of the water and approx. 137’ of sandy shoreline. Property features the 5,366 sq ft […]

Old House Lovers: your rare opportunity to own a piece of Hudson Valley history has arrived. Long before Croton-on-Hudson became one of Westchester’s most sought-after river towns, A.P. Gardiner – an early 1900s gentleman from New York City – chose this very hillside for his sprawling country estate. ”Hessian Hills” served as a seasonal refuge […]

The “Cloisterie”, one of the county’s grandest historic homes,  built in 1860 as a wealthy family’s residence, many years afterwards an adult home, it sold 16 years ago when the proprietor retired and it reverted to a private residence. It is now for sale again due to an untimely death in the family. There are […]

The Granby, circa 2002. Inspired by the work of master builders centuries earlier, this custom built unique home is an original work of art, designed by New England architect Lloyd Kirley . Historically correct proportions, form, scale and detail, establish an air of authenticity of its own. This classic colonial combines a spacious and comfortable […]

c. 1917
  • Larchmont, New York
  • $3,250,000

This architectural beauty is nestled on a tree-lined corner property in the heart of Larchmont Manor, close to the Village, parks, and the waterfront! This coveted location offers a lifestyle of convenience and seaside charm. Blissfully private and designed for entertaining, this home boasts a wide sun-drenched front terrace overlooking newly landscaped level lawn and […]

c. 1860
  • Buskirk, New York
  • $624,900

c. 1840-1860 Welcoming old homestead, surrounded by protected land trust which will never be developed, among rolling hill views. This historic, tastefully updated  home with kitchen and bathrooms, including soapstone countertops, farmhouse sink, high-end appliances and walk-in pantry. When you drive down this quiet country road full of lush green pastures, you will be experiencing […]

All the Cool Kids are Doing it.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in NY

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

2m

Monthly Page Views

575k

Combined Social Media Followers

55k

Newsletter Subscribers

Compare listings

Compare
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
SUBSCRIBE
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
SUBSCRIBE