Search

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

c. 1966
  • West Orange, New Jersey
  • $1,250,000

 The Belle of the Oldstead neighborhood! Set on a quiet street near South Mountain Reservation, this wonderfully bright home has been transformed through extensive, thoughtful renovations with exceptional attention to quality, design and everyday living. At its heart is a spectacular chef’s kitchen, beautifully conceived and impressively scaled, with custom cabinetry, an expansive island, professional […]

With the scale, craftsmanship and character of another era, this c. 1880s home is distinguished by Italianate influences, bracketed eaves, tall windows and intricate detailing. Three porches, of which two are covered, add to the home’s historic character and overlook the peaceful grounds. Ornate double entry doors open to a grand foyer, where soaring 10-foot […]

c. 1790
  • Lambertville, New Jersey
  • $3,850,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here!   Set beyond a gated entrance paved in reclaimed cobblestone, the Hart–Vorhees Farmstead is one of Hopewell Valley’s most extraordinary country estates—a rare convergence of architectural heritage, world-class gardens, refined equestrian amenities, and nearly ten acres of remarkable privacy. Originally constructed in the 1700s, the property’s iconic stone barn has […]

A rare opportunity to own one of Salem County’s most remarkable preserved farm properties, this extraordinary 64-acre estate offers nearly one-third of a mile of frontage along the Salem River, creating an unmatched setting for recreation, agriculture, and gathering. The landscape is a beautiful blend of open farmland, mature woodlands, and scenic river views, with […]

c. 1900
  • Rocky Hill Borough, New Jersey
  • $649,900

Visit the Open House this Sunday, 8/30 from 1-4pm! Perfectly situated on an expansive double lot with future potential, this exceptional property is located in the heart of the historic Borough of Rocky Hill & is recognized as a contributing home within the Rocky Hill Historic District. Rich in character and timeless appeal, it offers […]

c. 1900
  • Rocky Hill Boro, New Jersey
  • $799,900

Visit the Open House this Sunday, 8/30 from 1-4pm! Beautifully renovated historic Colonial located in the charming Borough of Rocky Hill and served by the highly regarded Montgomery School District. Rich in character and thoughtfully updated, this 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home blends timeless architectural details with modern comforts. Built as the borough’s first school […]

RARE OPPORTUNITY to own a definitive piece of American history with the Van Buskirk Home, the very first residence built in Saddle River. Circa 1707, this historic home is a Red Dutch Stone Colonial sitting on over 2 lush acres, offering modern amenities such as a freeform pool, oversized patios, and a tennis court – […]

Meander through, and this gorgeous stone house appears to have been built for a prosperous landowner. The evidence is everywhere from the unusually generous room sizes, plentiful closets, handsome millwork, and a floor plan intended to impress as much as it was meant to function. Nearly three centuries of history come together in this remarkable […]

A rare opportunity to own one of Kingston’s most historically significant residences, thoughtfully restored to blend timeless character with exceptional modern living. Dating to the mid 1800s and located within Kingston’s Historic District, this remarkable home has undergone an extensive renovation that preserves its architectural integrity while offering the comfort, technology, and craftsmanship expected in […]

c. 1830
  • Glen Gardner, New Jersey
  • $749,000

Steeped in history, this magnificent 1830’s stone Colonial offers a rare blend of historic character, modern amenities, and serene rural living. Tucked back from the road on 6.79 sprawling, landscaped acres, the property boasts approx. 800 feet of pristine river frontage. Imagine spending your evenings sitting by the fire pit right at the edge of […]

c. 1917
  • Dayton, New Jersey
  • $1,099,000

A Home You Don’t Simply Buy… You Become Part Of. There are homes that impress, and then there are homes that leave a legacy. Built in 1917 by local farmer Joseph Duncan and lovingly cared for by only four families in more than a century, 439 Georges Road is one of those rare places where […]

c. 1880
  • Millburn Township, New Jersey
  • $4,195,000

Step inside Montview Estate in the Heart of Short Hills where timeless design meets modern luxury living. This iconic 8-bedroom, 6 full and 2 half-bathroom residence has been reimagined with today’s lifestyle in mind, offering a seamless blend of grand entertaining spaces, private retreats and thoughtfully crafted details. The home has been enhanced to provide […]

c. 1823
  • Chester Township, New Jersey
  • $850,000

Straight from a movie set – Storybook setting in the quaint Township of Chester, 1823 colonial farmhouse with rocking chair porch, large enough for entertaining, overlooks perennial beds, picket fences and rolling hills! Authentic architectural Details combined with modern conveniences make this charming period home one that can’t be missed! Guest suite with kitchenette, full […]

c. 1880
  • Bethlehem Township, New Jersey
  • $675,000

Step inside and you’ll feel it right away: soaring timber beams overhead, sunlight pouring through the skylights, and that warm, lived-in character you just can’t fake. This converted barn turned custom home has a story in every wall, and it shows! Mornings here mean light spilling across the open kitchen and dining area, while evenings […]

Move right into this beautifully maintained home nestled on a quiet and beloved street in West Orange. This open and airy gem is where charm meets convenience – it offers the space you crave to spread out and breathe. From the moment you enter, you’ll fall in love with the updated touches, and the sun-drenched […]

c. 1740
  • Upper Montclair, New Jersey
  • $1,799,000

🏡✨ Some homes are built. Others become part of history. ✨🏡 Long before Upper Montclair became one of New Jersey’s most treasured neighborhoods, Johannes Van Winkle built his homestead here around 1740, establishing what would become one of the community’s earliest residences. 📜 Over the centuries, this remarkable property evolved alongside Montclair itself. It later […]

c. 1905
  • Haddon Heights, New Jersey
  • $780,000

Built in 1905, this classic Dutch Colonial offers over 3,300 square feet of living space on nearly a half-acre in one of Haddon Heights’ most desirable neighborhoods. Combining historic character with modern comfort, the home features new and newer HVAC systems, beautifully landscaped grounds, and a spacious covered front porch perfect for relaxing or entertaining. […]

c. 1762
  • Pilesgrove Township, New Jersey
  • $750,000

REDUCED $100,000! Welcome to Seven Stars Tavern — a rare opportunity to own an authentic piece of New Jersey’s colonial history. Built in 1762 and rich with Revolutionary-era significance, this extraordinary residence blends timeless architectural character with the warmth and charm of a true historic home. Once a landmark tavern along the King’s Highway, the […]

c. 1913
  • Mountain Lakes, New Jersey
  • $2,495,000

One of Mountain Lakes’ most sought-after and recognizable homes, this landmark, turnkey property blends presence, history, and modern comfort. Set on a striking hilltop, it offers exceptional curb appeal with a circular driveway and classic porte-cochere an unforgettable arrival. Inside, timeless architectural details meet refined updates: original chestnut trim, diamond-pane windows, period sconces, multiple fireplaces, […]

c. 1827
  • Washington Township, New Jersey
  • $1,275,000

Stone Hill. Some homes are built. This one was kept. A meticulously restored 1827 stone residence in the countryside of Washington Township — two centuries of craftsmanship, preserved and made effortlessly livable. The great room is unlike any you’ve stood in: 600 sq ft anchored by a 28-foot-wide sweep of exposed stone (the home’s original […]

c. 1900
  • Tewksbury Township, New Jersey
  • $3,995,000

Shaped by generations of thoughtful stewardship, By Pond Farm is a place where rich history, timeless architecture, and inspired modern design come together to create an estate that feels both enduring and deeply lived in. Located in bucolic Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, this exceptional 10-acre Gentleman’s Farm, previously featured in House Beautiful, offers an expansive […]

Open the door to this Craftsman-inspired American Foursquare, built in 1921, and you’ll find one of the most surprising in-town properties in Newton—a 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home featuring a large renovated kitchen, finished third floor with two offices, detached garage, and an exceptionally deep, fully fenced backyard that stretches well beyond what most would expect. Under […]

Located on a picturesque corner lot in West Orange’s coveted Gregory section, this stately 1898 Tudor Revival showcases exceptional Arts & Crafts detailing and architectural character throughout. This 4 bedroom, 4.5 bath home celebrates the craftsmanship of its era with rich, unpainted woodwork, top-nailed hardwood floors, thematic stained glass, and sun-filled peaked windows in the […]

c. 1980
  • Flemington, New Jersey
  • $949,000

13 Hamden Road | Flemington, New Jersey A remarkable Colonial Williamsburg-inspired reproduction where timeless American craftsmanship and architectural authenticity have been beautifully preserved. Privately set among mature trees and manicured grounds, this distinguished residence was thoughtfully designed to honor the proportions, materials, and detailing associated with 18th-century Virginia architecture. From the beveled cedar siding and […]

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

2m

Monthly Page Views

575k

Combined Social Media Followers

55k

Newsletter Subscribers