Compare Listings

OLD HOUSES FOR SALE IN NEW JERSEY

Lake Valhalla Victorian Gem

Montville, New Jersey

Motivated sellers! This porch is just calling out for relaxation with a lemonade and good book.

$749,900

Old Houses

for Sale in

New Jersey

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

c. 1810
  • Long Valley, New Jersey
  • $799,000

Meticulously updated while preserving its classic ethos, Heath House Hotel and Spa, with history dating back to 1810, was one of Schooley’s Mt Springs’ famous resorts. The result is a […]

c. 1929
  • Westwood, New Jersey
  • $1,250,000

…A Magnificent Brick Manor Home (One of the original homes built in the 1920’s  in this Spectacular Community) offers a Portuguese Tile Roof & Circular Driveway that leads to the […]

c. 1958
  • Mahwah, New Jersey
  • $499,000

This is an accurately detailed 18th century Dutch Colonial antique reproduction, built in 1958. Painstakingly constructed by the original master carpenter and sole owner. This home offers true historical charm […]

c. 1851
  • Barnegat Township, New Jersey
  • $419,000

Wonderfully maintained and upgraded colonial home situated in historic section of town. This home exudes old world charm but has all the modern conveniences. Hardwood floors throughout, large open living […]

c. 1880
  • Montville, New Jersey
  • $749,900

** Price Corrected to reflect the sellers motivation please present all reasonable offers** Located in the Lake Valhalla Community this vintage Victorian “Painted Lady” property circa 1880 sits on approx […]

c. 1906
  • Point Pleasant, New Jersey
  • $549,900

Old world charm living East of the Canal. This enchanting circa 1900 classic 4 bedroom, 2 bath Seashore Dutch Colonial captures the original architecture details of yesteryear.Enter through the welcoming […]

Distinctly unique and graceful 1905 home situated on prime Glen Ridge block. NYC Commuters take note:15 min to Glen Ridge & Bay St train stations, 9 min to DeCamp bus. […]

c. 1850
  • Waldwick, New Jersey
  • $699,900

OLD WORLD MEETS NEW! THIS UPDATED & RESTORED VICTORIAN HAS THE CHARM & ARCHITECTURAL DETAILS THAT ARE RARE TO FIND IN TODAYS NEW CONSTRUCTIONS! AS YOU ENTER THE HOME YOU […]

c. 1720
  • Fredon Township, New Jersey
  • $525,000

Vintage property renovated in 2013 and currently “The Hummingbird House” serving breakfast & lunch. A unique dining experience in the several quaint rooms plus a banquet room for 50. The […]

c. 1860
  • Westfield, New Jersey
  • $1,275,000

If you love the charm of an older home, yet want modern amenities, this beautiful turn of the century fully renovated home is for you. Stunning Gourmet kitchen featuring vintage […]

c. 1958
  • Mahwah, New Jersey
  • $550,000

Check out the Virtual Tour here! Built by the sole owner of this home and set on approx. 1 acre, prepare yourself to be enchanted by the unique details and […]

c. 1906
  • Ocean Grove, New Jersey
  • $549,000

Gorgeous 1906 Craftsman on an oversized corner lot. Located in the South End of Ocean Grove (Stockton at New York). 3 Bedrooms, 1.5 Baths. Largest single-floor Bungalow in Ocean Grove. […]

c. 1900
  • Ocean Grove, New Jersey
  • $1,129,000

Victorian Mixed Use Commercial Building with a TWO CAR GARAGE plus off street parking in the Heart of Ocean Grove’s Historic District. Three Updated One Bedroom Apartments on there 2nd […]

c. 1812
  • Morristown, New Jersey
  • $975,000

Welcome to the landmark “1812 House” in the charming Washington Valley Historic District. The recently renovated Federal Style home is set on 3.7 acres of beautiful lawns, stone walls & […]

One of Morristown’s treasured historic homes, situated on half an acre (.57). The original Junior clubhouse of the prestigious Morris County Golf Club. This home welcomes guests to a grand […]

c. 1760
  • Mendham, New Jersey
  • $599,000

Location is an Ideal 1/4 mile to schools, library, restaurants, parks, ball fields, and tennis courts. Enjoy the sunny kitchen with granite counters overlooking the migratory bird pond. Must see […]

c. 1931
  • Summit, New Jersey
  • $1,499,000

http://194springfieldave.com/ Setback from the main street in Summit and perched on a hilltop, allowing for ultimate privacy, lies this historic French-inspired Farmhouse. Renowned for its elegant simplicity, it exudes both […]

c. 1890
  • Burlington Township, New Jersey
  • $305,000

Check out the Virtual Tour here! Rare opportunity to own an 1800’s Victorian nested within an exclusive enclave of homes that has a long view of the Delaware River from […]

Built in 1868, this Italianate Victorian, once the residence of renowned author Mary Wilkins Freeman, is one of Metuchen’s oldest surviving historic homes.  It has been lovingly restored with a […]

c. 1895
  • Merchantville, New Jersey
  • $175,000

History for sale! This huge victorian circa 1895 has been owned by a single family for generations. Now it’s your turn. Situated on a 1/3+ acre lot, set way back […]

c. 1871
  • Hightstown, New Jersey
  • $399,000

Small town living at its very best! Have you ever dreamed of living in a Victorian home filled with charm and character? Don’t let this chance pass you by! Talk […]

Visit the Open House on Sunday, October 13th from 1:00-4:00! Nestled in the Heart of Beautiful GOODWIN PARK and Only Steps Away from the Walking Bridge….9 Rooms w/Lots of Nooks […]

c. 1840
  • Stockton, New Jersey
  • $239,000

In the charming village of Sergeansville sits this lovely Victorian home with a cupola/widows watch. Built in 1840 and updated, public sewer & water, original wood floors. Rear of house […]

c. 1749
  • East Amwell Township, New Jersey
  • $599,000

Dovetailing precision renovations of a 1749 farmhouse with 2016 amenities is the work of an artisan in flawless architecture. This home exemplifies a balance of modern design & vintage craftsmanship. […]

Old House

Real Estate

Agents in

New Jersey

Old House

Real Estate Agents

in New Jersey

KAREN SFERRA
Turpin Realtors
Oldwick

sferra (at) turpinrealtors (dot) com
(908) 892-3887

STEPHANIE SMITH
Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage
Westfield

letsgetmoving.stephanie (at) gmail (dot) com
(908) 230-8585

VIRGINIA “BETH” HARPELL
RE/MAX House Values
Landing

Beth (at) HistoricHouseHunter (dot) com
(973) 650-1637

DAWN BRAITHWAITE
Keller Williams Village Square Realty
The Dawn Braithwaite Team
Ridgewood

DawnBraithwaite (at) kw (dot) com
(201) 951-5196

PAULA ANASTASIO
Weichert Realtors
Hunterton, Mercer & Somerset Counties

PaulaAnastasio (at) gmail (dot) com
(908) 319-3113

All The

Cool Kids

Are Doing

It.

List an Old House

for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

2m

Monthly Page Views

575k

Combined Social Media Followers

55k

Newsletter Subscribers