Search

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

A truly special Livingston home, impeccably maintained, deeply loved and ready for its next chapter! Filled with natural light, this 4 BR, 3 BA home offers generous, open living and entertaining spaces while preserving its original charm and character. A large picture window fills the living room with incredible morning sunshine, while the dining room’s […]

c. 1913
  • South Orange, New Jersey
  • $1,125,000

: Design-forward c.1913 Victorian offering 5 BRs, 2.2 baths and an extraordinary collaboration of architecture, interiors and landscape design. A whole-home project by Jenny J. Norris Interiors was followed by architectural + interior work by Cristina Ioana Graff, AIA/Graff Guild, creating richly layered spaces that honor the home’s original character. The showpiece kitchen features custom […]

c. 1931
  • Maplewood, New Jersey
  • $1,250,000

Arrive home to this PICTURE PERFECT home in a HIGHLY COVETED location just .6 miles to downtown and a few blocks from idyllic Orchard Park & playground! Tucked at the end of a quiet dead-end street, 9 Garthwaite Terrace is in the heart of Maplewood, offering a rare sense of privacy and storybook curb appeal. […]

c. 1800
  • Bridgewater, New Jersey
  • $499,000

This is your opportunity to own a piece of Bridgewater history! Dating back to circa 1800, this charming 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath home is set on a picturesque 1 acre lot in one of Bridgewater’s most desirable locations.Rich in charm and character, the home features beautiful hardwood floors, including original pumpkin pine floors in the […]

c. 1912
  • Rockaway Township, New Jersey
  • $750,000

Tucked into nature, this Colonial invites you to homestead your heart out. A covered wraparound porch welcomes slow mornings, while mature trees, colorful perennial gardens, fruit tree orchard, berries & herbs surround you with historical charm. Grow your own in the enclosed garden, with outbuildings for equipment & homestead pursuits. Timber Brook, a small private […]

c. 1900
  • Red Bank, New Jersey
  • $2,890,000

Set along the Navesink River, this circa 1900 farmhouse was completely rebuilt & reimagined in 2015, offering exceptional waterfront living with a substantial Ipe dock & beautiful sunrises and sunsets over the water. The 4,149 sf home spans 3 levels while preserving original millwork, beamed ceilings, built-ins & doors. The oversized foyer with wainscoting & […]

c. 1927
  • West Orange, New Jersey
  • $699,000

Beautifully updated Colonial in West Orange’s desirable Upper Gregory neighborhood, just moments from Gregory Elementary, the jitney, and Midtown Direct trains. Thoughtfully renovated for today’s lifestyle while preserving its timeless character, this home features a stunning gut-renovated kitchen and dining room, first-floor powder room, 200-amp electrical service, renovated full bath with new plumbing, refinished living […]

c. 1898
  • Maplewood, New Jersey
  • $1,050,000

A truly special Victorian in the heart of Maplewood’s beloved, close-knit College Hill neighborhood, this move-in ready home offers 5 bedrooms, 2.1 bathrooms and more than 125 years of history, warmth, and genuine character. Built in 1898 on what was once a cherry farm, this remarkable home is filled with sweet details rarely found today. […]

c. 1927
  • South Orange, New Jersey
  • $699,000

Impeccably maintained Colonial in a prime location just 0.5 miles from vibrant downtown South Orange and its Midtown Direct train station, shops, restaurants, SOPAC, live music and newly renovated Cameron Recreation Area. Inside, a welcoming living room features a cozy fireplace and built-ins, while the sunny front room offers flexible space for a home office, […]

Completely reimagined and renovated in 2026 with exceptional craftsmanship, high-quality finishes and meticulous attention to detail, this show-stopping Victorian offers refined luxury and effortless living. The elegant main level features a living room with gas fireplace, family room with wood-burning fireplace, and a stunning chef’s kitchen with custom cabinetry, Viking 6-burner range with pot filler, […]

c. 1966
  • West Orange, New Jersey
  • $1,250,000

 The Belle of the Oldstead neighborhood! Set on a quiet street near South Mountain Reservation, this wonderfully bright home has been transformed through extensive, thoughtful renovations with exceptional attention to quality, design and everyday living. At its heart is a spectacular chef’s kitchen, beautifully conceived and impressively scaled, with custom cabinetry, an expansive island, professional […]

With the scale, craftsmanship and character of another era, this c. 1880s home is distinguished by Italianate influences, bracketed eaves, tall windows and intricate detailing. Three porches, of which two are covered, add to the home’s historic character and overlook the peaceful grounds. Ornate double entry doors open to a grand foyer, where soaring 10-foot […]

c. 1790
  • Lambertville, New Jersey
  • $3,850,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here!   Set beyond a gated entrance paved in reclaimed cobblestone, the Hart–Vorhees Farmstead is one of Hopewell Valley’s most extraordinary country estates—a rare convergence of architectural heritage, world-class gardens, refined equestrian amenities, and nearly ten acres of remarkable privacy. Originally constructed in the 1700s, the property’s iconic stone barn has […]

A rare opportunity to own one of Salem County’s most remarkable preserved farm properties, this extraordinary 64-acre estate offers nearly one-third of a mile of frontage along the Salem River, creating an unmatched setting for recreation, agriculture, and gathering. The landscape is a beautiful blend of open farmland, mature woodlands, and scenic river views, with […]

c. 1900
  • Rocky Hill Borough, New Jersey
  • $649,900

Visit the Open House this Sunday, 8/30 from 1-4pm! Perfectly situated on an expansive double lot with future potential, this exceptional property is located in the heart of the historic Borough of Rocky Hill & is recognized as a contributing home within the Rocky Hill Historic District. Rich in character and timeless appeal, it offers […]

c. 1900
  • Rocky Hill Boro, New Jersey
  • $799,900

Visit the Open House this Sunday, 8/30 from 1-4pm! Beautifully renovated historic Colonial located in the charming Borough of Rocky Hill and served by the highly regarded Montgomery School District. Rich in character and thoughtfully updated, this 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home blends timeless architectural details with modern comforts. Built as the borough’s first school […]

RARE OPPORTUNITY to own a definitive piece of American history with the Van Buskirk Home, the very first residence built in Saddle River. Circa 1707, this historic home is a Red Dutch Stone Colonial sitting on over 2 lush acres, offering modern amenities such as a freeform pool, oversized patios, and a tennis court – […]

Meander through, and this gorgeous stone house appears to have been built for a prosperous landowner. The evidence is everywhere from the unusually generous room sizes, plentiful closets, handsome millwork, and a floor plan intended to impress as much as it was meant to function. Nearly three centuries of history come together in this remarkable […]

A rare opportunity to own one of Kingston’s most historically significant residences, thoughtfully restored to blend timeless character with exceptional modern living. Dating to the mid 1800s and located within Kingston’s Historic District, this remarkable home has undergone an extensive renovation that preserves its architectural integrity while offering the comfort, technology, and craftsmanship expected in […]

c. 1830
  • Glen Gardner, New Jersey
  • $749,000

Steeped in history, this magnificent 1830’s stone Colonial offers a rare blend of historic character, modern amenities, and serene rural living. Tucked back from the road on 6.79 sprawling, landscaped acres, the property boasts approx. 800 feet of pristine river frontage. Imagine spending your evenings sitting by the fire pit right at the edge of […]

c. 1917
  • Dayton, New Jersey
  • $1,099,000

A Home You Don’t Simply Buy… You Become Part Of. There are homes that impress, and then there are homes that leave a legacy. Built in 1917 by local farmer Joseph Duncan and lovingly cared for by only four families in more than a century, 439 Georges Road is one of those rare places where […]

c. 1880
  • Millburn Township, New Jersey
  • $4,195,000

Step inside Montview Estate in the Heart of Short Hills where timeless design meets modern luxury living. This iconic 8-bedroom, 6 full and 2 half-bathroom residence has been reimagined with today’s lifestyle in mind, offering a seamless blend of grand entertaining spaces, private retreats and thoughtfully crafted details. The home has been enhanced to provide […]

c. 1823
  • Chester Township, New Jersey
  • $850,000

Straight from a movie set – Storybook setting in the quaint Township of Chester, 1823 colonial farmhouse with rocking chair porch, large enough for entertaining, overlooks perennial beds, picket fences and rolling hills! Authentic architectural Details combined with modern conveniences make this charming period home one that can’t be missed! Guest suite with kitchenette, full […]

c. 1880
  • Bethlehem Township, New Jersey
  • $675,000

Step inside and you’ll feel it right away: soaring timber beams overhead, sunlight pouring through the skylights, and that warm, lived-in character you just can’t fake. This converted barn turned custom home has a story in every wall, and it shows! Mornings here mean light spilling across the open kitchen and dining area, while evenings […]

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

2m

Monthly Page Views

575k

Combined Social Media Followers

55k

Newsletter Subscribers