Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

c. 1818
  • Haworth, New Jersey
  • $1,750,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! A charming piece of history in Haworth, New Jersey, the 1818 Christie Zabriskie Dutch Colonial Stone Farmhouse. On the Historical Register and with only 4 owners in the past 200 years, this pink sandstone and wood clad house is at once beautifully preserved and updated for today’s homeowner. It’s an […]

c. 1865
  • Hillsborough, New Jersey
  • $694,800

This fantastic farmhouse blends the old with the new, fresh air, rolling landscapes, and lots of space, everything necessary to make this your new home. The 4.7acre parcel consists of 4 structures with a house originally built in 1865. Gorgeous with thoughtful attention to detail throughout. There are 4BR and 3 full BA. The first-floor […]

c. 1735
  • Warren, New Jersey
  • $1,825,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! This magnificent historic estate is the perfect combination of historic charm & beauty for todays modern lifestyle. Built in 1735 and modernized in 2000 creating amazing spaces and 6584 sqft The private estate sits on 2 LOTS forming 3.69 acres of the most spectacular property in all of Warren Township! […]

c. 1891
  • High Bridge, New Jersey
  • $375,000

Welcome Home to the Hoffman House! This lovingly restored Queen Anne Victorian offers a unique opportunity as the new owners will be only the second to make it home since being built in approx 1891. Great care was given to preserve and showcase the intricate craftsmanship and character throughout while providing a modern functionality. The […]

c. 1811
  • Princeton, New Jersey
  • $1,399,500

The Worth Homestead and Mill c1700. Step back in time walking through the doors of this 18th century stone estate, which has transformed over the years from a thriving mill and farm, to a gentleman’s manor, to its current state as a single family home. This tranquil Austenesque enclave including a trio of stone outbuildings […]

c. 1885
  • Hoboken, New Jersey
  • $2,145,000

Do not miss this historic two family home on one the most beautiful blocks in Hoboken. This brownstone was built in 1885 and has original details and has been extremely well maintained and thoughtfully restored. The parlor level has a formal living and dining room with a gas fireplace. Pocket doors lead to a custom […]

c. 1902
  • Lake Hopatcong, New Jersey
  • $795,000

HEIRLOOM LAKEFRONT, Only 1 hour from NYC, Comes completely furnished, also includes 2015-20’4″Pontoon boat, 1956 Sportsman 17′ Chris Craft, house,boathouse, bunk house and more! Classic lakefront, 3-story, 4-bedroom Dutch Colonial-style home on New Jersey’s largest lake located one-hour from NYC in what is known as “lake country.” Named Pinehurst, this gracious three-season home is situated […]

c. 1700
  • , New Jersey
  • $1,998,000

“The Nathaniel Smith House” as it is known, was built in the 1700’s in Hopkinton, Massachusetts, was brought to its current location by the previous owners in the 1960’s, reassembled from its original materials on this site, expanded and updated over the years.  Offering 4,345 sq. ft. this house sits on 2.7 acres and includes […]

c. 1782
  • Westwood, New Jersey
  • $995,000

When history juxtaposed against modern refinement embodies artistic synergy, a masterpiece is reimagined. The Westervelt House is ranked among the finest Greek Revival homes in Bergen County. The beginnings of this property date back to the late 1700s rich with storried family roots deep in the founding of Bergen County and Westwood. Walking through the […]

c. 1808
  • Ho-Ho-Kus, New Jersey
  • $999,000

Welcome to this classic Ho-Ho-Kus colonial, convenient to train and downtown Ho-Ho-Kus and Waldwick. This spacious 6BR,4 1/2 Bath home has well manicured grounds with mature landscaping and gardens. Oversized entry foyer greets your guests. Formal LR w/wood burning fireplace, library w/built in bookshelves and fireplace (see seller disclosure). Large dining room w/access to lovely […]

c. 1793
  • Bordentown, New Jersey
  • $750,000

The most prominent corner in historic Bordentown is an apt match for the impressive grandeur of this treasured home built by Colonel Joseph Borden, son of the town’s namesake, successful businessman and Congressman, and Revolution-era patriot. Compelling architecture delights the eye and tempts the imagination. The elegant simplicity of the exterior is complimented by cast […]

Public & Virtual Open House, Sunday, June 27th at 12:30-1:30 PM  Now Within Reach: The Perfect Marriage of Old and New at a Great New Price! The storybook setting of this historic home, on peaceful grounds just a short distance to all that Pennington Borough is loved for including the Toll Gate Grammar School down […]

c. 1892
  • Plainfield, New Jersey
  • $635,000

To all Victorian lovers: this is a rare opportunity to own a true architectural gem. One of the crown jewels of the Hillside Historic District (and most iconic Plainfield homes) is on the market! Luxuriate on the absolutely epic, pristine-condition wrap around porch. 11ft ceilings and enormous proportions of the living room and dining rooms […]

c. 1860
  • Chesterfield, New Jersey
  • $894,000

SIMPLY PRESTIGIOUS! Built in 1860, this three story, approx. 4800 square ft historic home in beautiful Crosswicks is a must see! Situated on approximately 2. 5 +/- acres, the property includes an athletic facility, a detached 3 car garage with workshop, and beautiful backyard views. Mature trees and landscaping add to the beauty of the […]

c. 1830
  • Belle Mead, New Jersey
  • $699,000

Located in the Bridgepoint Historic District of Montgomery Township presents a remarkably intact picture of life in agricultural New Jersey from 1750-1850. The Schmidt Barn established in the 2nd quarter of the 19th century, originally two separate barns joined together to form an L-shape modern residence with a modern appearance. This historic 1835 bank barn […]

c. 1890
  • Montclair, New Jersey
  • $699,000

Ditmas Park meets Montclair in this lovingly maintained and updated 1890 Watchung Plaza neighborhood Victorian just steps to NYC commuting options and the best coffee and parks in town. Elegant period details welcome you in the extraordinary double-height foyer, with original millwork, moldings, 3 sets of pocket doors, formal living and dining rooms, a family […]

c. 1830
  • Blairstown, New Jersey
  • $475,000

Come home to this classic red farmhouse, set back amid rolling pastures; Fr Porch opens into LR/DR w/stone FP. EIK, Fam Rm, Off, 1/2 BA on first; 2nd: 3 BD, 1BA, 3rd:2 large rooms. Storage aplenty! Att. 2 car garage has stairs to upper level storage. Basement has large capacity indoor oil tank, utility & […]

c. 1749
  • Cranbury, New Jersey
  • $895,000

Fully updated and move-in ready colonial farmhouse in historic Cranbury sits on nearly 3 lush acres. Approach down a long, tree-lined driveway to this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home full of character and rich architectural details, including original hand-hewn beams, decorative molding, and wide-plank pumpkin pine floors. The gorgeous remodeled kitchen and spacious dining area boast all-new […]

c. 1894
  • Glen Ridge, New Jersey
  • $1,029,000

Located on one of Glen Ridge’s finest side streets this beautiful Victorian home welcomes you with its sweeping front porch and stunning original architecture. Soaring ceilings invite you into the homes unique foyer and 1st fl living space. The 2014 renovation includes a custom kitchen w/center island, 6-burner stove, convection oven and ample storage including […]

c. 1820
  • Pohatcong, New Jersey
  • $339,000

Feel as if you stepped back in time, this timeless antique beauty boasts original stonework.Located in the Historic District of Finesville, Enjoy the mountain view from the upper yard, just perfect to enjoy those chilly nights with an outdoor fire pit. Thought this timeless beauty was built in the 1800’s it has all of today’s […]

c. 1888
  • Glen Ridge, New Jersey
  • $1,149,000

Meticulous modern restoration of a classic Glen Ridge home. The warmth throughout this beautiful home is accentuated with natural light and soaring ceilings combined with pristine craftsmanship. The front porch invites you into an open floor plan “wowed” by a stunning kitchen and family room with wall-to-wall windows overlooking the exquisitely landscaped yard and patio. […]

c. 1785
  • Montville, New Jersey
  • $499,000

Charm & endless potential abound in this historic Victorian set on 1.69 acres. From the covered front porch welcome to the wide plank wood floors, soaring ceilings, unique archways & spacious rooms, the architectural details will capture your heart. Features include: LR w/fireplace & bay window inset; formal DR w/butlers pantry; powder rm & EIK […]

c. 1900
  • Westfield, New Jersey
  • $1,750,000

Known for its unique windows, this beautiful residence enjoys an open floor plan featuring large, gracious rooms and an easy flow that is ideal for casual living and grand entertaining. The three floors of luxurious living space feature eight bedrooms, five full and one half baths, custom millwork, and unique details offing elegance throughout. The […]

c. 1720
  • Fredon Township, New Jersey
  • $525,000

Vintage property renovated in 2013 and currently “The Hummingbird House” serving breakfast & lunch. A unique dining experience in the several quaint rooms plus a banquet room for 50. The building & equipment are inclusive w/an immaculate kitchen w/6 burner gas stove, flat top griddle, panini press, Salamander broiler, 2 gas ovens, char grill, dual […]

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.


Monthly Page Views


Combined Social Media Followers


Newsletter Subscribers

Compare listings

Follow us @cheapoldhouses + launching on HGTV & Discovery+, Monday, August 9th at 9pm ET