Search

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

c. 1870
  • Flemington, New Jersey
  • $784,900

Why settle for ordinary, when you can have extraordinary! This distinctive circa-19th Century Second Empire Victorian residence in Flemington Borough, is a standout in the community. It’s renowned convex mansard roof, dormers and central roof detail, and massive indoor wraparound porch create memorable curb appeal with a welcoming touch. Historic features continue inside with a […]

c. 1880
  • Glen Ridge, New Jersey
  • $1,429,000

A rare opportunity to own a gracious home in the heart of central Glen Ridge, ideally located for easy access to Midtown Direct train service and all this coveted community has to offer. Set amid mature trees and lush landscaping, this handsome residence combines classic architectural character with an exceptionally versatile floorplan and an enviable […]

c. 1880
  • Milford, New Jersey
  • $549,000

Welcome home, where timeless charm meets sophisticated modern living. Magnificent waterfront, 1880’s Colonial offers a rare blend of historic character, modern amenities, and serene rural living. This renovated home offers a beautifully designed open concept, filled with natural light, connecting kitchen, dining & living rooms, perfect for everyday living & entertaining. The kitchen features white […]

c. 1935
  • South Orange, New Jersey
  • $799,000

Welcome to 463 Tillou Road, a charming 3 BR, 2.1 BA cottage in South Orange’s coveted Upper Wyoming neighborhood! Beautiful curb appeal and mature landscaping welcome you into this sun-filled home, where timeless character meets thoughtful updates. The inviting living room features a wood-burning fireplace with insert and a beautiful bay window, while the formal […]

c. 1724
  • Dumont, New Jersey
  • $799,000

Watch a Virtual Tour here! Presenting the Daniel D. Demarest Homestead, an exceptional Dutch stone house dating to 1724, offered for sale for the first time in over 70 years. This house faces Demarest Court which is a cul-d-sac. Rich in character and history, this home receives abundant natural light and has a spacious layout […]

c. 1850
  • Forked River, New Jersey
  • $399,000

A rare find for the historic home enthusiast—this beautifully preserved c. 1850 landmark residence perfectly marries distinctive historic architecture with proud stewardship. Serving as a striking centerpiece, a grand, extra-wide good morning dual-entry staircase welcomes you into a layout filled with remarkable details, four original fireplaces, and beautiful cedar wood flooring. The formal dining room […]

c. 1936
  • Montclair, New Jersey
  • $715,000

A rare opportunity to own a truly special home that feels like a dream from the moment you arrive. Graciously proportioned and thoughtfully designed, this two-bedroom home offers a flexible floor plan with options to suit your lifestyle and needs. The spacious living room flows into a charming sunroom, ideal for relaxing, entertaining, or working […]

c. 1925
  • Glen Ridge, New Jersey
  • $1,599,000

Timeless charm meets modern-day convenience in this gracious Colonial, ideally situated on the ”sweet spot of Forest Avenue, one of Glen Ridge’s most desirable locations. Beautiful period details blend seamlessly with thoughtful updates, including a recently replaced roof. Inside, a welcoming living room with fireplace opens to a family room that easily adapts to a […]

Nestled in Moorestown’s coveted Club Estates neighborhood, just moments from Moorestown Field Club, this beautifully reimagined Tudor seamlessly blends timeless architecture with sophisticated modern living. Recently refreshed with a brand-new roof (2026), freshly painted exterior, and extensive interior renovations, this exceptional home offers classic character, luxurious finishes, and thoughtfully updated systems throughout. Step inside to […]

As one of Princeton’s most captivating and stunning streets, its allure is only heightened by being a stone’s throw away from the scenic campus and wooded trails of the Institute for Advanced Study. Designed by renowned Princeton architect Rolf W. Bauhan, 60 Battle Road pairs architectural pedigree with the enduring appeal of Princeton. Morning coffee […]

c. 1911
  • Verona, New Jersey
  • $799,000

Welcome to A Century of Charm! This stunning Victorian Colonial in the heart of Verona! Filled with character, warmth, and timeless appeal, this spacious 5-bedroom, 3-bath home offers a versatile layout and thoughtful updates designed for comfortable living.The inviting main level begins with a welcoming foyer and flows into spacious living and dining areas, creating […]

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Beautifully updated antique Cottage offers one floor living in a private setting.  Once part of the Combs Hollow Mill area, originally in Mendham Township, this home has been totally remodeled.  Cedar Shake exterior, new roof in 2025 and expansive paver patio.  Cozy Living Room with stone woodburning fireplace, Dining Room, […]

A rare opportunity to own one of Oldwick’s most recognizable historic homes. This iconic ”Painted Lady showcases classic architecture and exceptional craftsmanship on 1.5 beautifully maintained acres, with sweeping views of farmland, rolling hills, and spectacular sunsets all within an hour to New York City. A quintessential front porch welcomes you to this five-bedroom, four-bath […]

Historic professional commercial building located in the HEART of Woodbury. Built in 1858, this charming building can be used for residential or commercial occupancy. Currently, it is a professional office with three floors, several offices, a conference room, a greeting room, and two bathrooms. It could be converted to residential living upstairs and remain commercial […]

c. 1854
  • Keyport, New Jersey
  • $660,000

Own a Remarkable Piece of History. Built in 1854, this distinguished Federal-style home with Greek Revival influences offers 2,820 square feet, four bedrooms, two full baths, and extraordinary potential. Soaring 10-foot ceilings on the first floor enhance the home’s sense of grandeur, while beautiful hardwood floors, decorative moldings, and graceful arched doorways showcase the craftsmanship […]

c. 1941
  • Union, New Jersey
  • $575,000

Welcome to this charming 4-bedroom, 2 full bath Cape Cod offering flexible living space and an incredible backyard retreat! Step inside to a cozy living room that flows naturally into the dining room and well-maintained kitchen, with a bright sunroom providing additional space to relax and enjoy views of the backyard. The first floor features […]

c. 1953
  • South Orange, New Jersey
  • $1,149,000

A rare opportunity on one of South Orange’s most prestigious streets! Set well back from the road behind a crescent drive, this sun-filled 4 BR, 3 full BA Ranch combines the ease of primarily one-level living with the gracious flow of a Center Hall Colonial. Enter the welcoming foyer that leads through the dining room […]

c. 1846
  • Hillsborough Twp., New Jersey
  • $829,000

Step back in time and experience the timeless charm of this 19th-century Colonial nestled on 5.66 picturesque acres. Rich in character and history, this 4-bedroom home features wide pine floors, a cozy wood-burning stove, and many architectural details. The unique layout includes a rear staircase, a loft area above one of the bedrooms, and a […]

c. 1894
  • Middletown, New Jersey
  • $6,300,000

Set on a bluff above the Navesink with a rare gentle slope to the river & private riverfront access, this exceptional Victorian mansion pairs remarkable architectural character w/ modern amenities. Sweeping 180° river views unfold from nearly every level w/spectacular sunsets. Expansive indoor/outdoor living is enjoyed from the wraparound porch. A new illuminated dock extends […]

c. 1834
  • Hope Township, New Jersey
  • $399,000

”Honeywell House”: Enchanting Stone cottage set on Approximately a half acre of lawn with a decorative pond, stone walls, perennial gardens, garden shed, patio and flowering shrubs. There are wide-plank floors, three fireplace, two of stone ( floor-to-ceiling), vaulted ceilings, exposed beams and fine period details. The perfect Country Retreat. The property also has a […]

c. 1925
  • Glen Ridge, New Jersey
  • $1,600,000

Timeless character, generous proportions, and an enviable Glen Ridge setting come together in this handsome Craftsman Colonial, set on a broad and level lot nearly 1/3 acre. From the moment you enter, original details take center stage, including a show-stopping fireplace surround and the charming tiled floor of the sunroom. Designed for both gracious entertaining […]

c. 1932
  • Maplewood, New Jersey
  • $749,000

Look no further for the perfect Maplewood charmer! With four finished floors of living space, this enchanting home is filled with beautiful architectural details, bright natural light and ideal indoor-outdoor living. The open-plan first floor is designed for gathering, with a cozy, welcoming living room anchored by a gorgeous fireplace that flows seamlessly into the […]

c. 1923
  • South Orange, New Jersey
  • $759,000

Picture-perfect, renovated and brimming with charm! Thoughtfully transformed from top to bottom, this home pairs historic character with pristine, smart finishes. The window-wrapped front of the house hints at the incredible natural light within. Step through into a home filled with warmth and personality – high ceilings, beautiful original details and distinctive wood floors. The […]

c. 1895
  • Lambertville, New Jersey
  • $1,175,000

A Gem in Lambertville, New Jersey Calling all old-house lovers. This 1895 brick and frame home is a study in how to bring an older house forward without erasing what made it special in the first place. Located on a residential block in the Central Business District, this single-family home was extensively renovated and expanded, […]

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

2m

Monthly Page Views

575k

Combined Social Media Followers

55k

Newsletter Subscribers