Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

c. 1874
  • Belvidere Twp, New Jersey
  • $420,000

“This Italianate style Victorian was built in 1874 for Judge Jeheil Shipman, and was designed by the prominent architect Samuel Sloane, who designed the NJ state house in Trenton, as well as Greystone Mental Hospital. Mr. Sloane was based in Philadelphia, PA, and was responsible for many of the higher-end homes throughout PA and as […]

c. 1924
  • Moorestown, New Jersey
  • $3,050,000

Visit the Open House on Thursday, July 24th 5pm-7pm! Step into timeless elegance at this extraordinary Moorestown estate, where Great Gatsby-level glamour meets modern comfort and functionality. Originally built in 1924 and gracefully situated on just over an acre in the heart of town, this stately residence is more than just a home—it’s a legacy. […]

c. 1925
  • Hackettstown, New Jersey
  • $349,000

This incredibly unique and airy loft-like home was originally constructed in 1925 as a worship building before being converted to a private residence, and retains the best of those qualities- 14’ ceilings, large windows, open floor plan, a mezzanine that could be used as a library or second bedroom, and a massive walkout basement (approx. […]

c. 1896
  • Tuckerton, New Jersey
  • $490,500

PLEASE NO Realtors. Cash buyer only. Prefer email. No phone calls or texts 388 S. Green St. Tuckerton, NJ was the home of my great grandfather, Wilbur C. Parker, the captain of the Mattie Porter. The ‘Porter’ was the last oyster schooner built by Van Zant boatworks in Port Republic, NJ. The home is 129 years […]

c. 1875
  • Cape May, New Jersey
  • $2,750,000

Welcome to your ”Folk Victorian” 3-story home in a premier location on the beach block at Queen Street Beach. With ocean views from the second floor and the third floor looks out onto the beach and jetty, you can check the surf, watch the boats cruising by and enjoy spectacular sunrises and sunsets from multiple […]

c. 1890
  • Stillwater, New Jersey
  • $4,500,000

Set on over 40 private, wooded acres, this former 1800s farmhouse-turned-family-estate surprises and delights visitors around every corner with magazine-worthy organic gardens (started in 1967!), private pond with waterfall, and property features seen in numerous publications over the years. The Main Residence began as an old farmhouse and now hovers around 10,000 square feet, featuring […]

c. 1911
  • Glen Ridge, New Jersey
  • $699,000

Welcome to 68 Osborne Street, a unique, lovingly preserved five-bedroom home. This special Arts and Crafts Colonial is nestled on a tree-lined street in highly desirable Glen Ridge, close to Broad Street’s shops and restaurants, Montclair’s cultural hub, and NYC transportation. Located within Glen Ridge’s renowned school district, this charming home won the prestigious Glen Ridge Historical Society’s Preservation […]

c. 1905
  • Cape May, New Jersey
  • $2,990,000

Situated on one of the finest and most coveted tree-lined streets of Cape May, 1101 New York Avenue showcases a piece of history as one of the original “Sears Kit” cedar shake homes. Just two blocks to the beach with an ocean view from the second floor, this two-and-half story home is a gem with […]

Nestled among a family of trees, this spectacular one-of-a-kind 6 bdrm, 4.5 bathroom home masterfully blends old-world charm w bold, imaginative modern design. Created by a thoughtful, artistic soul & twice featured in commercial shoots, this home offers a rare architectural experience tailored for today’s creative, discerning buyer. Wake to treetop views & unwind to […]

c. 1940
  • South Orange, New Jersey
  • $990,000

From NYC to Private Serenity! Step into a home where high design meets exceptional comfort – an inspired sanctuary, fully reimagined with artistic precision and meticulous attention to detail. This home is more than a renovation; it is a reinvention of space, style, and soul. The sun drenched living room – gracious in scale and […]

c. 1796
  • Hillsdale, New Jersey
  • $999,999

Truly one-of-a-kind, this exceptional 3,535 sq ft historical home blends timeless charm, quality craftsmanship, and unique character throughout. This distinctive property is nestled on nearly an acre of beautifully fenced, park-like grounds. Step inside to a grand living room featuring a gas fireplace and stunning beamed ceilings. A cozy study/library and an elegant dining room […]

 Tucked along a leafy street in South Orange’s beloved Village Colonials neighborhood, this just-right 3-bed, 1.2-bath home blends timeless architecture with curated updates ideal for the design-conscious buyer who wants both soul and function. Step inside to find freshly painted interiors, original hardwood floors, and a layout that flows with intention. The living room’s wood-burning […]

c. 1880
  • Woodstown, New Jersey
  • 0

AUCTION 4-Bedroom Colonial-Style Farmhouse c. 1880 57.6+/- Acre Non-Preserved Farm Timeless Farmhouse Retreat Pilesgrove Township, Salem County, NJ July 15, 2025   – 1880’s  2,368+/- sf Farmhouse – classic architecture with modern comforts – The Home features exquisitely restored hardwood floors, four bedrooms and bathroom with jacuzzi tub – Eat-in Kitchen with stainless steel appliances […]

c. 1931
  • Glen Ridge, New Jersey
  • $1,895,000

This is the home you’ve been waiting for! A grand Georgian brick colonial on one of Glen Ridge’s most sought-after streets, 176 Forest offers six spacious bedrooms, three full baths, two half baths and two fireplaces. The first floor features a sunlit living room, formal dining room, eat-in kitchen with a bonus living area and […]

Welcome to your dream home nestled in one of Maplewood’s most sought-after neighborhoods. A picture-perfect blend of charm and timeless elegance, this sparkling home combines classic architectural details like stunning crown moldings and archways, along with modern comforts including central air. Step inside to a light-filled, airy living room graced by oversized windows and flowing […]

Exceptionally customized 7BR, 4.5BA beauty marries historic craftsmanship with today’s luxuries, in a convenient location minutes from town, schools, and Midtown Direct trains—yet lives like a private retreat on a lush half‑acre. Original chestnut millwork, 9.5‑ft ceilings, and French doors in every main‑level room blend the line between indoor and outdoor elegance with entry to […]

c. 1970
  • Chester, New Jersey
  • $1,175,000

Welcome to your dream home! This stunning center-hall Colonial, crafted from classic brick, sits on five scenic acres offering privacy and breathtaking views. Inside are 3 spacious bedrooms, 2.2 baths, central air, and a full-house generator for comfort and peace of mind. Elegant interiors feature custom stonework in the living and great rooms, with an […]

Sweet Sophistication. Instant Warmth. Welcome to 466 Park Street, set in one of Upper Montclair’s most beloved neighborhoods. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted by grace & comfort that instantly feels like home. A grand foyer & a sweeping staircase lead to beautifully proportioned rooms, thoughtfully designed for everyday living. The main level […]

Stunning 4BR/3BA home on rare .55+ acre lot in desirable Leonia! Perfect for multi-generational living, this home features a separate in-law suite and private entrance. The magnificent great room features cathedral ceilings, a fireplace, a bar, and a loft, making it ideal for entertaining. The first-floor bedroom suite is perfect for individuals with accessibility needs. […]

c. 1898
  • Plainfield, New Jersey
  • $799,900

OPEN HOUSE: 5/31 & 6/1, 1-4PM. Recently featured in the NY Times, this Exceptional, Stunning, Luxuriously Updated c. 1898 Dutch-Style Colonial Home is Located on a Tree Lined Street in the Highly Desirable Hillside Ave. Historic District Convenient to Everything. This exquisite home, with countless windows creating sun drenched rooms with a dramatic feel, has […]

Welcome to your storybook home in the heart of Maplewood! This sun-filled 4-bedroom charmer is just minutes from Maplewood Village, and NYC trains – making it the perfect spot for growing households. Brimming with character, the home features original built-ins, hardwood floors, vintage hardware, and a one-of-a-kind brick fireplace that anchors the cozy living room. […]

Welcome to The Old Fort, one of Long Valley’s most historically significant homes, ideally situated in the heart of the German Valley Historic District. Built circa 1774 and thoughtfully reimagined in 1876, this distinctive 5-bedroom, 3 full bath residence offers a rare blend of 18th-century charm and Victorian-era architectural detail. Set on a picturesque lot, […]

c. 1928
  • Millburn Twp, New Jersey
  • $1,850,000

Elegant and charming, this c.1928 French Normandy-style Tudor is nestled on a private 0.40-acre lot in the desirable Knollwood section of Short Hills. Impeccably restored and maintained, this home blends classic architectural details with modern updates. Notable features include thermal leaded glass windows, a soaring cathedral ceiling with Juliet balcony, original wood-burning fireplace with marble […]

c. 1920
  • Glen Ridge, New Jersey
  • $2,295,000

Perfectly situated on a picturesque street in the heart of Glen Ridge just moments from top-rated schools and NYC train, this elegant, meticulously updated 6 BR/5.1 BA Colonial blends timeless architecture with high-end modern updates, wrapped in warmth and thoughtful design. At its heart is a reimagined kitchen and family room featuring custom Parsons Cabinetry, […]

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

2m

Monthly Page Views

575k

Combined Social Media Followers

55k

Newsletter Subscribers

Compare listings

Compare
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
SUBSCRIBE
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
SUBSCRIBE