Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

Situated at the southeast corner of the old Barker tract, this L-shaped stone farmhouse has passed through very few owners since the late 1700s. Many original features are intact. The c.1820 addition contains a straight staircase as well as a big walk-in stone fireplace. Seven doors give access to this house, with a covered front […]

c. 1890
  • Montclair, New Jersey
  • $3,250,000

Welcome to your “country” house, nestled on over an acre of property just 15 miles from NYC and 4 blocks from Montclair’s trendy downtown, bursting with life and culture. Spend your days amid the lush sprawling landscape of this unique home, a delightful fusion of modern comfort and historic charm. The captivating entry sets the […]

Step into a living piece of Vernon’s history! This 200-year-old gem, featuring its original 4-room structure, is a true testament to the past. The original barn wood flooring and centuries-old artifacts speak volumes of its rich heritage. You’ll feel transported back in time while sitting in the original living area as if the echoes of […]

c. 1853
  • Riverdale, New Jersey
  • $645,000

Welcome to the Reeve Homestead, built in the mid 1850’s by the Reeve Family, this Colonial Greek Revival home is on the market for the first time ever!  Nestled in the small borough of Riverdale, along the Pequannock River on 1.41 acres, this home has been in the same family for 170 years-that’s six generations!  […]

c. 1770
  • North Caldwell, New Jersey
  • $1,575,000

Unique opportunity to own historic 1770’s Colonial estate reconstructed to fit today’s lifestyle. Expansive 4 Bedroom, 2.1 Bath home, Pool and 2 more buildings – stunning and inspiring Artist’s Studio with Powder Room, Pool, Large Carriage House/Garage with pool guest Powder Room and upstairs Studio Apartment all on beautifully landscaped 1.46 acres.

c. 1725
  • Mickleton, New Jersey
  • $776,500

Welcome to 522 Kings Hwy – It is rare when such a property becomes available, offering 21st century comfort and conveniences, wrapped in the elegant charm and superior workmanship of the 18th and early 19th centuries. This elegant grand stone manor house including four outbuildings is also known as the ‘Bodo Otto’ or ‘Tonkin’ house- […]

c. 1952
  • Princeton, New Jersey
  • $525,000

STRUCTURE ONLY, WHICH MUST BE MOVED – Calling all history buffs and mid-century modern enthusiasts! Now is your chance to own a piece of Princeton’s past with this one-of-a-kind Mid-Century Modern house designed by Wynant D. Vanderpool, Jr. for celebrated mathematician Atle Selberg. Currently located in the Institute for Advanced Study neighborhood, this residence has […]

c. 1732
  • Stockton, New Jersey
  • $7,500,000

A rare offering for the first time, an opportunity to own one of the most coveted pieces of history and unpreserved land in Delaware Twp. that has undergone years of stewardship within the same family. Nestled within the embrace of nature’s splendor, this Circa 1732 farmhouse sits on its vast 200-acre estate weaving together the […]

c. 1880
  • Woodbury, New Jersey
  • $569,000

Now is your chance to own this beautifully restored Victorian Era Gothic Revival Stone home that boasts over 3,050 sq ft of living space in the desirable west end area of Woodbury, NJ. Seller will assist with up to $10,000 in closing costs now that this renovation was brought to life as a 5 bedroom, 2.5 […]

c. 1920
  • Flemington, New Jersey
  • $700,000

Unique and historic country property: Own the magnificent 19th century Locktown Church and charming antique cemetery, newly converted to a unique architectural home set on 1.1 acres with endless views of preserved farmland. Three bedrooms and loft, 3 baths and enormous great room with all modern conveniences including kitchen with stainless appliances. Perfect for artists, […]

BANKRUPTCY AUCTION By Order of the US Bankruptcy Court 127+/- Acres Equestrian Estate Hampton Twp, Sussex Co, NJ September 12, 2023   Wonderland Farms 127+/- acre equestrian estate with possibilities to subdivide Rare opportunity to own this incredible estate with only four property owners since 1810 Stunning 4,872+/- sf home featuring 5-bedrooms with ensuite bathrooms, […]

c. 1966
  • Glen Ridge, New Jersey
  • $1,450,000

Exclusive Listing! Located in the “epicenter” of Glen Ridge and Montclair sits this one of a kind contemporary home with attached 800 square foot office (approx.), perfect for a small professional business owner looking to live and work at home. Office space could also be converted into additional living quarters – loads of potential with […]

c. 1790
  • Lopatcong Township, Phillipsburg, New Jersey
  • $3,500,000

Grow your dreams. So much potential here! Historic stone farmhouse, a ‘center-hall colonial,’ circa 1790s, has two large bedrooms and two baths, a large sitting room and dining room, and an original kitchen with a room above. The old kitchen’s stone fireplace has an 8-foot hearth, with original hardware and ovens. There is a three-bay […]

c. 1876
  • Jersey City, New Jersey
  • $1,625,000

This quintessential brownstone has undergone a  magnificent, and historically accurate restoration. Nec-Grec in style, it is sure to impress w/4 floors of living space + a lower level with full bath, sauna, and bonus room! In West Bergen/Lincoln Park Historic District. The garden level features a living room, dining room, & large modern eat-in kitchen […]

c. 1756
  • Washington Township, New Jersey
  • $400,000

“Aged to Perfection” WOW…1756 year built and still holding all the charm of yesteryear with modern upgrades to combine quality and convenience. The old gas stove in Kitchen is charming and 3 full baths are much preferred over the outhouse. Walk on the wonderful wide plank hard wood floors while watching your flat screen Tv’s. […]

c. 1902
  • Montclair, New Jersey
  • $1,900,000

Step inside this stunning mix of Mediterranean and old world charm inspired home. Original details flourish throughout this stunning home. From the great room to the peaceful serenity of the conservatory. This home is boasting with character. Listed for 1,900,000 by the Amy Owens Team. This home is definitely the showstopper on the street.

c. 1780
  • Bernards Township, New Jersey
  • $2,235,000

Seamlessly combining authentic historic charm and contemporary updates, a sophisticated Country Home dating back to 1780 was extensively renovated and expanded in 2011. Sited on 5.81 pastoral acres in Bernards Township, this cedar clapboard and fieldstone homestead was once part of a larger farm. While this home’s early American heritage is displayed throughout, it also […]

A stunning blend of vintage charm and modern amenities. Welcome Home to Main Street Woodstown. Stepping onto the wrap around porch, you are greeted by the original circa 1893 side-by-side entry doors (in the most amazing shade of teal) welcoming you into the foyer with a gorgeous chestnut staircase. To your left, slide open the […]

c. 1910
  • Glen Ridge, New Jersey
  • $979,000

Welcome to this stunning home meticulously renovated with a contemporary flair. A classic double door entry invites you into an open & airy layout allowing for seamless transitions between the spacious foyer and main first floor LR and adjacent office. Dining room w/custom bar & wine refrigerator. Renovated kitchen featuring a Wolf range, Subzero refrigerator, […]

c. 1797
  • Moorestown, New Jersey
  • $899,999

Built by Quakers in post-Revolutionary New Jersey, the Joshua Borton House was built on the site of a grist mill and has stood the test of time over two centuries.   In recent years, there have been significant upgrades and additions include a custom gourmet kitchen, in-ground pool, standalone garage with bonus room, expanded primary suite, […]

c. 1800
  • East Amwell Twp, New Jersey
  • $1,350,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Integrating heritage and modern design, this circa 1800 historic farmhouse was completely reinvented with a fabulous addition while still preserving the best of its old-world patina. The hub of the home is the open-plan kitchen and spacious family room in the new part of the house. A charming glass hall […]

c. 1895
  • Flemington, New Jersey
  • $649,999

Truly enchanting Queen Anne Style home exquisitely updated and maintained. Built in 1895, the character, unique architecture and master craftmanship define a warm and inviting atmosphere. 4 bedrooms, updated baths, SS appliances, granite kitchen countertops, tiled backsplash. Beautifully landscaped with plantings, perennials, a secret garden, 2 car garage, beautiful curved Palladian windows in the master […]

c. 1830
  • Blairstown, New Jersey
  • $475,000

Come home to this classic red farmhouse, set back amid rolling pastures; Fr Porch opens into LR/DR w/stone FP. EIK, Fam Rm, Off, 1/2 BA on first; 2nd: 3 BD, 1BA, 3rd:2 large rooms. Storage aplenty! Att. 2 car garage has stairs to upper level storage. Basement has large capacity indoor oil tank, utility & […]

c. 1785
  • Montville, New Jersey
  • $499,000

Charm & endless potential abound in this historic Victorian set on 1.69 acres. From the covered front porch welcome to the wide plank wood floors, soaring ceilings, unique archways & spacious rooms, the architectural details will capture your heart. Features include: LR w/fireplace & bay window inset; formal DR w/butlers pantry; powder rm & EIK […]

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.


Monthly Page Views


Combined Social Media Followers


Newsletter Subscribers

Compare listings

Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !