Search

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

A rare opportunity to own one of Kingston’s most historically significant residences, thoughtfully restored to blend timeless character with exceptional modern living. Dating to the mid 1800s and located within Kingston’s Historic District, this remarkable home has undergone an extensive renovation that preserves its architectural integrity while offering the comfort, technology, and craftsmanship expected in […]

c. 1888
  • Glen Ridge Boro Township, New Jersey
  • $1,595,000

Bathed in beautiful southwest light and set on a prominent corner lot, this remarkable 1888 Victorian farmhouse offers the perfect balance of historic charm, modern comfort, and an exceptional blend of indoor/outdoor living. Known for its appearance in more than twelve national commercials, the home is beloved for its gracious proportions, soaring 12ft ceilings, open […]

c. 1906
  • Mendham Township, New Jersey
  • $2,800,000

Known as ”Glenowre,” this distinguished 1906 south-facing Tudor estate offered for the first time in 50 years blends historic pedigree with refined modern living. Designed by noted Morristown architect Robert C. Walsh (Morris County Golf Club) for famed engineer Daniel E. Moran, the home reflects a rare level of architectural significance. Set on four private […]

c. 1830
  • Readington Township, New Jersey
  • $519,900

Step into timeless charm with this beautifully preserved historic home, perfectly positioned to capture breathtaking mountain views. Wide plank pumpkin pine floors flow seamlessly throughout the first and second levels, adding warmth and character to every room. The spacious living room invites relaxation with its cozy fireplace, while the dining room features a second fireplace […]

c. 1800
  • Mullica Hill, New Jersey
  • $965,000

Properties like this seldom come to market. The Jessup House is rich in history, beautifully reimagined, and ideally positioned on one of the most desirable streets in one of South Jersey’s most sought-after historic towns. This is more than a home — it is a legacy estate, designed to be cherished for generations. Set on […]

c. 1903
  • Orange, New Jersey
  • $1,150,000

Set on an extraordinary .84-acre corner parcel, 500 Berkeley Avenue is a distinguished estate where timeless grandeur, architectural pedigree, offers exceptional living. This remarkable 16-room mansion showcases the craftsmanship and design sensibilities of a bygone era, offering an increasingly rare opportunity to own one of Orange’s notable residences.From its commanding presence and stately proportions to […]

c. 1913
  • Montclair, New Jersey
  • $4,500,000

Introducing one of Montclair’s most extraordinary homes an impeccably restored 1913 Renaissance Revival masterpiece in the coveted Estate Section. Blending historic grandeur with modern luxury, this iconic home offers the elegance of a European villa just minutes from downtown Montclair. A breathtaking foyer with soaring ceilings, exquisite millwork, & a dramatic split staircase sets the […]

c. 1928
  • Glen Ridge, New Jersey
  • $699,000

Classic Glen Ridge charm meets everyday functionality in this beautifully maintained home, where original architectural details have been thoughtfully preserved and cared for over the years. Warm and inviting, the main level offers a spacious living room anchored by a fireplace, with an adjoining office area that creates a versatile and comfortable gathering space. A […]

c. 1956
  • West Orange, New Jersey
  • $1,299,000

THIS ONE-OF-A-KIND MIDCENTURY MODERN HOME IS UNLIKE ANYTHING YOU’LL FIND IN THE SOUGHT-AFTER GREGORY SECTION! Nestled within a private backyard that feels like a resort, enjoy the heated pool, bluestone terraces, a pergola-covered patio, built-in hot tub, treehouse, basketball, & even a tetherball court…a spectacular secluded oasis! As you step inside, the midcentury modern bones […]

Offered for the first time in decades, this extraordinary residence at 81 West Commerce Street in Bridgeton presents a rare opportunity to own a significant piece of architectural history. Held by only two families since the 1850s, the property thoughtfully balances preserved historic craftsmanship with meaningful modern enhancements throughout. Situated within Bridgeton’s Historic District and […]

c. 1927
  • Westfield, New Jersey
  • $2,695,000

Nestled on just under half an acre along one of the Gardens’ most coveted streets, this classic Center Hall Colonial effortlessly checks every box. A gracious foyer with a stunning open staircase welcomes you and is beautifully flanked by an elegant formal living room with fireplace and a spacious formal dining room. The updated kitchen, […]

c. 1927
  • Maplewood, New Jersey
  • $789,000

Thoughtfully updated and elegantly maintained, this pristine Colonial offers a rare blend of character, craftsmanship, and modern comfort – steps from Maplecrest Park and an easy train ride to NYC. The heart of 9 Amherst Court is the oversized, custom-renovated kitchen-intuitively structured with built-in stainless steel appliances, generous workspace, and seamless connection to the indoor […]

c. 1900
  • Maplewood, New Jersey
  • $1,550,000

Welcome to this Turn-of-the-century Victorian 4 Bed, 2.1 bath, just steps from downtown Maplewood Village & NYC trains. A welcoming wraparound porch sets the tone for this stunning home. The exterior is a gardeners delight with meticulously arranged plantings that bring seasonal color & privacy. Inside, a spacious entry boasts an elegant staircase w/ built-in […]

c. 1936
  • West Orange, New Jersey
  • $1,500,000

History & modern amenities meet in the picture-perfect Bamberger Estate, a luxurious English Tudor nestled among established landscaping on 1.7 acres & boasting all new construction interiors. Custom built for Louis Bamberger, founder of Bamberger’s department stores and sponsor of Albert Einstein’s entry into the United States, this bright, light, and airy 6 bed, 4.5 […]

A rare opportunity to own a Storybook Home in the beloved Gregory neighborhood!!! The perfect blend of historic character, modern updates, and exceptional space. Located at the South Orange border, this home combines craftsmanship, livability, and flexibility across multiple levels. Step inside to discover high ceilings, oversized windows, and beautifully refinished hardwood floors. The spacious […]

Experience the charm of small-town living in the heart of Califon, one of New Jersey’s most beloved river towns. Located within the National Register-listed historic district, 47 Main Street is a circa 1840 Victorian that once served as the town’s pharmacy and residence, reflecting the walkable village character that still defines the community today. Filled […]

c. 1925
  • Maplewood, New Jersey
  • $1,299,000

For the design-forward buyer craving soul, substance & story. Thoughtfully reimagined w/ a refined editorial eye, this 4-bedroom, 2.1-bath Colonial balances timeless architecture w/ deeply intentional, bespoke interiors that feel both elevated & entirely livable. Set on one of Maplewood’s most admired streets, this home unfolds in layers of warmth, texture & light. Original character […]

c. 1926
  • South Orange, New Jersey
  • $1,095,000

Perfectly marvelous Tudor offering timeless character, thoughtful updates, and stunning NYC skyline views. This 4-bedroom, 3.1-bath home blends classic architectural details with modern comfort, featuring newly refinished hardwood floors, beamed ceilings, charming stucco walls, central air, and abundant natural light throughout. The spacious kitchen/family room combination creates a true ”great room feel ideal for everyday […]

Set on one of the most beloved blocks in Maplewood’s coveted College Hill neighborhood, this cherished home is coming to market for the first time in over 50 years. Just moments from the Village, NYC trains, parks, and schools, it offers the perfect blend of timeless character, modern flow, and the kind of community people […]

c. 1907
  • Howell, New Jersey
  • $899,999

Welcome to 194 Fort Plains Road, a completely gut-renovated early 1900’s farmhouse where timeless charm meets today’s modern lifestyle. Zoned for Freehold Twp High School. From the moment you arrive, you are greeted by a long, tree-lined driveway leading to a gorgeous front porch that feels straight out of a magazine; the perfect place for […]

c. 1980
  • Flemington, New Jersey
  • $949,000

13 Hamden Road | Flemington, New Jersey A remarkable Colonial Williamsburg-inspired reproduction where timeless American craftsmanship and architectural authenticity have been beautifully preserved. Privately set among mature trees and manicured grounds, this distinguished residence was thoughtfully designed to honor the proportions, materials, and detailing associated with 18th-century Virginia architecture. From the beveled cedar siding and […]

c. 1762
  • Pilesgrove, New Jersey
  • $849,000

Welcome to Seven Stars Tavern — a rare opportunity to own an authentic piece of New Jersey’s colonial history. Built in 1762 and rich with Revolutionary-era significance, this extraordinary residence blends timeless architectural character with the warmth and charm of a true historic home. Once a landmark tavern along the King’s Highway, the property has […]

c. 1840
  • Chesterfield, New Jersey
  • $999,999

BUY THIS HOME, I WILL BUY YOURS! Park and ride! Take the train from Trenton directly to Penn Station NYC! A quick commute to the city for 45 Bordentown Crosswicks Rd! Work in the city and come home to your beautiful retreat to unwind! Welcome to 45 Bordentown Crosswicks Rd, an exquisite Italianate Victorian home […]

c. 1890
  • Mount Arlington, New Jersey
  • $999,000

Spectacular Queen Anne Victorian w/Seasonal Panoramic Lake Views Minutes to Lake Hopatcong! Step into timeless elegance with this one-of-a-kind Victorian known as the historic William Arnott House. This architecturally significant home offers a perfect blend of original charm and modern updates. The grand wrap-around porch welcomes you into a gracious entry foyer and exquisite grand […]

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

2m

Monthly Page Views

575k

Combined Social Media Followers

55k

Newsletter Subscribers