Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

Old Houses for Sale in New Jersey

Come see the historic home that inspired Thornton Wilder’s Pulitzer Prize-winning play Our Town! Situated in the heart of Moorestown, this 6,036 Sq. Ft. magnificent colonial, built in 1923, has been masterfully restored and updated to reflect today’s modern living while maintaining its original elegance and character. Nestled on .91 acres, this impeccably maintained corner […]

c. 1845
  • Sussex, New Jersey
  • $375,000

Curb appeal! Lovely c.1845 Center Hall Colonial at the entrance to private Lake Windsor. Farmhouse with 4 BRs & lake rights on a dead-end street. Hardwood and wide plank floors, spacious rooms, LR fireplace, stained glass windows. BONUS Rm/In-Law Suite over garage w/separate entrance, full bath, kitchenette, and separate heating zone. Baseboard oil heat (new […]

c. 1820
  • Parsippany, New Jersey
  • $600,000

A unique property, a jewel in move-in condition with great potential for expansion. This beautiful 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath, two-story historic house with original features and modern amenities includes a two-story barn! Dining room ca. 1820 with hand-hewn beams and fireplace. Original wide-plank floorboards throughout house. Full eat-in kitchen with stainless steel appliances, central air-conditioning […]

c. 1930
  • Clifton, New Jersey
  • $575,000

Center Hall Colonial with great curb appeal in a desirable section of Clifton conveniently located near NYC transportation! Greet your guests in the entry foyer with original stained glass windows leading to the formal living room and dining room. This home offers high ceilings with original crown molding and doors with glass knobs giving the […]

c. 1880
  • Watchung, New Jersey
  • $900,000

An expansive covered front porch invites you into this stunning Victorian that has been renovated to perfection, maintaining its historic charm while offering modern day conveniences & luxuries. Highlights include high ceilings, gorgeous wood moldings & hardwood floors. 1st floor includes formal dining room & living room with fireplace. The gourmet kitchen boasts a center […]

Totally renovated in 2006 by Merrick Construction, this beautiful custom home is located in one of the most sought after locations close to local beaches, schools & town center with great restaurants & shopping. Spectacular connoisseur kitchen was renovated in 2006 by Creative Kitchens with large island, double Subzero refrigerators, tile floor, Wolf double oven, […]

c. 1740
  • Mountainside, New Jersey
  • $475,000

Introducing the 1700’s Crane House – a historic four-bedroom 1.5 bath Mountainside gem perfectly showcasing the character of yesteryear and paired with the amenities and conveniences of today. Antique charm of hand hewn beams,wide plank floors & ornate molding throughout.Formal sitting rm boasts gas fireplace,ample space & plantation shutters.Dining room has exposed hand notched beams,carved […]

c. 1880
  • Harrington Park, New Jersey
  • $1,050,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Situated in historic Harrington Park, New Jersey, the warmth and charm of this elegant home reveals itself the moment you step foot on to the lush and meticulously manicured property. The property size is approximately 169’ x 159’. Relaxing front porches face the original water well which is a delightful […]

c. 1890
  • Jersey City, New Jersey
  • $874,000

Historic Charm meets Modern Chic in this spectacular, fully renovated, townhouse. Past double parlors with antique pocket doors, your gorgeous kitchen is a chef’s dream! Marble counters continue onto your backsplash and waterfall peninsula. Custom ceiling height cabinets provide ample storage, while an Italian Bertazzoni stove and Sub Zero refrigerator let you prep in style. […]

c. 1860
  • Long Valley, New Jersey
  • $489,900

Iconic, Historical Schoolhouse in Long Valley! This home is located on almost an acre in with public water and public sewer. This nationally and state registered home has been transformed through the years. This home has been rehabbed & remodeled to fit in with todays modern amenities w/ 3 bedrooms & 2.5 bathrooms. Retention of […]

c. 1895
  • Flemington, New Jersey
  • $649,999

Truly enchanting Queen Anne Style home exquisitely updated and maintained. Built in 1895, the character, unique architecture and master craftmanship define a warm and inviting atmosphere. 4 bedrooms, updated baths, SS appliances, granite kitchen countertops, tiled backsplash. Beautifully landscaped with plantings, perennials, a secret garden, 2 car garage, beautiful curved Palladian windows in the master […]

c. 1781
  • White Township, New Jersey
  • $499,000

Original stone house built by early settler John Axford. Situated near the Pequest River and adjacent to state preservation land. Country Kitchen with dining area plus fireplace, formal dining room with original stone wall and radiant heated floor. Open living room and family room both with fireplaces and original wide plank floors. Beamed ceilings throughout […]

Outstanding country retreat located in the attractive and historic village of Mauricetown. This scenic area is located close to Cape May Beaches and within an hour’s commute to Philadelphia with easy access to the Garden State Parkway. This Victorian beauty has been carefully and meticulously remodeled, expanded, upgraded and updated both inside and out. Surfaces […]

c. 1782
  • Westwood, New Jersey
  • $899,000

When history juxtaposed against modern refinement embodies artistic synergy, a masterpiece is reimagined. The Westervelt House is ranked among the finest Greek Revival homes in Bergen County. The beginnings of this property date back to the late 1700s rich with storried family roots deep in the founding of Bergen County and Westwood. Walking through the […]

c. 1830
  • Blairstown, New Jersey
  • $475,000

Come home to this classic red farmhouse, set back amid rolling pastures; Fr Porch opens into LR/DR w/stone FP. EIK, Fam Rm, Off, 1/2 BA on first; 2nd: 3 BD, 1BA, 3rd:2 large rooms. Storage aplenty! Att. 2 car garage has stairs to upper level storage. Basement has large capacity indoor oil tank, utility & […]

c. 1790
  • Blairstown, New Jersey
  • $450,000

Welcome Home! Every once in awhile, but not very often, a beautiful Circa 1800’s colonial home hits the market in Blairstown Twp. in Warren County, NJ. This is your opportunity! Own a piece of history and enjoy this quiet, country location in all 4 beautiful seasons in the Skylands of Northwestern, NJ. Set on 2.58 […]

c. 1785
  • Montville, New Jersey
  • $499,000

Charm & endless potential abound in this historic Victorian set on 1.69 acres. From the covered front porch welcome to the wide plank wood floors, soaring ceilings, unique archways & spacious rooms, the architectural details will capture your heart. Features include: LR w/fireplace & bay window inset; formal DR w/butlers pantry; powder rm & EIK […]

c. 1720
  • Fredon Township, New Jersey
  • $525,000

Vintage property renovated in 2013 and currently “The Hummingbird House” serving breakfast & lunch. A unique dining experience in the several quaint rooms plus a banquet room for 50. The building & equipment are inclusive w/an immaculate kitchen w/6 burner gas stove, flat top griddle, panini press, Salamander broiler, 2 gas ovens, char grill, dual […]

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

Not Your Grandmother’s Old House.

List an Old House for Sale in NJ

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.


Monthly Page Views


Combined Social Media Followers


Newsletter Subscribers

Compare listings

Follow us @cheapoldhouses + launching on HGTV & Discovery+, Monday, August 9th at 9pm ET