Old Houses for Sale in Indiana

Old Houses for Sale in Indiana

c. 1928
  • Crown Point, Indiana
  • $550,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Iconic, all-brick two story home, known locally as “the Little Castle House”. Built c. 1928, reportedly initially owned by a prominent local baker. Norman Revival with Tudor influences. Features a classic steep roof with round turret. Terra cotta tile in the foyer features original zodiac symbols. A grand spiral staircase […]

c. 1869
  • Lagrange, Indiana
  • $275,000

Turn of the Century, beautifully decorated throughout and operating now as a Bed & Breakfast but can be purchased as a personal home with 5 Suites that all have private bathrooms. As you enter the 1869 Colonial you are transported back in time with all of the beautiful antiques and mementos from the owners collection […]

c. 1883
  • Knightstown, Indiana
  • $225,000

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Own a piece of Knightstown history! This beautiful Italianate 3 bd/2ba historical home is in the heart of Knightstown The orig. portion of the home built prior to 1860 w/additions in 1866 & 1883, per house abstract Current owners have meticulously preserved the history in the home by keeping original […]

c. 1929
  • Michigan City, Indiana
  • $949,900

Watch the Virtual Tour here! Fit for Royalty! This historic gem in the highly sought after Edgewood neighborhood has been fully restored with meticulous detail! Over 7, 500 Sq Ft (combined) includes approx. 2, 023 Sq Ft Basement and an amazing Attic space with approx. 1, 800 Sq Ft that has 9 to 16 Ft […]

c. 1924
  • Indianapolis, Indiana
  • $589,000

Do not miss this wonderful opportunity in the heart of Meridian-Kessler! A very well cared for 4-bedroom & 2.5 bath home on a fabulous corner lot. Built in 1924 this all brick home is loaded with charm & has gorgeous restored leaded glass windows. An updated bright kitchen with white cabinets, granite countertops, newer appliances […]

c. 1855
  • Williamsport, Indiana
  • $75,000

Nestled in the quiet Old Town neighborhood of historic Williamsport, Indiana, the 1855 Hitchens House is a beloved landmark situated on over an acre of land with expansive lawn. Constructed for prominent local business leader Elisha Hitchens and his wife, Mary, the impressive two-story brick Italianate is the surviving mirrored identical twin to a house […]

c. 1910
  • Hudson, Indiana
  • $295,000

Truly one of a kind living in this historic converted church. Originally a Methodist Church, this amazing transformation from church to a very livable home has taken all the best features of a church structure and folded them into a gorgeous modern style home! As you can imagine being a church conversion, the design has […]

c. 1926
  • Indianapolis, Indiana
  • $2,000,000

Privately situated on the most iconic street in Indianapolis, this stately home offers incredible architecture, styling, privacy, and gracious living spaces for the most discerning buyer. Impeccably maintained and thoughtfully renovated, 5008 boasts five bedrooms, five and a half bathrooms, a newly finished basement, and 1.34 acres of lush outdoor living space (don’t miss the […]

This unique cabin built with hand hewn oak and poplar old-growth logs originally harvested in the 1840’s, sits above Indian-Kentuck Creek on 39.16 acres minutes from historic Madison, Indiana. Custom built from a “dog trot” log cabin and a stick-built frame addition, this home has all modern amenities and antique charm.  With large open rooms […]

All the Cool Kids are Doing it.

List an Old House for Sale in IN

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.

All The Cool Kids Are Doing It.

List an Old House for Sale in IN

Listing on CIRCA exposes your property to a large niche group of people who are specifically looking to purchase an old house.


Monthly Page Views


Combined Social Media Followers


Newsletter Subscribers

Compare listings

Follow us @cheapoldhouses + launching on HGTV & Discovery+, Monday, August 9th at 9pm ET