Welcome Home to Sunset Lane!

5715 Sunset Lane presents an extraordinary opportunity on one of Indianapolis’ most private and prestigious streets. Built in 1957 for the family behind Wonder Bread, this iconic Georgian Colonial is set on nearly two acres of beautifully landscaped grounds enhanced by mature trees and a striking fountain. Originally envisioned by renowned architect Warren Rindge, the residence has been shaped over decades by thoughtful expansions. This includes a massive 1996 South Wing addition by Richard Wood (former CEO of Eli Lilly & Co.) and Billie Lou Wood. Designed by celebrated architect Jonathan Hess—noted for the Eiteljorg Museum, Newfields, and other cultural landmarks—and built by premier commercial contractor Wilhelm, this addition resulted in a estate of rare scale, elegance, and distinction. Notably, the property’s stunning grounds were recognized in the Smithsonian Institution’s Archives of American Gardens, while the hand-carved woodwork in the Loggia, crafted by master artisan P.K. Smith, beautifully represents the four seasons in the intricate style of English master carver Grinling Gibbons. A slate roof, copper gutters, and hand-forged bricks from Williamsburg, Virginia, anchor its stately presence.

Recently transformed through a meticulous renovation, the residence flawlessly blends timeless craftsmanship with sophisticated design for today’s lifestyle. Six restored fireplaces, a new copper-domed roof, and refined trim work preserve its historic elegance, while strategic walls were opened to create a seamless entertaining space. This flow is anchored by a custom kitchen featuring Fahrenbacher cabinetry, a Thermador appliance suite, and quartzite countertops. The reimagined primary suite showcases a spa-inspired bath with heated floors and a new closet with main-level laundry. Enhancements continue with a new main-level bedroom suite, a media room, a wellness room with a hybrid sauna, Control4 automation, Sonos sound, upgraded security, and five new furnaces. The South Wing introduces a light-filled tea room, private offices, and elevator access. Outside, expansive windows overlook refreshed landscaping, museum-quality gardens, and the iconic fountain, making indoor-outdoor entertaining effortless. This is a rare combination of history, craftsmanship, and modern luxury. Welcome home to Sunset Lane!