Old Stone Houses for Sale

Old Stone Houses for Sale

They’re All We’ve Ever Wanted.

Papa was a rolling stone … wherever he laid his hat sprang a glorious STONE HOUSE! This time, we’re going old. Really, really old. Old as in simpler times, when evenings were candlelit and winters spent curled up by the hearth. We’ll never lose our appetite for stone houses, nor the romantic nostalgia that they bear. Rustic fireplaces? Check! Smoke houses? Check! Wide open spaces? It’s all here. Take a peek.

c. 1800
  • Cornwall, New York
  • $1,199,000

Welcome to the Carvey-Gatfield house, a stunning c. 1800 Federal style farmhouse nestled in the charming town of Cornwall, NY. Steeped in history and listed on the National Register, this remarkable property boasts not only a immaculately and thoughtfully preserved main house but also two one-bedroom cottages and a spacious two-story barn with endless potential. […]

Situated at the southeast corner of the old Barker tract, this L-shaped stone farmhouse has passed through very few owners since the late 1700s. Many original features are intact. The c.1820 addition contains a straight staircase as well as a big walk-in stone fireplace. Seven doors give access to this house, with a covered front […]

c. 1890
  • Cincinnati, Ohio
  • $2,850,000

This 1890 gilded age mansion is located near the inner city where its value is depreciated in its urban environment and the economics of maintaining it on its current site are prohibitive. It can be disassembled and moved to a complementary setting permanently preserving the beauty of this historic architecture. James W. McLaughlin was one of […]

c. 1700
  • Fredericktown, Pennsylvania
  • $1,650,000

One of the oldest homes in Western Pennsylvania with some of the most gorgeous acreage by far, Green Land Farm has grown in three sections from the eighteenth to the twentieth centuries, with the original section said to date back to the late 1760s. This one-of-a-kind 108+ acre farm with its beautiful CIRCA Colonial Quaker […]

c. 1723
  • Glen Mills, Pennsylvania
  • $1,425,000

Welcome to 1639 East Street Road, also known as Brooznoll, meaning “Breezy Knoll”. T tranquil oasis is set on a gorgeous 1+/- acre lot in the rolling hills of Chester County. Th home was built in approximately 1723, and has been lovingly updated for today’s lifesty historic home was featured a few years ago on […]

The story of the Mackay home mirrors the story of early Denver, and the experiences of the family who called this Scottish manor house “home” nostalgically reflect the lives of today’s Potter Highlands neighbors. Built in 1891 by Scottish mining engineer Hugh Mackay, this iconic stone house was a wedding present to woo his love, […]

One Hour from Albany NY. Designated National and State Historic site, a complete package of 5 Separate buildings: The Stone Grist Mill, The Mill House(1682 Mill Rd), The Hog’n House Cottage, Barn, and Carriage House. The Grist Mill was finished in 1835 with the stone sourced from the site. Interior is part Museum, Luxury Kitchen, […]

c. 1770
  • North Caldwell, New Jersey
  • $1,575,000

Unique opportunity to own historic 1770’s Colonial estate reconstructed to fit today’s lifestyle. Expansive 4 Bedroom, 2.1 Bath home, Pool and 2 more buildings – stunning and inspiring Artist’s Studio with Powder Room, Pool, Large Carriage House/Garage with pool guest Powder Room and upstairs Studio Apartment all on beautifully landscaped 1.46 acres.

c. 1713
  • Clarkstown, New York
  • $3,000,000

Nestled ON 32 ACRES sits a sandstone Dutch ranch. A true testament to history & craftsmanship. This remarkable home, known as the Peter Depew House, has heritage dating back to the 1700s. With it’s meticulously preserved exterior & thoughtful renovations completed in 2023, it honors its storied past, this residence stands as a timeless treasure. […]

c. 1915
  • Glenside, Pennsylvania
  • $1,800,000

Designed and built by renowned architect John Graham, JR in 1915,“The Orchard” is a great American house. This classic 8,645 sqft Colonial Revival estate was built in 1916 for the Wetherill family on almost 2 acres. The pedigree of this architectural masterpiece has been documented in Town & Country magazine’s June 1919 edition and the […]

c. 1754
  • Springfield, Pennsylvania
  • $719,900

It’s time for yet another one of my Magical History Tours! And today, we take you to Springfield Township (in Delaware County, not Montgomery, not Bucks and not any of the other ones that are in PA or NJ!). Springfield as a distinct entity did not first exist when the Penn land grants were sold. […]

c. 1725
  • Mickleton, New Jersey
  • $776,500

Welcome to 522 Kings Hwy – It is rare when such a property becomes available, offering 21st century comfort and conveniences, wrapped in the elegant charm and superior workmanship of the 18th and early 19th centuries. This elegant grand stone manor house including four outbuildings is also known as the ‘Bodo Otto’ or ‘Tonkin’ house- […]

Compare listings

Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !