Converted Houses for Sale

Converted Churches, Lighthouses & Other Unconventional Houses for Sale

Because Boring Houses Rarely Make History.

Normalcy is SO overrated. And who ever said a house had to be a house, anyway? Get quirky living in a converted lighthouse, an old mill, or a church reborn as a big, old mansion. Now THAT’s making a STATEMENT.

Welcome to 547 Concord Road, which has stood proudly as one of the earliest homes built in Pennsylvania and served many uses in the community both before and after the Revolutionary War. Situated within the Garnet Valley School District, this home was built in 1695 and owned by Col. John Hannum, a politician, businessman, and […]

c. 1888
  • Mendocino, California
  • $3,095,000

Purchased as “fixer” in the Mendocino Village in 2001, what followed was a multi-year labor of love to restore and preserve the historic Bettencourt House and Water Tower Barn. Arguably one of finest locations on the coveted western edge of the village of Mendocino, this compound offers stunning, unobstructed, 180-degree views of the bay and […]

Welcome to Potter Mountain House, a masterfully reimagined Greek Revival church turned luxury designer estate. The original timber-framed structure was constructed in 1837 as the Manorkill Methodist Church, serving its community for over a century before being carefully dismantled and relocated to its current site in Gilboa, NY. Now sited on 37 acres with sweeping […]

c. 1911
  • Alma, Nebraska
  • $349,500

Be a part of history in Alma, Nebraska, with this one-of-a-kind Carnegie Library turned private residence—listed on the National Register of Historic Places! Boasting over 4,000 square feet of finished living space, this home seamlessly blends timeless architecture with modern comfort. Inside, you’ll find 4 spacious bedrooms, 3 beautifully finished bathrooms, and a main level […]

c. 1925
  • Hackettstown, New Jersey
  • $349,000

This incredibly unique and airy loft-like home was originally constructed in 1925 as a worship building before being converted to a private residence, and retains the best of those qualities- 14’ ceilings, large windows, open floor plan, a mezzanine that could be used as a library or second bedroom, and a massive walkout basement (approx. […]

c. 1920
  • Franklinville, New York
  • $375,000

Step into a breathtaking fusion of history and modern luxury. This extraordinary 8-bedroom home is a fully restored and reimagined historic church, now a grand private residence with unmatched character and elegance. Every detail has been thoughtfully preserved and enhanced to create a truly one-of-a-kind living experience. At the heart of the home is the […]

c. 1900
  • Riegelsville, Pennsylvania
  • $4,450,000

The very essence of a Bucks County gentleman’s estate is evidenced at first approach…turning off a quintessential country road, meandering down a long, tree-lined drive, all surrounded by breathtaking views of the Durham countryside that include long distance vistas over the Delaware River Valley. Sequestered on 90 acres, the setting is a unique and timeless […]

c. 1940
  • New Concord, Kentucky
  • $190,000

Serenity awaits. This remodeled cottage, nestled among mature trees and adjacent to a National forest, offers updated finishes and historic charm. Located just a short stroll away from Kentucky Lake and Missing Hill Resort, with Cypress Springs Marina and Restaurant just a mile away, this lovely cottage offers a place to relax in a wooded […]

c. 1850
  • Galisteo, New Mexico
  • $1,025,000

This historic Hacienda embodies the essence of old-world New Mexico charm and a true Galisteo history with the spirit of this old adobe reflecting the lore, legend and mystery of the Galisteo Basin. Beginning in the 1800s this was the Headquarters of Don Jose Ortiz y Pino’s sheep empire – a gathering place, a general […]

c. 1930
  • Waite Hill, Ohio
  • $4,500,000

 Set across 27 sweeping acres in prestigious Waite Hill, 9391 Hobart Road is more than a home—it’s a lifestyle compound with limitless possibilities. Gated and grand, the English Country Estate unfolds from a genteel cobblestone courtyard into a private world of historical allure, architectural richness and pastoral beauty. At the heart of the estate is […]

c. 1802
  • Easton, Pennsylvania
  • $1,100,000

Nestled on just over an acre (1.12 acres – 2 tax lots) in Palmer Township, PA, 109 S Greenwood Avenue presents an exceptional opportunity to own a fully restored country stone barn, originally built in 1802 and completely reimagined over two years (2022-2023). The estate blends historic charm with modern luxury, featuring formal gardens, mature […]

Click Here for Property Flyer! Click Here for List of Renovations! Click Here for More History of Property! Historic Remodeled Timeless 4458 Sq Ft Residence with 5 Bedrooms, 4.5 Baths and off-street parking with beautiful gardens located in Historic Downtown Charleston. Own a RARE piece of Charleston’s past, modernized for todays lifestyle. Where Southern history […]

Compare listings

Compare
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
SUBSCRIBE
Have the most beautiful old houses on the market
delivered to your inbox every single week!

Enter your email below to receive our latest listings,
featured favorites and more !
SUBSCRIBE