Rare Cooperstown Beauty

  • $725,000
4 Prospect Place, Cooperstown, Otsego County, New York, 13326, United States
For Sale

Rare Cooperstown Beauty

4 Prospect Place, Cooperstown, Otsego County, New York, 13326, United States
  • $725,000


Watch the Virtual Tour here!

1912 Rare Historical Beauty! This 5 bedroom, 4.5 bathroom home is located on a little-traveled, desirable, quiet street in the Village of Cooperstown. Upon entering the home, one gets a sense of Old World Style, which will maintain its timeless and elegant appeal for many years to come. This beautiful home is heavily influenced by the French heritage of the owners who carefully assembled the decor and designed the space over the last 56 years. A graceful, generous sized dining room features a wood-burning fireplace and large windows that provide abundant natural light throughout the day. Off the dining room, a large cathedral-arched door opens into the living room where you are greeted with cathedral ceilings. This special room has held the family’s 20′ Christmas tree each holiday season over the years. A large fireplace anchors this room. There is an inviting little nook in one corner of the room, under a beautiful Palladian window overlooking the courtyard garden. Beyond the living room is a bright first-floor master bedroom with a 3/4 bathroom, double closets, and a picture window that looks out upon the garden in the backyard. The wood paneled library has a majestic, traditional feel, boasting floor to ceiling bookshelves, a window seat that looks out to the garden, and a built-in couch, creating the perfect place for contemplative reading time. The owners transformed the eat-in kitchen into a European-style kitchen with French charm. Off the kitchen is the original butler’s pantry, which provides abundant storage, sink, and prep space. As one moves upstairs, there is a door off the landing; this door opens onto a balcony overlooking the living room. Upstairs are four good-sized bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and another half bath. The owners designed one of the bedrooms after returning from a trip to North Africa in the 1970s; the “Tunisian Bedroom” is distinguished by exposed wood beams, a small alcove to hold books, stucco walls, and a half bath. All of the bedrooms have good-sized closets. Down the hall, you will find an art studio/office and a summer sleeping porch. The back staircase leads down to the kitchen. There is an attached one-car garage that opens into the mudroom/laundry room and a 3/4 bathroom. The enchanting courtyard garden is secluded by a tall hedge of trees and includes a patio, laid stone walls, perennial flower beds, and a koi pond; all combine to create a delightful space for entertaining. This area is fully enclosed by a timber fence assembled by the owner. Beyond the fence is a great open area for play. This impressive residence sits less than a block from the southern shore of Otsego Lake. It is around the corner from the Otesaga Resort Hotel and the legendary Leatherstocking Golf Course. Walking distance to the Fenimore Museum. One block to Cooperstown’s Main Street restaurants and shops.


Property ID
Square Footage
Lot Size
Year Built
Dutch Colonial
Updated on August 12, 2021 at 12:16 pm


  • Address 4 Prospect Place, Cooperstown, Otsego County, New York, 13326, United States
  • City Cooperstown
  • State New York
  • Zip/Postal Code 13326

Contact Agent

Amy Stack
View Listings


­čô║ Mondays 9:00 + 9:30pm ET 9:00pm EST
9:00pm EST

Similar Listings

Compare listings

Amy Stack
  • Amy Stack