Nestled in the quiet Old Town neighborhood of historic Williamsport, Indiana, the 1855 Hitchens House is a beloved landmark situated on over an acre of land with expansive lawn. Constructed for prominent local business leader Elisha Hitchens and his wife, Mary, the impressive two-story brick Italianate is the surviving mirrored identical twin to a house built next door by their daughter & son-in-law, Sarah & William Kent. Dominating the exterior of the house is the three-story tower uniquely rotated 45 degrees. Other original exterior features include the broad bracketed cornice, tall paired and tripled windows, and sandstone window hoods, sills, and front porch, which match the foundation.

The large enclosed west porch, an early twentieth century addition, now serves as the main entry into the first-floor public spaces. The entry foyer, living room, dining room, and 1st-floor bedroom all feature 11-foot ceilings and original wide crown molding. A slight interior remodel at the turn of the twentieth century added quarter-sawn oak flooring and Neoclassical touches such as a columned fireplace surround in the living room, decorative classical trim in the dining room, and wide openings between spaces. Off the dining room are the main service areas including the kitchen, a ¾ bath, a laundry/mud room, and large storage room with basement access. Located off the laundry/mud room is an attached one-car drive-thru garage not currently accessible from the property’s main drive.

Perhaps the most stunning interior feature is the original spiral staircase curving gracefully from the first floor to the top of the three-story tower where one gains a birds-eye view of the surrounding neighborhood and beyond. The main stairway and rear servant stairs provide access to four second-floor bedrooms and a sleeping porch. The bedrooms all feature 10-foot ceilings, hardwood floors, and abundant natural light. An unfinished full bath is also found on the second floor.

The property will be sold as-is with Indiana Landmarks’ protective covenants attached to the deed to ensure long-term preservation. Proof of financing may be requested before a showing will be scheduled.


Property ID
Square Footage
2700 sqft
Lot Size
1.2 acres
Year Built
Updated on May 20, 2021 at 4:47 pm


  • Address 303 Lincoln St.
  • City Williamsport
  • State Indiana
  • Zip/Postal Code 47993
  • Country United States

Contact Agent

Tommy Kleckner
View Listings

Similar Listings

Compare listings

Tommy Kleckner
  • Tommy Kleckner