Compare Listings

My Dream Fixer-Upper is in Stony Point, New York

My Dream Fixer-Upper is in Stony Point, New York

by Elizabeth Finkelstein

My amazing friend Ariana, who also happens to be an incredible photographer with a discerning eye for beautiful things, sent me the link to this fixer-upper in Stony Point, NY. It’s Meet Me in St. Louis meets It’s a Wonderful Life and has a storied history as home to some pretty big stars of the creative industry. I can never pass up a good mansard roof, so thought I’d take the time to share this phenomenal home. Oh, and hey, while we’re on the topic — YOU SHOULD BUY IT!


168 Filors Lane, Stony Point, NY

Asking Price $399,000
THE GLAMOUR OF A NEWPORT MANSION MEETS BROADWAY & THE ARTS – Stony Point, Circa 1850. Imagine… Brick Baron James Garner built this French Maison with double brick construction, River Views & a 2 Story Barn, on a separate included deeded lot (3 Ewald Pl). Steeped in history with a flair of show business of the 20s, came Rollo Peters of NYC Theatre fame as the next owner. Through the passage of time, new owners Bill Golden (designed the famous CBS Eye) & wife Cipe Pineles (Art Dir., Vogue Magazine), added to this avalanche of splendor, mystique & character, “purging the house of frivolous aspects.” The Goldens remodeled & redecorated in “good judgement & taste,” in their eclectic style, creating more of a “Paris Manoir Romantique.” This home served as a stage for occasions that were memorable for everyone. While living here will definitely inspire the new ownership to creatively restore the faded patina of the past, this is truly a home that one can’t duplicate today, 40 mins to NYC…
For more information, visit the full listing over at William Raveis Baer & McIntosh (and thank you to Old House Dreams for finding this diamond in the rough)

Elizabeth is the founder of CIRCA and a practicing writer, architectural historian and preservation consultant living in Nyack, NY. Elizabeth has loved historic houses for as long as she can remember, having grown up in an 1850’s Greek Revival gem that was lovingly restored by her parents. Elizabeth, her husband Ethan and their beagle Banjo remain on a relentless hunt for their perfect “Thanksgiving house.”

Related posts

This Mansion is Mahhhhvelous!

This 28 room mansion is *surprise* good 'til the last room. The entryway is all stained glass and...

Continue reading

This Turkish Room is Unexpected and Legendary

I could write a novel about the McNally Estate. Our very own Cristiana Pena visited this beauty...

Continue reading

Luxe Victorian Styled California Cool

I know, I know. We hear it a lot, don't we? "Charm of Yesteryear with Modern Conveniences!"...

Continue reading

One thought on “My Dream Fixer-Upper is in Stony Point, New York”

  • karlandmeganscott

    June 12, 2019 at 2:03 am

    How do I make this a favorite home? I am in love with this hom, doesn’t hurt that it was built by a Garner (my maiden name is Garner – family is from Tennessee). I would buy this in a heartbeat if I had the money to fix her up!

Join The Discussion